Discussion

52 comments
JustClient
JustClient

I could of known what games my kid plays. It's parents' responsibility. If adult mentally healthy there is no game in this world affect him(her). So I think it's just another way to get some political points for the government in the end.

nabed4t
nabed4t

Evan, mate, you can't generalise like that. Myself being an adult gamer feel the frustration that many other Australian gamers feel, the fact that the ratings board wont put out an R rated classification is, to say the least just plain short sighted. As far as I can see there is no real reason why they wont change this law? The Australian government is quite happy to make new laws allowing them to "steal" water from on place to take it to the city, (oh thank you so much Ruddy for the North south pipeline, you Wanker) but they wont allow this. Shame on them. You shouldn't vote for politicians, it only encourages them...

evan321456
evan321456

I've had enough of Australians banning games if you don't want kids 10-13 year old's playing ok put a new classification out I don't care JUST STOP BANNING PLEASE

Azuki
Azuki

I should make a comic about how only ever so slight differences in violence from one game to another results in a 'refused classification'.

Ramanode
Ramanode

if the appeal dosnt pass here is a good idea change LFD2 a little bit and make it dlc for the first game

Cyn987654
Cyn987654

Jimbojones: I plan on fronting up to my local member as soon as I'm able. The actions of this committee are so plainly arbitrary as to completely invalidate the arguable worth of function they've been assigned. It's a joke.

BertisAU
BertisAU

@cabbage100 It's doubtful they've even heard of youtube. L4D2 must've appeared in their local newspaper.

Liponade
Liponade

Good One Australia....NOW I CAN BE SAFE, THE PIXELS CANNOT AMUSE ME, THE FAKE RUSH OF ZOMBIES WONT REACH ME IN MY COUNTRY!

jimbojones1996
jimbojones1996

as our numerous letters and email seem to end up in the governments bin can i just suggest ( this might be going a bit far) a protest at your local member of parliament or if your willing to go that extra mile ( i know i am) actually going to parliament?

DAMSOG
DAMSOG

Once again Australia proves to the world what archaic thinking and ideals our government has, how they must thank themselves everyday for keeping us safe against the threat that videogames represent. They seem to have no problem whatsoever cramming american crime shows down our throat every night of the week on free to air television that has some of the worst stuff that 'actual' society has to offer yet feel that we need to be protected from the hacking off a limb or two in the context of a game. Thanks to Valve for making a game we Australians are obviously are too immature to play, oops....have to be carefull......the government has eyes and ears everywhere......hey ....who's that at the door....its....AHHHHHHHHH

cabbage100
cabbage100

Oh yeah, also, if it's not coming out here, or if we end up getting a damn watered-down version, then Aussie gamers are simply going to end up resorting to game piracy, which I really don't like seeing as all that does is take away profits from an industry that really needs it and it discourages progress for our industry.

Mephistoau
Mephistoau

@ SgtDeathrax - While i agree with some of the reasons behind your rant, things like "I bet the Board of censorship is made up of a bunch of old farts and churchies that think they know best.." are good blocks of text that show you probably don't have the maturity to argue gamers' cases to anyone, let alone anyone remotely close to the government. @ Cyn - Well said. Honestly, i think it's getting to the point where they don't KNOW what to refuse and what not to. It's almost a guess. Plus quite frankly i don't think they care anyway. It all seems rather ridiculous, for two specific reasons - A) These kind of decisions are neither helpful to the Australian people, nor do they have any major effect apart from removing that business from Australian shores, and B) The government shouldn't have the right to make that decision in the first place. I'm sorry but i cannot ever agree with someone telling me as an adult, what games i can or cannot play - provided they don't incorporate anything like child pornography etc. The Australian Government needs to grow up.

cabbage100
cabbage100

@Cyn987654 you're absolutely right, my friend. The Aussie Board 'o' Classification is too far out of touch with society to even give a damn and as far as I've seen, the only people on the board are 50+ old, grumpy (looking) men who are apparently given the right to choose what we can and cannot comprehend how they are able to play through all of these games and give a competent, level-headed decision. THey look like they'd probably just look it up on youtube, have a grumpy old mumble to themselves and slam their big red 'BANNED' stamp down on a copy of the game box and send it back to Valve. You obviously know what's going on man, if your interested I uploaded a little rant onto my Deviatart page, I'm captaincabbage there. :)

Cyn987654
Cyn987654

I'm further confused, because games such as Fallout 3 feature combat of a far more 'impactful' nature. That title in particular has very detailed dismemberment (eyes, pieces of jaw and skull flying freely about the place in close-up and in slow-motion) yet the only thing that almost stopped it being available in Australia was the use of the word 'morphine.' L4D2 is far tamer, and yet this has occurred. I am utterly baffled. (cont next comment) Furthermore, if what I've read in the international press is any indication, this decision - and indeed the very nature of the classification board - is serving only to deny income to this country in the midst of the global financial crisis, and is promoting us as little more than a nanny state... a backwater. Do we want this? L4D2 has been highly anticipated and was set to be a big earner for Australian businesses. This money will no longer be coming in, and a lot of it will quite possibly be going offshore. It will also lead many users to simply source illegal copies. So why has one been refused classification while the other got through without a hitch?

Cyn987654
Cyn987654

I sent a letter to the Board as well. It read as follows: I'm writing to inquire as the effective banning of PC and 360 title Left 4 Dead 2 in Australia, given its predecessor - Left 4 Dead - was available at retail without issue. This is doubly confusing as the premise and execution of both games are similar, if not identical, in most respects: 1). The antagonists in both titles are 'infected'. 2). Both games have comparable if not identical combat traits. (L4D2 does feature melee, but I'm unclear how a blow with a guitar, frying pan or even an axe differs from a point-blank attack with a shotgun. Especially given 90% of the combat occurs at close range.) 3). Both games result in bodies littered about the environment. 4). Both games feature dismemberment. 5). Both games use the same technology, the same engine, and similar if not identical graphical assets. 6). Social and non-combat game mechanics are identical. 7). Backstory is identical. (cont in next comment.)

SgtDeathrax
SgtDeathrax

It's not the Australian people that got the game banned. It's those half witted classification board which consist of a small group of Church'es old farts and so called do-gooders along with that retarded prime minister of ours ( Kevin Rudd). The Australian people love L4D and will love L4D2. But the Government think we are stupid so they have to make the decision for us.. I sent this to those retards at the censorshipboard enquiries@classification.gov.au This is an outrages act of power play and a direct attack on people civil liberties and not to mention -it's a game.. The infected humans are in fact zombies. ( A zombie is a creature that appears in folklore and popular culture typically as a reanimated corpse or a mindless human being.) MINDLESS HUMAN BEING!!! There is no difference from the first Left 4 Dead and yet you ban number 2... Why don't you put an R rating on it then? But you won't! Cause our good Churchy of a government is trying to flex it's muscle and making the choice for us ..They think were are stupid ....Why don t we ban religion instead? It causes more wars and upheavals in the world than Left 4 dead 2. I bet the Board of censorship is made up of a bunch of old farts and churchies that think they know best.. I'm appalled to see my country fall into this type of dictatorship .. Shame on you censorship board.. So take that Censorship board.!!

SgtDeathrax
SgtDeathrax

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

xtremeflem2day
xtremeflem2day

The grenade launcher looks a bit easy to kill special infected... I really hope that versus mode is easier in zombies favor in L4D2. it was just a bit too easy for survivors in the first L4d

stormbard
stormbard

As far as the classification board goes, I am sorry to say that I'm living in SA, and so would love to see the ass end of Michael Atkinson.

Cyn987654
Cyn987654

I wish piracy was an option in this case because I'd be all over it, frankly. This is outrageous. But as a Steam-native product, the functionality of the thing is tied to your country of residence. Meaning if Australia says no, Australians don't play. It's f***ing ridiculous. It makes no sense and is, frankly, goddamned insulting. We look like a friggin' backwater.

forhekset
forhekset

People who are saying pirating is our friends - we still won't have servers OR the ability to play online with no serials or whatever DRM that gets removed.

forhekset
forhekset

An appeal? I guess that's more news than I had before, but I was hoping for some real feedback from someone important not just a level designer.

GRhys
GRhys

well thats just stuipd. fallout 3 almost got a R rating it still got though. L4D2 most likey get M or MA and they want to ban it.Were just kill zombie not taking drugs.

Shwa86
Shwa86

Its illegal to import RC material. It also means no Australian servers.

GetafixOz
GetafixOz

The only theing the Oz ban ensures is that Australian retailers wont get to sell it thats all. Everyone that wants it will import it, we always do.

J-J80
J-J80

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

J-J80
J-J80

I don't care if they ban it, we still have things like the pirate bay and i come from Germany and it shouldn't be hard to get it there since I'm going to visit my family on Christmas.

millencolin
millencolin

I hope the appeal gets passed!!! Fingers Crossed!!!! The inconsistency of the classification board is driving me nuts!!!

raptor1906
raptor1906

Oh it'll definately get passed. Just who, What is the Australian Classification board compared to a successful company like Valve anyway? Exactly, they are nothing.

madtomato
madtomato

Dont worry L4d ausssie fans, if we cant get it legally.....the pirate bay is our freind in these kinds of situations =)... but it should be allowed given that they are appealing

rkaycom
rkaycom

Interviewer is hot...

ttam01
ttam01

People wine l4d 2 was made 2 soon how is more l4d a bad thing?? And I can't what to hit a clown zombie with a baseball bat FTW!

buzznugget
buzznugget

I'm getting this game just to spite everyone who whines that this should be DLC.

Unheard-Volume
Unheard-Volume

People complain that all this could have been solved with a simple patch...while some of the smaller game "tweaks" could have possibly been solved this way, the addition of 3 new special infected, and 5 new maps would've been a HUGE patch!!! And especially for 360 gamers, a patch would have taken up a lot of the "oh so precious" hard-drive space! (20gb is such a rip!!! Sometimes microsoft frusturates me! XD)

Jaguar_Shade
Jaguar_Shade

whoevers playing sucks pretty bad :s Doesnt look like they added much to L4D2, just small polishes which a patch could do to the first.

1r3ap3r
1r3ap3r

I CANT WAIT TO PLAY THIS GAME............................

spacemariens22
spacemariens22

hopefully it will get threw there just zombies not ppl!!! god grow up people on the board!

vampyre1985
vampyre1985

the wording that Valve are using suggest they wont change it to fit into Australia if the RC is not lifted, does not sound fun

2uneek4u
2uneek4u

i have all my fingers cross even my toes crossed for this game to be allowed to release in australia

WickedWeavile
WickedWeavile

@ rock_solid Australia DOES want to fix these atrocious classification laws, but a certain ignoramus in South Australia is stonewalling any potential changes with his naive and narrow minded views.

Faber_Fighter
Faber_Fighter

RockZillaX, if this game does get banned completely from Australia, the Australian online community for it will be greatly reduced as only true fans will be willing enough to import the game. Not to mention there wont be nearly as many dedicated servers for Australians because of this.

RockZillaX
RockZillaX

If the ban doesn't get overturned I'll just import. No Probs...

AndreasRoeder
AndreasRoeder

What's up with the blue haired sissy in the background?

Rattlesnake_8
Rattlesnake_8

Hopefully the appeal will get through and it'll be released here in Australia.

DandamanAUS
DandamanAUS

I think I would prefer a Big Brother and not a Big Grandma looking over me! Come on there is no sex or drugs in this game... well maybe some pills =0

GhoX
GhoX

I really wish the ban can be lifted. If L4D 2 is banned in Australia, there is little chance that the game will have servers with decent connection rate for people living in NZ like me. =/ EDIT: Hm, it may be me, but I think I just saw three of the four survivors in the first look of that video getting burnt down by their own molotov? o.O

southwardraptor
southwardraptor

The whole "banned in Australia" thing is absolute bullsh*t. If parents don't want their kids playing it then its up to them to stop them and if they don't want anyone playing it then whats the message they're trying to send to us. Are Australians more susceptible to violent games than Americans?