Top spin 4 has poor graphics, terrible gameplay and overall a lack of professionalism.
The first thing I noticed was the awful graphics in the game. You won't believe how terrible the players look! They look old and weird. This is to me a disrespect to the real players, and to us users. Today's gamers expect quality graphics and quality gameplay. However, none of this is achieved.
I've been playing real tennis for a long time, but I found difficult to synchronize the perfect shot in the game, relying on the real sports mechanics. This means this is not a SIM at all. Top spin 3 really was much more intuitive. Also I didn´t like the on-court help, it makes the game feel a lot more arcade and it's very distracting.
There are other flaws like the player creation, the horrible sound effects and the lack of player signature moves. I won't address these issues but you can check out other reviewers comments discussing the problems in this areas.
.
Overall this is a terrible game, and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone.