My Esteemed Colleagues - Pilot

GameSpot's editors know a thing or two about long-winded pontifications proclaiming [enter game here] as better than [enter game here]. Civilized battle royale time? You betcha!

Discussion

231 comments
Freezeryder
Freezeryder

This is why I re-love Gamespot. These guys know their gaming, and don't mind the debate getting heated and complex at times. IGN's highschool approach and Giantbombs "let's just laugh at the flaws" style just doesn't have that. (Disclaimer: I realize there are more to the aforementioned sites than that, but put on yer recklessly generalizing hat and perhaps you can see where I'm coming from ;-))

Chris_Watters
Chris_Watters staff

@ChewieOnIce New episode posting on Monday!

ChewieOnIce
ChewieOnIce

@Magrino @shaunmc @Chris_Watters @TomMcShea @KevinV More 'My Esteemed Colleagues'!!! That is all.

DKant
DKant

@Magrino, lol. :P Past few weeks have been crazy work-wise and I've actually come ONLINE again only today. Geez.

JusticeCovert
JusticeCovert

@Toysoldier34: No worries :) If you check out the site at www.metaga.me they actually just announced their first expansion pack.

okami5436
okami5436

The DK guy is Billy Mitchell, Billy Dee Williams played Lando in Star Wars x|

Toysoldier34
Toysoldier34

@JusticeCovert Alright thanks for the info. I was planning on buying maybe two decks if they were different, but if they are the same I can just get one and keep an eye out for additional decks as they release.

max-Emadness
max-Emadness

@shaunmc sorry about that just a spelling mistake. and i didnt mean any offense with my comment. i merely believe that everything you do even if affected outside stimuli is a decision you make. The events that occur might be random but ur decisions and the way you deal with them are not. im sorry if i offended you.

prostar343
prostar343

haha Pretty funny. Hope you guys continue with this.

Silos911
Silos911

This is awesome, and in the spirit of arguing in metagame I will provide a short argument why it's great. The main reasons is that this is entertaining for many audiences and it is eduactional. For people who know a lot about the game industry, we understand the games you are talking about and we can find joy in your struggles to make hard arguments for games. For people who don't know about the game industry, they will be baffled at the thought and existence of some of these games but find it enjoyable at the weird arguments the panel makes. They will become intrigued and look up the games after the show. Finally it is educational. Many people wouldn't know there's a boxing kangaroo in Tekken. Others may not know about the existence of Scribblenauts. Or maybe you will just be interested in how you can debate games that are taken out of their usual genre or descriptive words. Anyway, great show Gamespot, keep up the great work.

sonynhater
sonynhater

Nothing is random according to everyone in the video.

Chris_Watters
Chris_Watters staff

@sidh9u5 We didn't forget, we just have to argue for the game on the card we're dealt. If I had my choice, I certainly wouldn't have picked Pong for most open-ended!

DrAmazinDood
DrAmazinDood

little kid mode ON: ball physics *giggle* :P

sidh9u5
sidh9u5

nice show.... btw everyone forgot braid in the "Most Complex Game Round" or something??

rvgarafola
rvgarafola

windwaker was amazing.... I don't know why people hate it so much (or well at least the people who do hate it?)

malitm
malitm

OMG 30 min of my life that i will never get back...

CrackSnack
CrackSnack

Awesome! Include the uk staff, and this would be perfect!

bernstein1986
bernstein1986

Good stuff guys. Keep them coming and I will continue to watch. Perfect length! Filled up my whole lunch break.

_Judas_
_Judas_

I didn't know Lando played Donkey Kong

shaunmc
shaunmc moderator staff

@max-Emadness I disagree with your spelling of my last name.

max-Emadness
max-Emadness

i really disagree with shaun mckinnis's view on the human mind

pepsicon
pepsicon

omg vanord with angry birds for most open ended game is just hilarious XDDDD

austrato
austrato

great show folks! i'm following.

MN121MN
MN121MN

Nice show "I didn't make the card" 10:11 Then who did?

jamesbigmac
jamesbigmac

Awesome show guys! Definitely going to look forward to the next episodes.

Evtutchenk0
Evtutchenk0

and like HipHopBeats said, a GS US vs GS UK would be quite interesting

koolkat14
koolkat14

Great show guys, hope we can see some more episodes.

ragnar320
ragnar320

well i love this i actually busted up laughing throughout the whole show. and for the final round Shawn is completely right he is a genius because the human expirence is completely random shawn man have been born be china or russia or south africa or brazil but no shawn was born where ever he was born and thus lead to his experience on this show which resulted in his unique choices for scrible notes based solely on his random existence. The only guy who knows what shawn gonna do (if you believe in him and i think tom does) is god so that proves he is random so HA beat that guys

Unfallen_Satan
Unfallen_Satan

Lol. Hilarious. I love these guys. I am going download this and listen to it when I have to do some dry errand to lighten up my day.

MornaFanyare
MornaFanyare

This was a lot of fun to watch. While I love the silliness of the Hotspot podcast, I also like it when the panel dives into a more academic discussion of games and gaming. This was a nice balance that the Hotspot used to have, that I feel for some reason was missing the last few episodes. Hope to see another of these at some point.

Master_ShakeXXX
Master_ShakeXXX

This was very entertaining. I hope it continues for a while and can't wait for next week's episode. Chris was certainly the standout and he seems to have a natural gift for this type of debating. The other three gave noble efforts though. And big props to Kevin V. His argument for Angry Birds was freakin hilarious. And ignore the haters, Tom. You were fine. They're just InFamous 2 and Zelda fans no doubt.

Devils-DIVISION
Devils-DIVISION

@Vince21C No need for a pause. It's true! Actually Maxwell McGee is his name.

g1rldraco7
g1rldraco7

I love this show and I hope there will be more episodes.