Not many games left you wanting to play more. I remember grief after I finished first MGS on PS1. I remember very well this big hole that left inside me after finishing Half-Life... The Lost of Us is one those games that will really suck you in.
Almost everything is perfect. First thing that struck me was (of course) graphics. I thought that Uncharted was the PS3 limit. I was wrong. This is out of any doubts the best looking game of current generation. Environments are very detailed with great sounds effects. Add to that great voice acting and fantastic soundtrack, and you have a masterpiece.
Story is great. I really got connected with the main character and choices he had to made. It's really rare when a story is better than the way the game looks... Great screenplay.
If you played Uncharted series, controls will not be an issue, however my friend who is not such a great fan of the series complained about layout and overall feel of the controls. I guess it's matter of a taste. I liked it.
Another things that hurt the experience are bugs... Unfortunately this code have some problems: disappearing enemies, corrupt autosaves... And some problems with enemies seeing you from behind the wall. But this can be easily forgiven as those are not too often to break the fun.
Multiplayer is one of the best I have ever played... Everyone should at least try it. Very tense, very clever, very challenging.
This is one of the game that everyone should try. Not playing LoU is like not playing Zelda or Resident Evil, or God of War...