Discussion

90 comments
dapman418
dapman418

It's really quite sad to see this absolute masterpiece receive such unfounded hate.

supersackboy23
supersackboy23

The fact that this got a higher score than LBP 1 and 2 makes me angry.

Philthy101
Philthy101

I'd rather play my old copy of abes oddysee

XxgunsxX
XxgunsxX

9.5 ok im not buying this game is so stupid and boring this game is for ppl who got nothing todo end yust wana do some puzzels or love doing puzzels

Jibroni
Jibroni

Not my type of game, I would probably never even rent it...from a friend.

LMessi101
LMessi101

So what? You can change time so you dont start again (erm, see the brilliant Sands of Time on the PS2) and it sounds awful. This looks like a game someone made on the old Nat Yaroze Playstation about 12 years ago. Fully appreciate that gameplay is vitally important but Comet Crash, Savage Moon, Critter Crunch etc all prove you can have both on the PSN at a budget price. Sorry, this looks like a terrible game.

Jackc8
Jackc8

Donkey Kong with a pause button. Wow, what creativity and imagination that must have taken.

YodaOfTheEmpire
YodaOfTheEmpire

No idea how something that looks at home on a Sega Master System gets a 9.5 as a 2010 PS3 game.

reaputt
reaputt

if this game is supposed to be rated according to it's genre then it should not be included in with ratings from other genres but seeing as how it is i can't say that it compares at all to some other games which were even rated lower how this gets a 9.5 baffles me frankly it looks like someone took a mario game stripped away the music and added a lame feature to it

Maddv1lla1n
Maddv1lla1n

people don't get that games are rated on over all quality of the game , genre doesn't matter after all some game have more than one genre , anyways this is very enjoyable and it deserves its rating because it is of near perfect quality of game play !

patriotsnake171
patriotsnake171

[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]

calvinsora
calvinsora

smookert010: MGS4 and GTA4 are the highest rated PS3 games, both got a 10. And I don't see why Braid having a high score is funny, it's a brilliant game.

smookert010
smookert010

this is the highest rated ps3 game ? lolol :)

alirezateenager
alirezateenager

I want to know that what dose this game have that take this rate?

overlordzzz
overlordzzz

somrthings not right here, how did this beat modern warfare 2?

Mr_GOR
Mr_GOR

important point is understand that game logic. After that, you will enjoy!

calvinsora
calvinsora

When did a higher score for a game in a different genre mean a better game overall? This game got a 9.5 as a puzzler, and thus, it is of high quality. HR, ACII, RE5 (disappointing game in most aspects, in fact) and UC2 are in other genres entirely, they can't be compared. Please, haters, get to your own senses. I was very logical when I reviewed this game and gave it a 9.5, so I agree with GS entirely. It's a fantastic game, period. If you can't establish objective criticism, then you shouldn't comment much. Adieu.

ps3freek
ps3freek

so gamespot u wanna tell me that this game is more better than UNCHARTED 2 GOW||| (HEAVY RAIN ) ASSASINS CREED 2 RESIDENT EVIL 5 WHATS NEXT BETTER THAN METAL GEER SOLID 4 WHATS GOING ON PEOPLE COME ON BACK TO UR SENSES

ps3freek
ps3freek

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

clap-trap0095
clap-trap0095

it looks fun but come on! 9.5!!! thats a joke. haha

Tarixon
Tarixon

this game is kind nice relax game but a 9.5 for this aaaaaaaaaaaaaa that is a kind bad

kubb724
kubb724

so what that you think this games gay smoke a few blunts or bowls and youll be set, half the Whole game industry likes to make games for pot heads it makes it way better experiance. and this game right here is one of the funnest games you can play garunteed haters

SpiKeX-Crom
SpiKeX-Crom

You guys don't see the point of this game. It's not meant to be a 3d action game. It's a simple platformer that is so much fun to play. Stop being so judgmental.

dwd_27
dwd_27

wtf wtf wtf!!! 9.5 for this

ps3freek
ps3freek

is this a fkin joke are u f****g kidding me please gamespot check your rating again u know this f***ed up game is in the top games of the ps3 of ( ALL TIME) in the third plce over UNCHARTED 2 F***** ME IF IAM WRONG WTH THIS I LOVE THIS WEBSITE MORE THAN ANY OTHER ONE BUT THIIS IS REALY START TO GET UNDER MY SKIN I MEEN COME ON I KNOW ITS A PUZZLE GAME BUT THERE IS ALOT OF OTHER PUZZLE GAMES THAT KICK ASS AND THERE NOT ON THE TOP GAME LIST G.S CHECK AGAIN SOM ONE SAID THAT WE JUDJE A GAME ON THE GRAPHICS AND WE THINK 2D IS BORING NO MAN WE LOVE 2D GAMES AND PUZZLES GAMES ALSO BUT THERES SO F****G ALOT OF THEM OUT THERE BUT WHY IS THIS ONE SO SPECIAL TO PUT ON THE HONOUR LIST COME ON ( I LOVE 2D GAMES )

popovicsasa
popovicsasa

Cute game. Play this on PC and have fun :) Puzzles are very good, don't let the look fool you, this game is not easy to finish.

johnnyheno
johnnyheno

seriously are ye just doing this site as a joke you gave this 9.5 and you gave alien vs predator 5.5. I take it ye sit around in a circle and smoke drugs before ye review then.

canmoore
canmoore

You know, not everyone likes the same game. LOTS of people like puzzle games, you know where you use something called a brain, that is located in your skull.. Just because a game does not feature machine guns, zombies, or large explosions does not make it a bad game. There are lots of different genres of gamers. This game is high for its genre, but comparing this game to say a FPS, would be like comparing apples to oranges. If you do not like these types of games, than do not play them...and do not comment when one gets a good score!!

battu1
battu1

this is the S***** game ever made to a console i cant believe this. gamespot is somehow brain damaged

francislopes
francislopes

WTF!!! r u F*ckn' kid me!!! This is Babys games men.

dogmatikos
dogmatikos

oh come on ppl..thats an original game.ok the score might be a little overrated but for it's category is superb.

calvinsora
calvinsora

Most of you haven't even played the game :? That's professional.

XFull_MetalX
XFull_MetalX

Gamespot doesn't know WTF they are talking about. This look dull as **********

itcher1966
itcher1966

WTF indeed are you guys on acid???

PascalPPL
PascalPPL

how does a game like this even get a rating higher then a 7.5!?!

tlam94
tlam94

this does not look that good to me.. :\

shadowandluigi
shadowandluigi

I never even liked mario very much so this would be the worst thing for me

inso-maniac
inso-maniac

looks like you'll have fun in the end when the games finished

chucknoddis
chucknoddis

wow this looks extrmely boring. i think i will go and play some uncharted 2

aluiziospautz
aluiziospautz

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

calvinsora
calvinsora

What most people here have done so stupidly are the following: 1. Started the game with a negative preconceived opinion 2. Think that 2D games don't belong on consoles and are boring (the most stupid thing I've heard for some time) 3. Judge a game based on graphics and sound only (how old are you, seriously) 4. Think this game is ripping off Mario (it's literally trying to be a bit like Mario, that's the point. There are plants that jump from pipes and enemies that are called Goombas!) 5. How does this game even compare to Donkey Kong. It's much more Super Mario Bros. than anything else 6. Don't even try the game or give it a chance I applaud GS for daring to award innovation and clever gameplay. And, sorry, but if you think the graphics suck, you really need glasses.