Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

The Walking Dead: Episode 5 - No Time Left Review

By Brett Todd

The Walking Dead series shambles to a brief but moving conclusion that doesn't quite live up to the gruesome brilliance of earlier chapters.

The Good

  • Closing scene finishes off the story in heart-wrenching fashion  
  • Claustrophobic atmosphere with hordes of zombies all around you  
  • Some great moments with the script and voice acting.

The Bad

  • Shortest episode of the series, clocking not much more than an hour  
  • Disappointing final confrontation.

It may have started with a hungry growl, but The Walking Dead adventure game series goes out with a soft groan in No Time Left. The fifth and final episode in the adventure franchise based on the Robert Kirkman-created graphic novels closes off the saga of Lee Everett and friends with a tearjerker of a conclusion that is suitably gloomy and moving, if not entirely satisfying when compared to the gory brilliance of the preceding chapters. The story veered off track in the last episode, losing a fair bit of steam after the introduction of an offputting new plot device--and the whole thing comes to a halt in this brief final act that lacks the devastating impact of the earlier episodes, despite more than a few heartbreaking moments. (Note: The following text includes information that could be considered minor spoilers for The Walking Dead series.)

No Time Left picks up where its predecessor, Around Every Corner, left off. Episode four ended with the ragtag gang of zombie apocalypse survivors stuck in Savannah, Georgia, after the notion of securing a boat and heading out to the undead-free high seas didn't work out as planned. Plucky ragamuffin Clementine is still missing, the victim of an abduction that concluded the preceding episode.

The abduction still feels tacked on, a phony way to take things back to the beginning when it was just Lee and Clem on their own. The plot has moved off on a tangent, with a new villain and a corny chase for a missing child that is miles removed from the brutal focus on survival that made the first three episodes so engrossing. The narrative flow feels forced. Too many core characters have died, and it feels like the game is being brought to a close largely because this is the final episode, not because the story is coming to a natural ending.

Aspects of No Time Left also play fast and loose with the premise that the game responds to your actions, although the game varies enough based on how you play that you may or may not see any given inconsistency. At the start of play, for instance, you head out after Clementine with a buddy or four, depending on how good you've been getting along with everyone. But after some quick scenes, you might wind up back at square one, and a group that may have just told you to get lost could immediately offers to pitch in and help find your little buddy.

Personalities and motivations can be thrown out the window, depending on the course you pursue. A previously selfish Kenny might suddenly grow a conscience, forgiving a fellow survivor for kicking off a tragic chain of events, and then risk his life to play hero. Yet the scenario might be much more organic should you have taken a different path in previous episodes. In that case, Kenny's motivations are a much more realistic blend of tough-guy bravado and self-importance, which is consistent with how he's behaved throughout the series. You might also witness some touching moments with Kenny when he finally must confront his own selfishness. Some of these conversations also flesh out the characters of Omid and Christa, who were previously as dull as dishwater.

Everything moves at a frenetic pace. You can zip through this episode in little more than an hour or so, less time than it takes to complete any previous episode. Part of the speed comes from the lack of challenge in the quick-choice combat and button-mashing action sequences. Nothing should require more than a single attempt, save a fight near the end of the game with a gun-wielding nutcase.

79 comments
nomailx
nomailx like.author.displayName 1 Like

I don't like these kind of game's pretending that you have choices through out the story. In fact, you never have choices in the outcomes that matter the most. *** Spoilers Ahead *** For example, your protagonist always dies, or you can never save the journalist, nor the little boy from being bitten, etc... Your choices affect only irrelevant situations like who accompanies you in one quest, or else. If you want to enjoy this game, just watch it, and keep the interaction as some kind of fun feature. It's not really a "game".

weisguy119
weisguy119

***WARNING***SPOILER ALERT***

My comments below contain major polt spoilers for those who haven't played the game.  You've been warned.

weisguy119
weisguy119 like.author.displayName 1 Like

This game had an interesting story that got kind of corny towards the end.  Who leaves their car abandoned and unlocked with the keys in it and gets THAT pissed when someone comes along in a post-apocalyptic, scavenge-or-die world and strips it clean.  Who wouldn't pick the car clean?  You'd be a supreme idiot not to.  There are no morals concerning thievery in such a world when people in your group are starving and in need.  You do what you gotta do.  Everyone in that setting would understand that.  The guy should've parked the car off the road, locked it (for what little good that would do) and hid it with branches and leaves or something.  Protect your own or lose it.  It's not Lee's fault the guy was a moron.  If I found the car hidden and locked, I'd be more inclined to try to find its owners before stripping it clean.  Leaving it unattended and so easily accessible, the way he did, makes me think something happened to them and it's there for the taking.  Also, why didn't Kenny just pop Ben in the alley and get out of Dodge?  If he wanted to off himself, there are much easier ways to go - especially when you come upon more ammo.

Gallesh
Gallesh

Wow.. I cant believe Brett Todd is still reviewing games. (WTF)

 

After the disastrous game reviews he had done in 2007 i always assumed he was fired or just hanged himself.

 

Please just dont pay attention to his reviews, this guy knows nothing about games..

Neil211
Neil211 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

I'm sorry but this episode was pure perfection. I haven't seen a story this good since "The World Ends With You". The climatic ending with Lee and Clem actually made me shed a few tears o.0 

daabulls23
daabulls23

It was a good ending. At the end of it all, it wasn't about having a big climatic fight against a bunch of zombies. It was about the relationship between Clem and Lee, and how much Lee went through to basically save Clem.

aquaphx
aquaphx

7.5 is right.

i'm gonna skip the next season. after episode 3, i just pick any option because it doesn't matter.

Pickleking23
Pickleking23

I disagree. This was an amazing ending, almost flawless even. I would personally give it a 9.5. So heart-wrenching and so well done. Voice acting was top notch to add.

vault-boy
vault-boy like.author.displayName 1 Like

There are some valid complaints here, mostly being that it was a little short and not very climactic BUT it had some of the most emotional moments the industry has ever seen. For me it would go from best to worse 2-1-5-3-4. All in all the game deserves somewhere between a 8.5-9.0 and I can't wait for season 2.

outlawst
outlawst

no spoiler :after the accident at the final event in 4th episode,they ruined the last episode,cause you already know what will be happens next,there were no surprise in the main story at the last episode,but after all the whole series was so fun to play.

WakizashiSabre
WakizashiSabre

@outlawst Agree totally. I have not tried the option with cutting off the arm, but i guess Lee will die because blood loss or will turn anyway. For me I find the fifth one among the weakest.

I think the fourth, third and the second were best for me.

buckwild73
buckwild73

I liked the 2nd episode most in this series but this episode a close second. As good as the TV series imo but with more emotion & better characters.

iempire68
iempire68 like.author.displayName 1 Like

that was so sad. great story. glad i had the experience. 

Gamemaster_94
Gamemaster_94 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

This game was just... pure awesomeness. Really awesome ending. Thanks Telltale for this outstanding series! :D

renome
renome

A quality series, but mediocre last episode (except the emotional ending).

ewjiml
ewjiml like.author.displayName 1 Like

SO this is the only video game that nearly brought me to tears.  I agree with the reviewer saying that it is short, and I do wish they fleshed out the conclusion more.  But the series as a whole, I would give a 9.  Great acting, dialogue, and enough variety to keep me going.  If people are pissed about the ending, they should be because it is absolutely brutal. 

pseudospike
pseudospike

The whole game (all episodes) easily deserves a 9.0!

 

Not only is it the best zombie game ever made, not only does it have some of the best heart-string tugging writing in the history of games, not only that but it is also a unique take on the Adventure genre.

 

Giving this a 7.5 just because it's short is like giving RE6 a 4.5 just because it's not what you expected...oh wait...

cyborg100000
cyborg100000 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Great series, emotional ending, can't remember another game that brought a tear to my eye. Very tense episode all the way through, one of the darkest games I've played.

FreakshowGamer
FreakshowGamer

I absolutely felt this way after I completed it. It felt so rushed and weird. The conclusion was so anti-climactic and the guy at the end was so useless to the story. Episodes 1-3 were amazing, 4 was good but then 5 just sort of stirred up my feelings for the series as a whole. I don't know what to say.

pseudospike
pseudospike

 @FreakshowGamer Isn't that EXACTLY what a good final episode should do?  All those feels.  Brilliant game, equally brilliant ending IMO.  Looking forward to another season!

ao28
ao28 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Even though it is the shortest episode, I do believe it was the best one. The intensity was extremely high and I have never been more emotional during a game or even a movie. As gut wrenching and horrifying the ending was (it also made me cry), I would not have it any other way. Almost all of your choices are at least mentioned in this episode, even little dialogue choices. What I thought of shortly after was how this was the complete opposite of the mass effect 3 ending. While both are amazing games, mass effect, while it is an excellent game, completely botched the ending, as none of your choices matter and I felt like I did not get a full conclusion. Walking Dead was also an amazing game, but the end was its best moment. pretty impressive for 5 episodes at 5 bucks a piece. Can't wait for season 2!

q-bert39
q-bert39 like.author.displayName 1 Like

The whole "stranger" (aka pedophile rapist on the radio) plot was retarded and unneeded. None of them died proper deaths.

 

Kenny completely broke character and sacrificed himself to save a radio they didnt even need/use. They botched the last few episodes in a half hearted attempt to add suspense and emotion.

 

 

ewjiml
ewjiml

 @q-bert39 SPOILER ALERT.  Thanks.  Btw, you would understand why Kenny did it if you read the dialogue.  Not that hard to understand why he did it. 

scrkpr
scrkpr like.author.displayName 1 Like

Whoever wrote this is an idiot. Who cares if it's too short? It was an hour long, but it left me more emotionally drained than any game I've ever played! What ever happened to quality over quantity?

Robspace1
Robspace1

The ending was bad. It left everything in limbo and way too many questions not answered. But, wait a minute folks- alas! This was not the end, no. Word is out that the next part is being made now. So, it's not over yet.

SirenAries
SirenAries like.author.displayName 1 Like

im so happy another reviewer pointed out how the final episode was the weakest. the length and the abrupt unsatisfying ending was just not worth it. the game just ends and seems unfinished vs a proper cliffhanger or closing. im all for cliffhangers, but dont just end it like that, totally felt cheap and was not worth all you had went through waiting for the episodes and just how amazing the game really is. it seriously just ends and you dont know anything about the outcome. its like theres scenes missing. i was so disappointed in this episode.

Vojtass
Vojtass

 @SirenAries So what other ending would be good in your opinion?

SirenAries
SirenAries

 @Vojtass i didnt have an issue of what happened, it was just how it was done. theres a giant gap between the scene before the credits and after. it seemed very cheap and more like a budget restraint than what could have been. it wasnt what happened, it was how they portrayed it that was really weak. reminded me of the ending in "Angel" terrible ending for the fans. instead of feeling like, wow great ending cant wait to see what happens. it was after all that, they ended it like that. you gotta be kidding me. bad directing.

zmija58
zmija58

I really really don`t understand why people would cry at the end of this...????I mean everything that happend in the e5 (only the introduction scene was like...hey holy fuck they will not do this...oh hell...they will) was so predictable ...And the end...was not sad, was not surprising! It was a bit emotional ...if I were a 9 year old! I mean "Founding Nemo" was more emotional...For me the most disappointing was that no matter what decision You make during Your adventure the final outcome is always the same. It reminds me of another game from this year...and that wound is not healed yet so... 

ewjiml
ewjiml like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

You didn't cry because you are that hardcore.....bro....

tmrtyn
tmrtyn

Man, I hadn't cried that much in a game since Tifa died xD

twister_nt
twister_nt

I agree with the final score here. No matter what choices were made, the same people *had* to die in the end. Very disappointed- it would have been game of the year, until the ending- the zombie slaying in the street was pretty bad-ass though :)

SUNDRAGONJ
SUNDRAGONJ like.author.displayName 1 Like

I give it an 8 or an 8.5 at most. The story was brilliant, yes it was short but the story telling is really what matters and they did it right! If they don't make a sequel then they will be letting a lot of fans down, including this one.

wyan_
wyan_

The final boss in this episode is Steve Pavlina.

AlisterFlint
AlisterFlint like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

by some aspects,  TWD finale could be disappointing: too short, too sad, not enough people make it through, you name it; BUT compared to so many supposedly "top" games flooding the market, TWD still stands its grounds because at least TTG tried to deliver quality all the way; and that's refreshing, nowadays.

 

having said that, it's true it's too short. :)

SebMillGermany
SebMillGermany like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 3 Like

Most of the people playing games as mean of distraction or escapism want a happy ending, or an ending full of glory, even if that included a sacrifice (Like Tassadar in Starcraft), however, this can`t be applied to The Walking Dead.I loved that ending.

lester850
lester850 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

Well I played the game twice and chose different option every single time. My first Lee was more like a leader who tried to take care of everyone and the second Lee was a jerk (I even chose "..." if all the available answers were too good). But sadly the progressions of the game from both playthrough are the same. I'm somewhat disappointed because I was expecting different routes and multiple endings.

 

The stranger and Kenny storyline is just the example of it. From one playthrough their motivation is very believable and the other one I would say what the hell would they've thinking?

ruudboy5
ruudboy5 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 5 Like

I genuinely can't believe people are disappointed by the ending. It was a friggin' masterpiece in storytelling! I haven't cared that much about characters in a videogame for a long long time. I agree about the brevity of it being a negative but story-wise it was the best of the episodes. So brutal, so sad. My personal choice for game of the year.

 

SPOILERS

 Seems like a few people thought the stranger/kidnapper guy was crap and should have been a character we knew but in my opinion it was far better and scarier to have it be a random guy that was has been destroyed by the situation. And having it tie into the car that the group takes from was clever. Yes there are plot holes in terms of how he was in Savannah and followed you etc. but I honestly didn't even consider them until I read some comments threads.  I also haven't played any of the chapters more than once a from a couple of comments I read it seems that the discussion with the stranger is not as satisfying in other playthroughs. Still, I loved this so much and can't wait for another season or just another game from Telltale.

Vojtass
Vojtass

 @ruudboy5 Most of people don't like unhappy endings. It's too uncomfortable, too disturbing for'em.

SirenAries
SirenAries

 @Vojtass  @ruudboy5 im all for unhappy endings. but this ending was just like they ran out of time. the cliffhanger was done poorly and deserved better. poof...over

leeti
leeti like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @Vojtass  @ruudboy5 Actually, I prefer unhappy endings and it was heartbreaking to watch, but what I think me and most people who disliked the episode feel is the whole story was problematic. They left too many things unsolved and the ending was the conclusion to a recently disappointing story. You couldn't help but think "what? that's it?" because they left everything unanswered with the promise of continuing on the next season - and that is a very, very unforgivable trick to play on the fans. It only didn't ruin the whole experience for me because the first three episodes were really memorable.

WakizashiSabre
WakizashiSabre

@Vojtass@leeti

I think, that our friend wanted to point out the option of you "tailoring the story"  And that makes damn sense. You can choose who should live and die somehow when playing the game and that is nice thing indeed.

With this nice thing, there is the expectation some similar thing will also happen at the end. Good endings and bad endings would be damn nice. And honestly, while not BW with EA behind azz, making more endings would not be that hard, considering their writing skills during all episodes.

Vojtass
Vojtass

 @leeti High expectations are good, but not too high IMO.

 

You have to take into account that TWD is more or less middle budget game and more possibilities means more money. Unfortunately Telltale isn't a BioWare, who has support of EA. Besides I don't really see what is really wrong with more linear structure. Most of adventure games are linear and many of them are outstanding.

leeti
leeti

 @Vojtass  But it isn't it something good to have high expectations? It means the creators were doing a great job that we really wanted them to keep up. What's wrong about that? It's also great to have critical sense about what you're playing and to be demanding on the quality of the game (or, really, of anything else in life), instead of mindlessly liking whatever thing's thrown at you. Demanding players make creators be demanding with the quality of their work :D

 

Maybe depending on your choices they could've made you not even get bitten and gone to a totally different path with the story. Or maybe cutting off your arm could've saved you even with the psychological and physical torture it would cause. There are literally endless good possibilities for the ending that weren't considered. I'm starting to think maybe the bite was the huge mistake. I also have that feeling the story will continue and if they can really make it good again I'll gladly clap my hands.

Vojtass
Vojtass like.author.displayName 1 Like

 @leeti  @ruudboy5 Actually it's really important who is playing. Some people have too high expectations. They expect to see something absolutely incredible even if they know subconsciously that any other ending will be horrendous, just bad, extremely cliche etc. I can't imagine an outcry if Lee would miraculously survive or be healed by secret antidote from government lab. Even when ending has high quality, people with too high expactations almost always are greatly dissapointed. Creators never will be able to make them happy. I'm sure that ANY cliffhanger would dissapoint them too. And BTW - there are many changes that appear (or not) and they're depending on your playstyle. I have also a feeling that the story will be continued in 2nd season.

ruudboy5
ruudboy5

 @leeti  @Vojtass Suppose we just have to agree to disagree on this (is that allowed on the internet?!) I personally thought the ending was extremely well written and executed maybe aside from it being a bit short. For me, the choices affected the story as it played out and changed who dies when, who comes with you in ep 4, and how the characters developed. The fact that specific aspects of the ending are set does not bother me and I never felt like I was being steered in a particular direction or forced to decide something that I didn't want to. Maybe this was just a happy fit between the game design and the way I wanted to play as Lee.

leeti
leeti

 @Vojtass  @ruudboy5 Not really. The story finishing poorly has nothing to do who's playing, it has to do with the writers. That is an obvious thing. Especially when our choices didn't matter at all because everyone gets the same ending. Way to finish a game where 'the story is tailored by how you play'.

 

One thing is building an amazing cliffhanger throughout the story and other thing is playing a cheap trick on everyone who had high expectations on the game. I also love when things are left unanswered but only when it's done in a decent way. Not in a way that makes me lose my trust in the writers.

Vojtass
Vojtass like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

 @leeti  @Vojtass  @ruudboy5 The problem lies in people. They think that everything MUST be solved and everything should be showed. No, it doesn't have to. I like when some things are left without answer. It force me to think what happened and what could have happened. So yeah, that's it. Deal with it.

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Game Emblems

The Good

The Bad

  1. A powerful exhibition of human drama that perhaps ended up in the wrong medium.

  2. A strong final scene doesn't make up for the fact that this episode is short and a bit limited.

The Walking Dead: Episode 5 - No Time Left Boxshot
Not Following

    Game Stats

    Also on: