The new quake game is more than a renter it is I think one of the top five title for the 360. Even though as pointed out the gameplay lags somewhat during some spots in the game, it still is a great game. All around this is a great first person shooter with a good mix of nostalgia and some new upgraded gameplay. This is a great game and if you haven't played this yet, it should probably be close to the top of your list. I think its a great game and it is a great title for the xbox 360 in its 2 month launch window. Defenitly on to pick up right away.