Much better than Shattered Universe. Then again, is that saying much?
Encounters is a pleasant surprise! You get to fly ships from every era. The control scheme is great and offers tons of control. It's pretty impressive how they've mapped all of the controls onto the DualShock. Not only do you control ship movement, which includes a z axis. But you also can direct power to many systems, select weapons, control transporter room, lock on, select which phaser bank to use... I mean it allows for all types of play styles. Albeit can get a little complicated if you let it. And YES, the ship can stop!
The graphics are great. They seem to be more like the show and less like the cartoon styling of previous entries. That probably has to do with harnessing more of the PS2 power. However, there is one gripe with the graphic presentation of the game. Everything is so far away! On my TV, the Enterprise is often about an inch big. THat's because the camera has to zoom out to show the rest of the action, reticules, waypoints.... well. It's not a true problem, but you do get the sense that it's a compromise the designers had to make. When you play this game in co-op mode and split the screen the image gets worse.
If you are looking for a good Star Trek experience, this is a safe bet at the budget price. If you're looking for the BEST ST game, well, that's going to depend on your preferred play style. ST has cranked out FPS, RTS, and even the now famous Bridge Commander. Which, I have to say is my favorite ST game. It's a mystery why they never created an expansion or a sequel. It truly captured the ST experience.
All in all ST: Encounters is a safe bet and will please most casual ST fans and even a few hardcore fans..... is that Trekkie or Trekker?