Part-by-part review.

User Rating: 7 | RuneScape WEB
Levelling of skills - 4/10. Everything is grindy if all you're doing is staring at it. Better to multitask, unless you're one of those who finds it fun, like I do.

Quests - 9/10. Every quest is well-written and occasionally have voice-overs. Unique logic puzzles in most of them; nothing is straightforward. Never use a walkthrough, it spoils the fun

Sound - 7/10. Music is excellent, but some places' bgm can get repetitive (soul wars come to mind). But some good pieces like autumn voyage might stick with you forever. SFX is limited though, hence this low score.

Minigames - 8/10. There are so many of them, all with a substantial amount of regular players. And these minigames usually reward with ingame xp too, so it's a win-win concept. Just like quests, many facets of logic apply during the games.

Total -> 7/10