Discussion

25 comments
orbit991
orbit991

Liked both skyrim and Witcher for different reasons, but Skyrim is pretty damn shallow sometimes especially with the story and characters. Witcher was smaller but it took me on a hell of a ride. I especially liked how different the game became based on choices.

aragorn-1
aragorn-1

i really respect "skyrim" but my vote is for "dark souls"

ApatheticClone
ApatheticClone

@Bowmangr I loved The Witcher 2 as well, but Dark Souls takes the cake for me; nothing has immersed or enthralled me as much since Demon's Souls itself, with it being one of my all-time favorites.

Bowmangr
Bowmangr

Witcher 2 should take this home. No other game pushed the genre forward like TW2 did this year. Unfortunately because most people will vote either pro-hype or pro-platform I guess SKyrim is going to win this one but NOT because it is something extraordinary.

GSDiogo
GSDiogo

Skyrim is awesome, but why did Bethesda released the game with so many freakin bugs especially the save file one for PS3. WHY BETHESDA WHYYYYYYYYYYYYY ??????

siklara
siklara

The Witcher 2. Skyrim's great too, and it will probably win, but I prefer a greatly written, focused story to free-roaming, plus I'm a fan since The Witcher.

krisk7
krisk7

Witcher 2 for me!

theshonen8899
theshonen8899

I know everyone will think that Skyrim should win (and it probably should) but the reality is, every single one of these RPGs are phenomenal. This year was truly a year for RPG enthusiasts, whether it be SRPG, JRPG, or WRPGs.

TheGreatmars
TheGreatmars

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

TimmyP777
TimmyP777

Skyrim was great. Dark Souls was great. The rest were pretty good (havent tried Tactics) But Xenoblade, hands down, should be the winner. Havent played a game since the old SNES days that grabbed me like that.

heroesfan261
heroesfan261

either skyrim or witcher 2. Both were godly.

kennythomas26
kennythomas26

@ArcherRO Yeah I really do not care which RPG wins this, Because if I know how this site is going to go they are going to give it Skyrim and if that one doesn't win then Darksouls will definitely win but maybe not, but let's just wait and see. Where is every body voting their was no link for the voting on this site awards or are they not up yet.

321FOX123
321FOX123

IMO: PS3 best RPG of 2011 is Mass Effect 2

zaiwen
zaiwen

as much as i'm having fun & vote for dark souls.. i have the feeling skyrim will win by a landslide

Codester_41
Codester_41

I'm sorry, due to the amount of people that play the games, Skyrim will probably get it.

ArcherRO
ArcherRO

@kennythomas26 It deserves to win but I'm sure it won't.Let's hope Dark Souls will get it though.Not Skyrim.

iowastate
iowastate

Skyrim is also a great game but I vote for Witcher

C4rl0
C4rl0

Skyrim is definitely a gr8 game, and totally deserves to win this.. Anyway i like Xenoblade better.

Jeebes007
Jeebes007

Skyrim should win this, it is mind boggling how well it plays for the size of game that is.

kennythomas26
kennythomas26

I hope The Witcher wins this but I'm pretty sure it will not.

GameMaster-LN
GameMaster-LN

Skyrim of course,aside from the witcher 2 and dark souls those other games sucks