GameSpot Reviews

Player Reviews

Average Player Score Based on 378 ratings
4.3
Please Sign In to rate Silent Hunter 5: Battle of the Atlantic
Score Breakdown Based on 378 ratings
  1. 10 (26)
  2. 9 (28)
  3. 8 (27)
  4. 7 (36)
  5. 6 (29)
  6. 5 (37)
  7. 4 (27)
  8. 3 (30)
  9. 2 (24)
  10. 1 (114)

Most Helpful Positive Player Reviews

Most Helpful Critical Player Reviews

What Gamespot Users have to say about Silent Hunter 5: Battle of the Atlantic

  • User Rating 1

    Why silent hunter V killed the silent hunter series which once upon a time prospered though not huge had a solid base

    Rated on March 04, 2010 by tomnuke

    This game be slaps ever hardcore silent hunter fan which we all put up with (drm).This game is unrealistic,an arcade version of the previous installments,i personally rather play silent hunter 4 and i...

    15 out of 27 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 1

    If you want to be a submariner, ignore this game and join the Navy!

    Rated on March 04, 2010 by borrisimo

    **Listed difficulty as hard due to the fact that it's a pure frustration to get anything done in the game** A true disappointment in every sense. Graphics engine may have had an update since Sil...

    16 out of 16 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 2

    Total dissapointment! Having played all SH games which non of them ever let me down I gotta say that SH5 is a disaster!

    Rated on March 04, 2010 by HuSSaR83

    I mean why would company took out all great things about previous SH games and gave us All flash, no substance broken game? I thought that company that never dissapointed before is just gonna make thi...

    17 out of 17 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 5.5

    A beautiful sub game but that's about as far as it goes with Silent Hunter 5.

    Rated on March 05, 2010 by gijas

    Like with any game there are things that make it a good or bad game. SH 5 starts out good as your treated to some of the best graphics the series has ever witnessed. When you start to play you see tha...

    10 out of 10 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 3

    SH5 is all the proof i need to judge Ubisoft at being extremely resistant to learning.

    Rated on March 05, 2010 by kailii

    (Yes, i said yesterday that SH5 is not even worth a review. After a good night of sleep i changed my mind as i believe i owe the simulation community at least a warning. Here it comes...) What defi...

    14 out of 15 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 9

    Great game, Realistic as it will get.

    Rated on March 08, 2010 by Stereorec

    Let me start off by saying this game is the best so far is Silent Hunter...that is if you have played them ALL. Everyone complained to Ubisoft to make the game more realistic and FPS/RPG elements t...

    6 out of 31 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 7

    Long time since Silent Hunter IV, but it seems that Ubisoft didn't forget how to make a good Sub-Sim (...with bugs).

    Rated on March 08, 2010 by jeromecharette

    I bought Silent Hunter from D2D right after it came out. I read a lot about the new uPlay-Client, but having Steam and EADM I gave them a chance. Well, my verdict for the Client. It is at it's curr...

    0 out of 5 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 2

    Anyone who is a fan of any of the previous Silent Hunter titles will find this a BIG disappointment. It's all eye candy.

    Rated on March 09, 2010 by PJMaybe75

    Firstly, I am a BIG fan of SH3. SH4 was very good too but not my cup of tea just because I preferred playing as the Germans. I have been eagerly awaiting SH5 in the hope that it would be every bit as ...

    11 out of 11 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 1

    Terrible!!! I'm a life long Silent Hunter player and am hugely disappointed with this rubbish!

    Rated on March 09, 2010 by Serpicko

    I have played the silent hunter games for many years and love the realism they have brought to controlling a WW2 submarine. I was really looking forward to this game and thought it would be a new and...

    23 out of 25 found this review helpful.
  • User Rating 1

    It's difficult evaluate a game that...just don't plays!

    Rated on March 11, 2010 by devil_geppo

    Simply the Server that Ubisoft chose to force the game-users is totally unreliable, often down, with save game (teorically sinchronized on this server) lost and unrecoverable, so you can play for more...

    8 out of 9 found this review helpful.