Too short, too easy
Gameplay-9
The gameplay got a nine, barley avoiding an eight. The vibes was yet another thing that made this game way too easy. None of the boss ideas were original, a lot of them from Super Mario Sunshine. You could not buy enough different extra weapons and power ups. Saving the Toads was pretty pointless. The replay value is extremely poor, it gets old the first time playing through. The "brains" the umbrella got weird after about thriteen minutes.
Graphics-8
The graphics were pretty good, for the game being a 2-D game but were not even close to being the best. The background when you had to select the stage was another thing that brought it down. The umbrella thing looked bad during the game and the other times like when selecting a stage or at the shop.
Sound-10
The sound was really good. Peaches voice was one of the best parts of the sound, it was better than Luigi's voice in a lot of games and his voice was really awesome. All the other little things were other great things that the sound had to offer in this game.
Value-9
The value was pretty good in this game. The only improvment I could think of that brought it down to a nine instead of a ten was that collecting the Toads was really piontless.
Overall this game was pretty good. If you are looking for an alright game to keep you mostly entertained for a short amount of time you should rent or buy this game. If you get bored of a game fast if it does not change much, this game is definatly not for you. Like I said before this is a good game that will keep you entertained for only a short amount of time.