Oldie, but a goodie
For those who don't know (:O how could you not?) the Super Mario Bros. series are the greatest platformers of all time (that's not even biased), blending good graphics with strangely addictive gameplay for a complete experience. Through all the thousands of times you'll hear the death music, you'll still come back for more.
Very good games to play alone, or with a friend. Good games for kids as well.
Graphics: Good graphics. (8)
Gameplay: Highly addictive, fun game. (8)
Sound: Just about the catchiest music in video game history. Bad sound effects, but somehow it doesn't really matter. (8)
Story: You're a plumber who is rescuing a princess from a dragon/dinosaur. There pretty much is no story. (4)
Overall: (7)
Epically nostalgic. I was raised on these games.