Forums › The Walking Dead: Episode 4 - Around Every Corner Forum › The Walking Dead: Episode 4 - Around Every Corner Xbox 360 Forum › What choices would you have made if you ...

What choices would you have made if you WERE in this world as Lee? spoilers

« prev next »

Page:

This topic is now read-only on GameSpot.
To post new messages, please visit GameFAQs and log in using the same email and password that you use on GameSpot.

flagg2kplus

Oct 10, 2012 6:15 pm GMT
Carley or Doug? I still would have chosen Carley. I would almost always save a woman before a man. That's just how I am.

Shawn or Duck? I would always save a kid before an adult. So I went for Duck first.

Shoot the crazy lady with the crossbow? I would have. The moment she pointed it at me, she was dead.

Kill the St. John brothers? I would have killed them both. Leaving them alive means they can be a liability later.

Kill Larry? I would have tried to save him, but if he could not be revived, his brain is getting smashed ASAP.

Leave Lilly? I would have left. Again, another liability you cant have around if you truly expect to survive.

Shoot Duck? I would have if Kenny didnt seem up for it.

I would have pushed Omid.

Let Ben die? Another liability and an idiot that I would have had no regrets leaving behind.

How bout you guys? And I mean if you truly were in this world. There are no alternate saves. There are other choices you can feel free to add as well. I just listed these since they were the most important imo.
---
Don't take life too seriously. You'll never escape alive.
codyallen25

Oct 10, 2012 6:33 pm GMT
flagg2kplus posted...
Carley or Doug? I still would have chosen Carley. I would almost always save a woman before a man. That's just how I am.

Shawn or Duck? I would always save a kid before an adult. So I went for Duck first.

Shoot the crazy lady with the crossbow? I would have. The moment she pointed it at me, she was dead.

Kill the St. John brothers? I would have killed them both. Leaving them alive means they can be a liability later.

Kill Larry? I would have tried to save him, but if he could not be revived, his brain is getting smashed ASAP.

Leave Lilly? I would have left. Again, another liability you cant have around if you truly expect to survive.

Shoot Duck? I would have if Kenny didnt seem up for it.

I would have pushed Omid.

Let Ben die? Another liability and an idiot that I would have had no regrets leaving behind.

How bout you guys? And I mean if you truly were in this world. There are no alternate saves. There are other choices you can feel free to add as well. I just listed these since they were the most important imo.

1. I'd choose Carley even though I chose Doug first time around.
2. Chose Shawn the first time cause Duck annoyed me and Shawn seemed like a really great guy, but I would honestly choose Duck because he's just a kid and would be easier to save then Shawn pinned under a tractor.
3. Didn't shoot her, but probably would IRL, I'd be to scared of getting shot.
4. I would want to kill them, but don't think I honestly could.
5. No I'd try to save him, he wouldn't turn right away and I wouldn't want to murder him.
6. I'd still leave her, you can't kill a living person in our own group and still expect to be a part of it.
7. I'd want to shoot Duck, but I probably couldn't bring myself to, ending up with the leaving Duck in the woods result despite how cruel it is.
8. I would have just jumped leaving him behind, if I pushed him I would think I might just end up killing him, and it's not my call to decide if he wants to or not.
8. I would not have dropped Ben if I could still pull him up, I'd kick him out of the group afterwards though.

Nice question, most of my real choices are the opposite of what I did though, because as a video game I know I'm not about to die anytime soon.
---
The only common factor in all your failures, is you. -- Karakh
arc125

Oct 10, 2012 6:42 pm GMT
1. Carley. Women first.

2. I chose Shawn because I knew Kenny would take care of him. I didn't account for him ditching Shawn though.

3. I would have tried to shoot her leg to incapacitate her. I wouldn't shoot to kill.

4. I wouldn't be able to. I'd just let them be walker bait.

5. I would try to save Larry definitely. He wasn't dead yet and if he was, then he would have gotten the salt lick.

6. I would leave Lilly as well. There's no way a psychopath like her will be allowed on board a small RV with children and others.

7. I would have shot Duck if Kenny wasn't able to. Like Lee said, no parent should have to do that.

8. I would have convinced him to jump for Christa's sake.

9. I would have saved Ben. I believe everyone can learn from their mistakes and be redeemed. After all, Lee is redeeming himself throughout the game. He also wanted to take the easy way out, but I think he should live and think about his mistakes.
---
http://i56.tinypic.com/148pvet.jpg http://i48.tinypic.com/eqyvpk.jpg http://i48.tinypic.com/20gi792.gif
codyallen25

Oct 10, 2012 6:46 pm GMT
arc125 posted...
9. I would have saved Ben. I believe everyone can learn from their mistakes and be redeemed. After all, Lee is redeeming himself throughout the game. He also wanted to take the easy way out, but I think he should live and think about his mistakes.

If Darth Vader can redeem himself then so can Ben god damnit!

... But wouldn't that be a big kick in the balls from Telltale if saving him gets yet ANOTHER person killed..
---
The only common factor in all your failures, is you. -- Karakh
arc125

Oct 10, 2012 6:52 pm GMT
From: codyallen25 | #004
If Darth Vader can redeem himself then so can Ben god damnit!

... But wouldn't that be a big kick in the balls from Telltale if saving him gets yet ANOTHER person killed..

Exactly! Darth Vader even killed kids on purpose himself. Ben just made a dumb mistake which led to a kid dying.

Yeah, I REALLY hope he gains courage in episode five and does something heroic. I imagine he will then it's going to cost him his life. That would be a good way for Ben to go. Especially if he sacrifices himself for Kenny as a final apology.
---
http://i56.tinypic.com/148pvet.jpg http://i48.tinypic.com/eqyvpk.jpg http://i48.tinypic.com/20gi792.gif
flagg2kplus

Oct 10, 2012 7:53 pm GMT
codyallen25 posted...
arc125 posted...
9. I would have saved Ben. I believe everyone can learn from their mistakes and be redeemed. After all, Lee is redeeming himself throughout the game. He also wanted to take the easy way out, but I think he should live and think about his mistakes.

If Darth Vader can redeem himself then so can Ben god damnit!

... But wouldn't that be a big kick in the balls from Telltale if saving him gets yet ANOTHER person killed..

Darth Vader is a fictional character in a fantasy sci-fi setting.

Had Hitler not killed himself, would you have been ok with giving him a shot at redeeming himself?

Now I know Ben's not on the same level as Hitler or anywhere close, but what Im trying to say is Ben showed more than once he's a dumbass and a huge liability to your survival. If you really want to survive, you cant have someone around like that.
---
Don't take life too seriously. You'll never escape alive.
arc125

Oct 10, 2012 7:58 pm GMT
From: flagg2kplus | #006
Darth Vader is a fictional character in a fantasy sci-fi setting.

Had Hitler not killed himself, would you have been ok with giving him a shot at redeeming himself?

Now I know Ben's not on the same level as Hitler or anywhere close, but what Im trying to say is Ben showed more than once he's a dumbass and a huge liability to your survival. If you really want to survive, you cant have someone around like that.

I get what you're saying, but I still wouldn't be able to let him die. I'm a lot like Dale from the show. I give people a chance. Also, after I would have told him to not touch anything and to listen to my orders.
---
http://i56.tinypic.com/148pvet.jpg http://i48.tinypic.com/eqyvpk.jpg http://i48.tinypic.com/20gi792.gif
DutchAngel9

Oct 10, 2012 9:19 pm GMT
-Carley or Doug?
Carley, in a zombie apocalypse a good shot is worth a lot.
Plus, she looks good, so yeah.

-Shawn or Duck?
I would lift Duck off and immediately go and help Shawn.
If that's not possible, just Duck. I can't let a kid die, now can I?

-Shoot the crazy lady with the crossbow?
Tough one.. I do think I would have shot her though.
She threatened to kill me, and I believed her. It's either me or her.

-Kill the St. John brothers?
Yes, they're dangerous.

-Kill Larry?
Yes, he tried to kill me by knocking me down at the drugstore.
And he's having a heart attack (I believe?) in a small room. Bye-bye Larry.

-Leave Lilly?
Yes. She's crazy. She shot Carley (Or Doug for those who saved Doug I guess) without proof that she did it.
So she's shooting random people and I killed her dad, not a good combination.

-Shoot Duck?
Yes.
I would first give Kenny some time, to see if he could do it, but if he takes too long I would tell him I'll do it.

-I wouldn't have pushed Omid.
It's his choice, really. And I wouldn't know if I could trust him, so I wouldn't mind if he didn't jump at all.

-Let Ben die?
Yes.
His fault Carley died, he put Clem in danger, let her escape the house, removed the axe from the barricade, and made a deal with the bandits behind our backs.
Clearly he can't be trusted.
zinsindetta

Oct 10, 2012 10:11 pm GMT
Carley or Doug? Carley. Female.

Shawn or Duck? I went for Shawn because it was Ducks fault. Yes he is young but got to be fair.

Shoot the crazy lady with the crossbow? No. Violence vs humans is last resort. Was not their yet.

Kill the St. John brothers? Yes. Think not what you are killing but who you are saving later.

Kill Larry? No.

Leave Lilly? Yes. If she says she has "no chance" just point to Carly and say "you got a better chance then her."

Shoot Duck? Yeah, sadly Duck was dead already.

Push Omid. No.

Let Ben die? No. Killing humans still not acceptable in that situation.
---
Gamertag/PSN - http://gamercards.exophase.com/31441.png
http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/CareerStats/default.aspx?player=SinZinDetta
Oct 10, 2012 10:12 pm GMT
If i was Lee i wouldn't get bit a walker in the last episode
codyallen25

Oct 10, 2012 10:29 pm GMT
zinsindetta posted...
Kill the St. John brothers? Yes. Think not what you are killing but who you are saving later.

Kill Larry? No.

The irony!
---
When life gives you a Salt lick you make Larryade -- Acadias
Flowling

Oct 10, 2012 10:40 pm GMT
1.) Carley - Crackshot with a gun and ammo in an overrun close quarter situation? Enough said.

2.) Duck - Instinct would have kicked in long before I remembered Kenny had even existed. Plus I wouldn't have known how of a coward he was until after the fact.

3.) Held Out - She was close to giving up vital information and the St. John brother had already played his card with his reaction to the camera. I would have been dead against going to the farm to begin with so the risk of not knowing versus her shooting me was equal at that point.

4.) Spared Both - As much as I think I'd have the lack of restraint and remorse eliminating a realistic threat, I don't think I could do it in the end. Clem having a front row seat would have sealed the deal for me. I also wouldn't want give the rest of the group pause to trust or view me as an unstable threat. Both of them were screwed at that point anyway and I don't take orders from psychopaths. Kill you? Nah... go **** yourselves.

5.) Saved - He was a dick but also one of us. He deserved a fighting chance to live and I would have loved playing that trump card every chance I got in the future, but Kenny just had to **** it up.

6.) Kept - Mainly because I would have told her the truth about my past and due to trying to save her father she would have understood. Plus she was right about the missing meds and the fact myself, Kenny and now her were all killers to some extent. I would have tried to give her the benefit of the doubt or at the very least dropped her off somewhere else.

7.) Made Him Do It - No way in ******* hell I would have done that for him. His family, his problem. The whole Larry incident would have placed me on his **** list turning Kenny into an unreliable jackass. The most he'd get from me is some comfort but the gun is getting shoved in his face quick, fast and in a hurry. Man up and handle your business so it's one less thing you have to blame me for later on.

8.) Convinced Him To Jump - Anyone with a fully functional brain would have known they were together. Easiest way to rattle his cage would to be go straight for his woman. Showed a little interest... and BAM. Easy money.

9.) Saved Him - Between the Chuck's death, the Crawford arc, Ben's guilt and saving Molly there's no way I could have held enough of a grudge to kill him. Especially not when he's trying to take the easy way out instead of atoning for his mistakes. He owes a lot of people. Time to grow up, man up and try to fix things before it's too late kid.
---
"Like the rest of the world, Skyrim fans want to bang fictional vampires and werewolves." - Retneug
theedizzyone

Oct 10, 2012 10:53 pm GMT
1. Carley. Women come first.

2. Shawn. Kenny was standing RIGHT there.

3. Shoot her. You can't trust anyone now... Why should I trust them during a zombie apocolypse?

4. I would kill them. Them crazy ***** don't deserve to live. Plus they cut off my buddy's legs!

5. He's not dead yet, so I try to save him.

6. Leave her. She's ******* crazy. You can't trust someone who "shoots off" at the mouth like that!

7. I'd shoot him. I probably couldn't kill my own kid.

8. He's on his own. If he didn't jump that's on him.

9. As much as I'd want to drop him, he doesn't deserve to die. I'd rather him live and suffer through the living Hell I'd have to live with... Plus... My girl died cause of him >
zinsindetta

Oct 11, 2012 10:25 am GMT
codyallen25 posted...
zinsindetta posted...
Kill the St. John brothers? Yes. Think not what you are killing but who you are saving later.

Kill Larry? No.

The irony!

Whoa Larry was like the St. John brothers in the sense of killing unsuspecting people and eating them. Wow I missed that big time.
---
Gamertag/PSN - http://gamercards.exophase.com/31441.png
http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/CareerStats/default.aspx?player=SinZinDetta
KaizerFree

Oct 11, 2012 1:52 pm GMT
Carley or Doug? I still would have chosen Carley. She knows my past and yet wants me around.

Shawn or Duck? Shawn, Duck could have just gotten off the tractor, but didn't ..... idiot

Shoot the crazy lady with the crossbow? Depends, the fact that she didn't shoot us at the start means there's a chance that she could of lower her weapon.

Kill the St. John brothers? Probably still would have killed Danny. Andy until someone stops me from punching him to death or til I saw my reflection.

Kill Larry? He's an ass, but he has a good reason to be, so no.

Leave Lilly? She's dead to me

Shoot Duck? Yeah, Kenny lost everyone he loved...... rather have him hate me than to make him end his own life

Let Ben die? Not on my watch and until he man up.
codyallen25

Oct 11, 2012 1:59 pm GMT
zinsindetta posted...
codyallen25 posted...
zinsindetta posted...
Kill the St. John brothers? Yes. Think not what you are killing but who you are saving later.

Kill Larry? No.

The irony!

Whoa Larry was like the St. John brothers in the sense of killing unsuspecting people and eating them. Wow I missed that big time.

I mean a popular reason to kill larry is to save the people in the room, think not what you are killing (Larry), but who you are saving later (Everyone in the room).
---
When life gives you a Salt lick you make Larryade -- Acadias
zinsindetta

Oct 11, 2012 8:53 pm GMT
codyallen25 posted...
zinsindetta posted...
codyallen25 posted...
zinsindetta posted...
Kill the St. John brothers? Yes. Think not what you are killing but who you are saving later.

Kill Larry? No.

The irony!

Whoa Larry was like the St. John brothers in the sense of killing unsuspecting people and eating them. Wow I missed that big time.

I mean a popular reason to kill larry is to save the people in the room, think not what you are killing (Larry), but who you are saving later (Everyone in the room).

I wait... he was going to become a zombie? Now come to think of it I forgot how that all went down. Damn Telltale and the long gaps in releases. You might have a point fine sir.
---
Gamertag/PSN - http://gamercards.exophase.com/31441.png
http://www.bungie.net/Stats/Reach/CareerStats/default.aspx?player=SinZinDetta
assassinreaper

Oct 12, 2012 11:28 am GMT
flagg2kplus posted...
Carley or Doug? I still would have chosen Carley. I would almost always save a woman before a man. That's just how I am.

Shawn or Duck? I would always save a kid before an adult. So I went for Duck first.

Shoot the crazy lady with the crossbow? I would have. The moment she pointed it at me, she was dead.

Kill the St. John brothers? I would have killed them both. Leaving them alive means they can be a liability later.

Kill Larry? I would have tried to save him, but if he could not be revived, his brain is getting smashed ASAP.

Leave Lilly? I would have left. Again, another liability you cant have around if you truly expect to survive.

Shoot Duck? I would have if Kenny didnt seem up for it.

I would have pushed Omid.

Let Ben die? Another liability and an idiot that I would have had no regrets leaving behind.

How bout you guys? And I mean if you truly were in this world. There are no alternate saves. There are other choices you can feel free to add as well. I just listed these since they were the most important imo.

Save Carly
Save Shaun
Shoot the lady and take her stuff
Kill Larry and the brothers they'd just cause problems
I wouldve killed Lilly and took her gun
And I would've thrown Ben down and gave him the finger
There is no room for screw ups or weaklings in the apocyolapse I like to think I would end up worse then Shane in the apocyolapse
---
Please excuse my grammar I'm an American teenager.
ApolloCreed

Oct 13, 2012 7:39 pm GMT
Carly or Doug

1. I'd save Carley, because she's a strong party member. Good with a gun, easy on the eyes and resourceful. (Saved Carley in Game)

-----

Duck or Shawn

2. Would've saved Duck, not only because he's a kid but because Herschel made it clear we were not welcome long-term anyway. Might as well be on good terms with Kenny.

(Saved Duck in game)

-----

Crazy Lady with the Crossbow

3. Probably wouldn't have shot the crazy lady with the crossbow, she seemed to be giving up a lot of info on these people we're thinking about staying with, people that I already find suspicious.

(Didn't shoot her in game)

-----

Cannibal Cleanup

4. I would've killed each and every one of those cannibalistic pyschos, without any regrets. They killed Mark and tried to feed him to us...! That's SICK...! They didn't even bother to eat that last cow...! Eat the COW, you sick creeps...! Who eats people when there's COW...??

(Did NOT kill them in game because of Clementine's fragile mind)

-----

Reviving Larry

5. I would've tried to save Larry. Sure he's an ass **** but I'd rather not have Lily against me; and Kenny would get over my not letting him kill the guy... especially if Larry revived.

(Sided with Lily in Game... Larry started to breath on the count of "5", then his head exploded)

-----

Leaving Lily Behind

6. I'd have left her, or even shot her myself. I was really digging Carly. Not only that but it seemed like Lily just killed her in cold-blood. I don't even think she ended up shooting her over the "missing supplies", it seemed more like she shot her because Carly told her off. After Lily's father got murdered, she lost it and became a danger to herself and to others in the group.

(Did NOT leave Lily behind in game)

-----

Dealing With Duck

7. In real life it would have been hard for me to put duck down... but the scene being what it was (Duck dying, and Kat dead by her own hand) you'd be a fool to hand Kenny a gun; Chances are he'd blow himself away just to be with the two of them. I'd have to man up, ask Kenny to return to the group, and do the deed myself.

(Had Kenny shoot duck in game)

-----

Omid and the Train

8. After telling him a few times to jump, I'd have left without him. Pushing him in real life probably would've equaled a broken neck and death rather than just the broken leg.

(Pushed him off in game)

-----

Pull Ben Up --- Let him Fall

9. The funny thing about that Ben scene is that, in real life, he would be dead as ****ing fried chicken the second that walker grabbed him. Surely the buckshot from that shotgun blast would've blown off about half his face, right...? IF (and that's a BIG IF) he survived it though... yeah... I'd have pulled him up. Lily pulled the trigger on Carly, not Ben and that's the ONLY reason I'd spare him. He's obviously a coward, and he's put the group, including Clementine in danger many times at this point... So even though I'd spare him in the bell-tower, he'd have to go his own way once we left Crawford.

(Spared Ben's life in game)

---
"This game is like picking your ASS and then picking your nose!"
ApolloCreed

Oct 13, 2012 7:58 pm GMT
....and I would've punched Kenny in the head and stole his car for assuming that just because I'm black I can pick locks.

---
"This game is like picking your ASS and then picking your nose!"