Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»
5Oct 12

Many years ago, I read David Mitchell's singular novel Cloud Atlas. I felt changed by the experience. Wherever I walked, I felt as if I could see the phantoms of people who had walked there before, whose lives and experiences were no less vibrant and immediate and real to them in their times than mine is to me now. I could see how their choices and actions had, in ways large and small, shaped the moment in which I existed. I also felt that I could see how my choices and actions and those of the people around me were shaping the future that will be the present for those yet to come. Actions rippling out, like pebbles hitting the surface of the water. It was then that I made the banner you see above. Long retired, it now graces my blog again.

lana.jpgAs you've probably heard by now, a film adaptation is almost upon us. When I first heard that a movie of Cloud Atlas was in the works, I was a bit incredulous. To even attempt to adapt Cloud Atlas into a feature film seemed like such a massive, almost foolhardy undertaking. But it's hard to imagine any collaboration of filmmakers being better suited to such an ambitious task than a dream-team pairing of the Wachowskis and Run Lola Run director Tom Tykwer. And in recent weeks, I've been increasingly fascinated with the story of Lana Wachowski, and how her journey toward accepting herself and transitioning has been intellectually and emotionally intertwined with the Cloud Atlas undertaking, as indicated in this great New Yorker story. As a transgender woman myself, naturally I'm intrigued by Lana Wachowski as a filmmaker, and reading the New Yorker story, I found I could relate to many of the experiences she described. Her involvement in the project has also made me think about Cloud Atlas in a new way. The novel is widely acclaimed and of course you don't need to be transgender for it to resonate with you--that would be silly--but I wondered if there was something about our similar experiences that made both Lana and I be particularly taken with it.

berry.jpgI'm tremendously eager to see the Wachowskis' and Tom Tykwer's vision of Cloud Atlas. At the same time, my love for the novel is so great that the potential for disappointment is bigger than it is with a typical film. The novel is about so many things. About how our choices, about how the things we create and the things we destroy, shape the world. About all the different kinds of narratives we create about ourselves--in letters, journals, novels, films, and oral storytelling. About how the things we imbue with power and authority, be they religious figures, corporate mascots, or what have you, can be used for good or ill, to aid or to manipulate. And how patterns repeat, again and again, throughout human history. The film weaves all of this elegantly and beautifully into its tapestry of stories, which switches effortlessly from one voice to another to another, each one captivating and each one utterly distinct from the others.

berryhanks.jpgMitchell is magical as he shifts from one voice to another, but it's not just to dazzle the reader. It's not just a gimmick. It's essential to the story's scope and its thematic power. There's nothing subtle about the novel Cloud Atlas--it's a big, tremendously ambitious book filled with moments of intense emotion and monumental importance--but I never felt that the book was being heavy-handed about its themes. Massive though they are, they arise naturally out of the story. From what I've seen in trailers, I worry that the choice to have actors play multiple roles--having Tom Hanks, Halle Berry and others showing up in multiple story strands--will make the connections that were deliciously implicit in the novel seem clumsy and explicit. And I'm concerned that a film, even a long one, may not be able to develop the characters in any one story enough for us to connect with them.

But these concerns, if anything, only make me more eager to see the film. Even if it leaves me frustrated or disappointed, I expect that I will be fascinated by whatever choices it makes. It will give me a great deal to think about, and I'm sure that I will come away admiring the sheer ambition of the undertaking.

14 comments
carolynmichelle
carolynmichelle moderator moderatorstaff

 @s_h_a_d_o I will wait until after I've seen the movie to read that, but while responses to it have been quite divided, it has been getting some very strong positive reactions, including this review from Roger Ebert: http://rogerebert.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20121024/REVIEWS/121029991

s_h_a_d_o
s_h_a_d_o

 @carolynmichelle 

When I consider the ambitious scope of the premise, the structure used to carry narrative and to enable multiple roles, and the divisive critical reception, I'm reminded of 'Orlando'.

pokecharm
pokecharm

I almost wish my fave books never turned into movies, just so I wouldn't see them undo something I always imagined.  A film version isn't always a better version...

s_h_a_d_o
s_h_a_d_o like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @pokecharm 

"I almost wish my fave books never turned into movies, just so I wouldn't see them undo something I always imagined."

 

Therein lies the greatest obstacle to adaptation - an inability to satisfy the idiosyncratic expectations that arise within the individual mind. This is why I think the consensus on game-based film adaptations is one of failure - even the tiniest quantity of emergent narrative from the gameplay creates a uniquely unattainable experience.

dark_being
dark_being

I never read the book (I didn't even know the movie was based on one), but when I accidentally stumbled upon the movie trailer a few weeks ago, It stirred inside me a mix of powerful emotions. It was absolutely beautiful, and now I can't wait to see the whole movie (and I usually avoid movies with Halle Barry), and maybe even read the book.

 

It also looks like a great setting for a video game.

carolynmichelle
carolynmichelle moderator moderatorstaff

 @dark_being I did try to imagine what a Cloud Atlas video game might be like. It's difficult to imagine how a developer would tackle such a challenge, but the results would probably be very interesting.

iowastate
iowastate ranger

I am hopeful for this film -  it has such potential - those are scary words though.

 

 

 

s_h_a_d_o
s_h_a_d_o

I feel much the same way - fingers crossed they do things right...

then again, Speed Racer. *cringes*

Rodrigo_AA
Rodrigo_AA

I think that expectation is something that can really interfere with the relation that you have with a work of art and affect your judgment. Some people can't see that the masterpiece that they have been waiting for was just a regular movie. Maybe the best thing is be curious about a movie, book or game. Wait for it with a open mind and appreciate by its own merits and flaws. 

 

P.S. Carolyn, I must say that your skills as a writer are much superior to your skills to produce a banner. :P

 

 But I liked the quote that you choose. 

 

carolynmichelle
carolynmichelle moderator moderatorstaff

 @Rodrigo_AA Haha, yeah, I just tossed the banner together in no time years ago with no knowledge of how to do such things and with as little effort as possible. :)

SaudiFury
SaudiFury

Still plan on picking up the book soon. love the concept behind the story

Conversation powered by Livefyre