Discussion

72 comments
Immortalsaiyan
Immortalsaiyan

I wish something about the winners would be written. As it stands we get no idea what the staff actually thinks of the games or how they picked them. Just saying Tekken Tag 2 is our winner tells me nothing. I want to know why is it the winner. 

MarchingOrd3rZ
MarchingOrd3rZ

Though it disappointed me on many levels, Tekken Tag Tournament 2 is my pick. I must add, as long as Virtua Fighter doesn't win I'm alright.

SciFiCat
SciFiCat

P4A should win this because it is combining two completely unlikely genre together into and excellent game and because it is doing something the fighting game genre needed to do long ago, to make the genre approachable and accessible to people that haven't played fighting games in the past for being near inscrutable for the uninitiated.  That alone is a commendable achievement.

LtJef
LtJef

I have no dog in this fight (pun intended)!

shaggyaz
shaggyaz

VF5 or DOA5 gets my vote

Xero1246
Xero1246

TTT2 or Dead or Alive in my opinion 

EPaul
EPaul

Tough but i would take Tekken

Rittifruity
Rittifruity

it is sad that Soul Calibur V didn't make it on the list

 

Hydrafiend
Hydrafiend

Didn't Soul Calibur V come out this year? That is a great fighting game. 

MEDzZ3RO
MEDzZ3RO

Have to admit though, I'd still want Tekken to take it either way so in the grand scheme of things it doesn't change anything.

MEDzZ3RO
MEDzZ3RO

SF x Tekken and PS All Stars should have made the list, just my personal opinion. Granted SFxT has balancing issues but as a game it offers everything SF4 does as well as way more fan service, all it needs is balancing. As for All Stars, it's severely underrated.

alenth
alenth

VF and TTT2 are my votes.

 

Also lol @ people whining for SFxT there, not even the FG community likes that cash grab.

iBuSHiDo
iBuSHiDo

Gotta be Tekken Tag 2, although they all look like good games. 

Komissar33188
Komissar33188

It seems the people's choice award is for Tekken, and I agree. I haven't written it off for Gamespot's pick, but you're right that they tend to hold its  intricacy and depth against it. Admittedly, I would never call myself good at the game, but I can totally pick a random character and ruin my less experienced friends because the entry barrier is so high, but it's a game one can really sink one's teeth into if they cared to.

Robspoticus99
Robspoticus99

GS will pick P4A cuz its user friendly and has an auto-combo system,though i'd like ttt2 to win.So much content!!

boogon123
boogon123

Tekken Tag 2 even though it seems hasn't been winning overall fighting games often

mateyman
mateyman

It probably won't win, but Tekken Tag Tournament 2 should totally take the crown.

ADO300
ADO300

tekken tag tournament 2

mohamedmounem
mohamedmounem

The best fighting game ever is TEKKEN until now ...and the best fighting game for this year is TEKKEN tag 2

Mc_Trickz
Mc_Trickz

TT2 but where is Street Fighter X Tekken????Epic fail...

Weedster_PkR
Weedster_PkR

playstation all stars aren there cuz they werent released before nov 20th so they wont make this year cuts maby next year if they can hold up that long

nedsig7
nedsig7

no Street Fighter x Tekken, Fail for Gamespot Review

The_Last_Ride
The_Last_Ride

where is Playstation All Stars Battle Royale?! Even though Gamespot gave it a low score, doesn't mean it isn't good

NeoDevastator
NeoDevastator

Tekken, best of all of them. only reason people pick DOA is for the boobs >_>

prince_Arash
prince_Arash

Streetfighter X Tekken Better than All of Them

 

eyal8a
eyal8a

My vote go to "tekken tag toutnament 2" Love this game so much

suplax
suplax

Oh cmon.... Persona arena was a total lame , just to think about the story mode.... boring.

Tekken Tag 2 hands down.

CrazyCraft
CrazyCraft

SXT should be on the list for battling the GOTY out!

 

DoA5/TTT2 should take the win when SXT missed the chance to hit.

madsnakehhh
madsnakehhh

I really hope the most mainstream game doesn't take the award just because, well its named Tekken i mean Persona 4 and even Skullgirls deserve it much more.

stripesonfire
stripesonfire

Soulcalibur V is better than every single game nominated in this list.

maramsp
maramsp

Doa or tekken for me:)

Stonecutters908
Stonecutters908

GS gave Streetfighter X Tekken a much better score than 3 of the 5 nominees and the same score as the other two (8.5) but it isn't nominated? LOL what?

wantbackin
wantbackin

Although not seeing Street Fighter X Tekken on this list is kind of surprising, I guess we can say that this is the end of the line for Fighting games until the next console generation.

we5
we5

what is that is that a games MAM !!!!!!!!!!!

stop play with me put some thing worth to vote please.

666NightsInHell
666NightsInHell

there is no game to choose , all candidates sux badly!