Not as good as the first game, in my opinion. The different storyline lets it down and even though there are bigger armies it does not seem as personal. The graphics are slightly better, but the characters, armies and areas aren't as interesting as the first game.
Story - 6, the original storyline featuring Glorfindel and Gloin is a complete departure from Tolkien's world.
Gameplay - 8, a few tweaks for the worse, but still fun. Custom characters are great.
Visuals - 7, a slight improvement.
Music - 9, still just as good.
Controls - 9, still just as good.
Multiplayer - 8, still just as fun, nearly.
Originality - 6, not enough improvements for mine.
Characters - 7, the elves and dwarves are fun, but lack the characterisation of the Fellowship.
Fun - 7, a good game, just a let down compared to the first.
Overall - 7.4