Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

Most Surprisingly Good Game

Flash Player 9 is required to watch this video.

At GameSpot we make every effort to approach each new game without any preconceptions about its quality. But in some cases, a game will surprise us with how good it is, which makes us realize that we weren't really expecting much from it, for one reason or another. Maybe the game seemed generic at first glance, or maybe the concept seemed too gimmicky. And some types of games simply have a reputation for being too unwieldy for or inaccessible to the average player. The sleeper is the one that rises above any preconceived limitations and proves itself to be truly great, which is exactly what these five games have done.

Viva Pinata (X360)
Publisher: Microsoft Game Studios Developer: Rare Ltd.

Microsoft's promises of "synergy" between a new Xbox 360 game marketed toward kids and a simultaneously launched computer-animated cartoon made our skin crawl, but we should have had more faith in Rare, who turned out a great, addictive game in Viva Piņata.

Viva Pinata (X360)
36%
(7,774 votes)
Publisher: Microsoft Game Studios Developer: Rare Ltd.

Microsoft's promises of "synergy" between a new Xbox 360 game marketed toward kids and a simultaneously launched computer-animated cartoon made our skin crawl, but we should have had more faith in Rare, who turned out a great, addictive game in Viva Piņata.

Watch the Video Review
Saints Row (X360)
23%
(5,032 votes)
Publisher: THQ Developer: Volition Inc.

Unlike so many other Grand Theft Auto imitators, Saints Row went deeper than just the basic look and controls of GTA and succeeded at being fun to play and fiendishly funny at the same time. We didn't expect that.

Watch the Video Review
The Godfather (X360, PC, Xbox, PS2)
14%
(2,965 votes)
Publisher: Electronic Arts Developer: Electronic Arts

Taking a cinematic masterpiece like The Godfather and having the audacity to turn it into an action game is automatically going to polarize people. Some never gave The Godfather game a chance, but those of us who did were pleasantly surprised with how it turned out.

Age of Empires: The Age of Kings (DS)
9%
(1,935 votes)
Publisher: Majesco Games Developer: Backbone Entertainment

Although this PC real-time strategy series carries a well-respected name, it didn't sound like it was going to turn out all right when transformed into a turn-based, portable game. But it turned out better than all right.

Marc Ecko's Getting Up: Contents Under Pressure (Xbox, PS2)
6%
(1,289 votes)
Publisher: Atari Developer: Double Helix Games

A video game inspired by the brand of an outspoken urban clothing mogul? It might have had "train wreck" written all over it, but Getting Up won us over by delivering an all-around great game of fighting the establishment one spray can at a time.

Watch the Video Review
Okami (PlayStation 2) 0.3% (74 votes)
Wii Sports (Wii) 0.2% (45 votes)
Dead Rising (Xbox 360) 0.2% (36 votes)
Elite Beat Agents (DS) 0.1% (30 votes)
God Hand (PlayStation 2) 0.1% (29 votes)
Best Original Music Best Licensed Music