Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

Super Mario Galaxy 2 Review

Game Emblems

The Good

  1. Galaxy 2 is the wonderful sequel that improves on the original, and asks the question: Why not have more of the same?

Tom Mc Shea
Posted by Tom Mc Shea, Editor
on

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is even more varied, challenging, and fun than its superb predecessor, making it the new standard for platformers.

The Good

  • Levels have tons of different objectives, all of them fun  
  • New power-ups spice up the action  
  • Later levels offer a sizable challenge  
  • Stunning visuals that are a marvel to look at  
  • Catchy soundtrack that combines classic Mario songs with new material.

It may be easy to take one look at Super Mario Galaxy 2, see the same gravity-altering traps and spherical worlds from its predecessor, and dismiss this as a by-the-numbers sequel to the superb original. But by assuming you know what to expect from Mario's latest adventure, you would be doing yourself and this game a great disservice. This is not only the new standard against which every 3D platformer must now be judged, but it also seamlessly integrates so many elements from Mario's 2D roots that it stands toe-to-toe with even its genre-defining progenitors. Every aspect of this game is absolutely bursting with joy. The vibrant artistic design immediately welcomes you into this colorful world, and the catchy soundtrack deftly mixes classic tunes with new compositions to provide the perfect backdrop for your goomba-stomping, star-snatching fun. But it's the expertly designed levels that will keep you coming back, even after you've seen everything this game has to offer, just to experience it one more time. This is an instant classic that belongs alongside the best games Nintendo has ever created.

Journey to the center of Earth, and right back out the other side.

Things are once again rotten in the Mushroom Kingdom. Bowser has taken Princess Peach prisoner for the umpteenth time, forcing Mario to momentarily put his plumbing gig on hold to rescue his fair lady. The best thing that can be said about the story is that it mostly stays in the background. A few lighthearted exchanges between Mario and his foes precede major battles, but there is only a brief break in the action before you get back to flinging fireballs and cracking shells. In fact, Galaxy 2 is much more streamlined than its predecessor. The elaborate hub world that has appeared in each of Mario's previous 3D adventures has been scrapped and replaced by an easy-to-navigate map that lets you hop right into the next level. Galaxy 2 has less downtime than the original, ensuring you're always engaged and entertained.

And you'll be happy to jump right into the action because Galaxy 2 is a long and often challenging adventure. There are lots of different activities to take part in, but everything comes with the same prize: a shining star. It takes 70 of these celestial bodies to make it to the end of the game, but there are many more hidden throughout the universe waiting to be discovered. No matter what you're doing in Galaxy 2, everything feels just right, thanks to the ultraprecise controls. It's a breeze leaping between walls, performing deadly butt-stomps, or jumping across lava-filled pits. There is an unabashed joy in movement that makes even running around the colorful worlds and taking in the uplifting atmosphere feel special. The camera does an admirable job of framing the action, giving you a clear view even when you're dancing on the ceiling in a reverse-gravity room or leaping between floating meteors in space. There are a few times where the angle is less than ideal, making it difficult to line up an exact jump, but for the most part, the camera performs its duty with flying colors.

The wealth of different objectives in Galaxy 2 is mind boggling. Just about every star introduces at least one new mechanic, generating a truly stunning degree of variety. Whether you're grabbing onto the talons of a powerful bird, competing in score-based challenges for a monkey that's wearing sunglasses, or slamming into enemies while ice skating, you're constantly presented with a new activity. Even though many of these situations only appear once or twice during the course of the game, they're all fully fleshed out and incredibly fun. It's really interesting how varied objectives can be even within the same level. The first time you enter a level, you may have to zip down a sand slide at breakneck speed, dodging cactuses and nabbing coins all the while. But when you enter the level again to try for a different star, you may have to navigate an underground obstacle course from a side-scrolling perspective. Because your goals are constantly changing and always at a high level, Galaxy 2 never gets stale or predictable.

If the huge variety of goals doesn't sound like a big enough change, there are also power-ups that further mix things up. One of the few weak spots in the original Galaxy was a lack of interesting power-ups to play around with, but that has been rectified here. The most notable addition is Yoshi, the lovable dinosaur with the prehensile tongue. Once on this green fellow's back, you can point at enemies or objects with the remote and swallow them whole. You can snatch up a spiny and then shoot it like a projectile, inhale a pepper to receive a massive speed boost, or chow down a bulb to light up hidden pathways. There's also a power-up that lets Mario roll around like a Goron from the Zelda series, a special suit that gives you the ability to create clouds in midair, and a drill for digging through soft dirt. All of these power-ups build on their most basic functions as you get deeper into the game, forcing you to look beyond your preconceptions to use them in unique ways.

Tom Mc Shea
By Tom Mc Shea, Editor

Tom Mc Shea loves platformers and weighty moral decisions. Some call him a T-Rex with bigger arms, some call him a gorilla with smaller arms -- you can just call him the jerk who hates all the things you love and loves all the things you hate.

21 comments
bruno_fmenedes
bruno_fmenedes

Outstanding review Tom!
I pretty much agree with everything you wrote about this game, particularly this line: "This is not only the new standard against which every 3D platformer must now be judged, but it also seamlessly integrates so many elements from Mario's 2D roots that it stands toe-to-toe with even its genre-defining progenitors."

Here's my shortened review of this masterpiece:

Super Mario Galaxy 2 is surprisingly even more polished and better designed than its superb predecessor. This was clearly a work of love done by people that really comprehend what makes action platformers, and Mario games in particular, so fascinating to play.

The game is fun and exciting from the beginning to the end, progressing at a breezy pacing, with some fast paced levels and none too slow paced or too difficult. It even has an easy-to-navigate map that, like in the 2D classics, lets you fly right into the next level, giving it a more addictive non-stop action feel, when compared to past 3D Mario games, by focusing on what's important: stomping goombas and going through the extremely engaging levels.

No doubt the best graphics engine of any game for the Wii, one of the best artistic visual designs of this gaming generation and an even more amazing and wide-ranging soundtrack that skilfully mixes old tunes with new compositions and always fits the action perfectly.

The concept behind the creation of Super Mario Galaxy 2 is an extension of the first Galaxy's concept, so it can't possibly have the same impact. But what makes Galaxy 2 so great and what will keep you coming back, even after you've collected every star, is the expertly designed levels, with an incredible amount of variety, a constantly changing pace due to excellent mix of 3D and 2D gameplay, and the great number of different power-ups, mechanics and activities, all smartly placed, delightful and interesting, level after level after level after level? leaving you breathless and full of joy!

MY SCORE: 10/10

yoyou225
yoyou225 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 5 Like

Hm... if it was Gamespot in 2013, it probably would have gotten an 8.5 at best. It deserves a 10, which it got. But nowadays, Gamespot just gives anything good an 8.5 (unless they are being paid off of course...)

skayj2
skayj2

@yoyou225 What's even harder to believe is the fact that Tom McShea gave this a 10! 

:P

Nintyfan95
Nintyfan95 like.author.displayName 1 Like

Not as big of a deal as people make it. Super Mario Galaxy is the real 10.

SkullsnChains77
SkullsnChains77 like.author.displayName 1 Like

It's-a-me! Mari...wait...where's-a-Luigi? He makes-a-dis-a-game so much bettah! He runs-a-so much-a-fastah & jumps-a-so much-a-highah! It's about-a-time he started getting some-a-credit! Here we go!!!

vicke32
vicke32

Saying that this is too easy doesn't even begin to describe it.

Now, I'm not some guy who brags about his skills, but this game is pathetically easy, sands of time (2008) is hard compared to this, there was just no epic buildup, there was no 'grinding 99 1-ups before going against bowser'-moment like in 64. Just like the first galaxy the only "hard" levels were the ones with gimmicks, like 'tilt controller to move' or 'you need to point at the screen', I beat the final boss without dying, once.

Being good at games shouldn't make you unable to enjoy them, right?

The only enjoyable times when playing SMG1 and 2 was when I was fighting bouldergeist with daredevil, and even then I had just started to warm up when I beat him (which was about 10 or so lives) and when I did 'The Perfect Run'.

Does not deserve a 10/10, hell, no game except, no, no game deserves 10/10, this game should be a 6/10, slightly above average but not good.

bruno_fmenedes
bruno_fmenedes

@vicke32 I have one honest advise for you: live more and play less videogames. If you find this game so damn easy that it's a cakewalk it's because you spend way to many hours of your time playing videogames, which ironically will cause you to enjoy less and less the games you play. But saying Sands of Time is less easy than this game is just untrue/dishonest. Maybe you were less skilled in games when you played Sands of Time or you played much more action-platformers than action-adventure games, but Sands of Time is an easier and much shorter game than SMG2. I beat Sands of Time in a 1/4 of the time, with at most 1/10 of lives lost, than SMG2, but maybe that was just me...

vicke32
vicke32 like.author.displayName 1 Like

@bruno_fmenedes 
I also have one  honest advise for you: don't reply to comments half a year old and live more. I play games because I find human conversations and the need to "socialize" completely useless and disgusting, I only communicate. There are good and bad games, there are fun and boring games, but generally easy games are as per definition bad, hard games can be bad but that's not often the case since if a hard game is bad it's called "unfair". This game is so mediocre and bland that I haven't heard a thing about it since I wrote that comment, is that a feat a so called "10/10" game should boast about? MGS4 was GotY and was mentioned in other places, but SMG2 was completely forgotten. This game is slow paced, watered down and overall it lacks the feel of being "fresh".

TheEveryMan
TheEveryMan

I would have given it a 9.5 in contrast to a perfect 10. 

ZeroAce510
ZeroAce510

AW-some game i hope Nintendo plan to Super Mario galaxy 3 soon :).

Cocotroid
Cocotroid

Jeez Mc Shea, at it again? "SMG2 HAS PERFECT CONTROLZ" when infact, they can be very jumpy, and unresponsive, but nope, Skyward Sword's controls are horrible and very unresponsive, right? You are the reason why there is no hope for the gaming world.

Voice_of_Wisdom
Voice_of_Wisdom like.author.displayName 1 Like

good, but not better than mario 64 and super mario world

bruno_fmenedes
bruno_fmenedes

@Voice_of_Wisdom Super Mario World is a perfect game, so it's unfair to say that since it's impossible to be better than perfect. But for me SMG2 is better than SM64, particularly in control precision, soundtrack and visual design.

Maurik03
Maurik03 like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 4 Like

the best mario game of all times e a must have game for wii onwners.

turtlethetaffer
turtlethetaffer like.author.displayName like.author.displayName 2 Like

One of the absolute best games this gen, both the Mario Galaxy games will be remembered for a long time as games that took 3D platformers to new hieghts.

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Super Mario Galaxy 2 BoxshotEnlarge the boxshot
Not Following

    Game Stats