All of the elements of a great game are here!
The menus are well-done and make the game more accessible.
I could give the gameplay and graphics both an 8.5 each. The only fault I have with the graphics is the lack of zoom. The replays and the cut scenes for the conversions, injuries, lineouts, etc are of different angles at least. There is still a lot to learn about rugby but I can see this as being one of the best balanced games as far as "pick-up and playability" and "challenge" without being buggy or too hard.
New Zealand All Blacks and the Haka kick serious ass.