Unrest Review

Against the grain.

In many games where conversational choices dictate plot progression, success is often guided by a system of modern Western morality. Choosing the noble response sends you on a path toward "good," while the opposite is clearly "bad." Sometimes there is a moral gray area, but ultimately, the games are typically designed around the binary concept of good and evil. Unrest, however, steps away from such tradition. Challenging the ancient and uncompromising social barriers of Unrest can yield dire consequences: putting your family in peril, shaking a community apart, or much worse. While Unrest struggles to stay consistent in its message, the lives of its damaged, refreshingly human characters stayed in my mind for many days after the credits rolled.

Against the backdrop of an ancient India rooted in both myth and history, you guide several people as they struggle to survive in Bhimra. Once a thriving city, previously considered the mightiest of all, Bhimra is choked by drought and bridled by poverty, disease, and hatred. The game's unconventional cast members stand as grim reflections of Unrest's dismal world. This point-and-click adventure game is devoid of the cleft-chinned adventurer who approaches danger with a charming quip--or a crack of a whip, when charisma won't do the trick.

Talking to everyone you meet can open new quest options.

Instead, you play as individuals straddling the social divide of India's rigid caste system. They include a peasant girl, betrothed against her will; a priest who bows to new masters for the sake of his family; a mercenary captain, barely keeping the city from tearing itself apart; and a princess, fallen from grace, fighting for survival in the slums. The emotional impact of their stories hits deep. It's hard not to feel sympathy for a young girl whose world was once adorned with flowing drapes, clean clothes, and rich food. This same girl now finds herself filthy, starved on the streets, and standing over a mutilated corpse, contemplating whether she should walk away and save her dwindling pride, or soil her hands with the victim's blood in hopes that a pocket yields a mere crust of bread. Desperation is prevalent, and in Unrest, living to see another day is the greatest victory.

Most of your time is spent in conversations, where your replies shape your fate for good or ill, and discourse is rarely straightforward; Unrest is not a game that provides easy answers to complicated issues. Instead, you are rewarded for your ability to intelligently weave your way through conversations, suppressing any penchant for a brazen response. Yielding to the social laws is hardly virtuous, but it could keep you breathing.

Unrest stars a cast of unconventional characters.

In conversations, characters acknowledge you in three colored bars representing friendship, respect, and fear. That acknowledgment is important in choosing the right person to strike up a conversation with in order to pursue your goals. In one event, a town guard with little respect for your plight shows a comparable amount of empathy for your hunger pangs, refusing you access to a temple that hands out food. A guard in another story, however, can be coerced to step aside if you latch onto his fear and agree to help appease his crippling gambling debt. But not all characters welcome discourse. The reptilian naga, for example, are often blamed for Bhimra's condition, and therefore show no love toward humans. Most interactions with these creatures in the slums involve death threats.

In Unrest, failing in a storyline is worse than the end of a quest; it could mean the death of a character. You might believe that decisions you make are the correct ones--like I did many times. But Unrest is not like games such as Mass Effect or Dragon Age, and assuming the sensibilities of such games could leave you staring down an executioner's blade. As the story draws to a close, the game tells you how your character managed after leaving your care. My first experience in receiving this report card of my actions was a gut punch--despite my best efforts, my character didn't survive. What had I done wrong? I did everything that came natural to me, and so I assumed I would be kindly rewarded. Unrest's cold pragmatism was sobering, and such lessons linger as the game progresses.

Most of your time is spent in conversations, where your replies shape your fate for good or ill, and discourse is rarely straightforward.

Unrest requires much readiing, both in and out of conversations. In games with so much unvoiced conversation, reading several paragraphs with each character interaction comes with the territory. But the game also provides detailed profiles on the people the character knows personally, as well as descriptions and the history of items in your inventory. The game's own exposition, coupled with books and scrolls containing Bhimra lore, has you perusing pages and pages of information. It gets exhausting, and I found that I needed to take occasional breaks to rest my eyes and stave off boredom.

Unrest isn't free of concerns, the most damning of which is its tendency to hinder immersion. The vibrant hand-painted environments are far too cheerful for the theme. Bright splashes of colors and hand-illustrated designs are a jarring juxtaposition to Unrest's somber motif, and undercut the overall impact of the stark, poignant world. There are also technical issues, which range from crashing to desktop following one of Unrest's many loading screens to odd pathfinding problems in which characters oscillate along their path or get stuck on corners. During conversations, making choices drops the menu back to the gameplay screen for a split second, which is distracting to the point of aggravation.

In Unrest, failing in a storyline is worse than the end of a quest; it could mean the death of a character.

With different ways to approach situations, Unrest encourages multiple playthroughs. Unfortunately, in replaying the game, I found myself disappointed by how completed stories affect the overall plot. Unrest claims that characters, left alive or otherwise, blend naturally into the game's narrative after their tales are finished. However, only two individuals were ever mentioned, one of them just in a passing comment. In reality, the characters' plights and their impact on the plot are superficial, existing merely to give you the impression that their lives changed something.

But I found myself most disappointed in the game's central story. Out of the four playable characters, there is one whose placement in the narrative is an anomaly; she experiences the hardships of her world, but no matter your influence on it, you cannot alter her course. I had even tried replaying certain sections in an effort to sabotage the final sequence of events, choosing options that I felt could have affected her path, but to no avail. Unrest ultimately opts for what is almost a fairy-tale-like conclusion, which goes against the messages that paved the way.

You can't make everyone happy, especially the desperate.

At the end of her journey, the character ends up in a situation similar to the one that started it; the ending, uninspired, rang hollow. After I completed Unrest, I spent some time contemplating the circular logic behind the conclusion. I thought, perhaps, that the game was attempting to explain that no matter how hard we try to change our destinies, fate is carved in stone and impervious to our influence. But I could be searching for a deeper meaning where one doesn't exist. A quote by a character near the end of the game seems appropriate: "When you get lost in a happy story, all the other details and consequences are nothing, and anything becomes possible."

Despite the glaring issues, I was swept up by Unrest's unique cast, and I cared about their troubles, enough to even feel responsible if the path I led them down ended up in disaster. Though flawed, Unrest's system of cause and effect is a refreshing change from traditional conversation mechanics and deserves appreciation. In a sea of clearly defined morality systems, Unrest proves that sometimes the best waters consist of infinite shades of gray.

The Good
Emotionally broken, realistic characters
Unconventional conversation system
The Bad
Visuals are incongruent with the dire theme
Some characters do little to change the plot
Uninspiring conclusion
6
Fair
About GameSpot's Reviews

About the Author

Cameron Woolsey enjoys the simplicity of traditional morality systems in games, but found Unrest to be refreshing. For the purposes of this review, Cameron spent around 10 hours playing the game multiple times, completing his first run in around four and a half hours.

Discussion

37 comments
leikeylosh
leikeylosh

Primary School Art Lessons: The Game

hitomo
hitomo

if you cant do graphics, there is no need to make a game at all ... seriously

Orontes13
Orontes13

One of the ugliest games I have ever seen. In a year populated with beautifully illustrated 2d games this one sticks out like a sore thumb.

Tr2et
Tr2et

Look much like a visual novel to me, with more choices and interaction but not that many of endings and after all there is only what the writer wanted us to see, not what we want it to be.


Anyway, I will see it as a sign of the "maturing of gaming".

jeager_titan
jeager_titan

You guys seriously reviewed an indian game? Cool. Not many coverage was on this game except in RPS.

DepressiveMan
DepressiveMan

Oh you guys actually review games before they come out now? A lot as change since that Divinity: OS review...

Pierce_Sparrow
Pierce_Sparrow

@hitomo Why? The only reason one would say that is if they have misplaced value in a game. If the characters, story, and gameplay are great, then graphics have a place down the list. Example: Deus Ex.

RogerioFM
RogerioFM

@hitomo lol what? that's the most moronic thing I've read in a while.

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

@jeager_titan 

I would caution that credit should go to the freelancer who submitted the review, not GameSpot as a whole.

RogerioFM
RogerioFM

@DepressiveMan Depressive Man, I'm here for you if you want to talk, I still have recurring dreams about bein a pineaple, but  we all got our problems, lean on me brother,

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

@DepressiveMan 

Not everyone appreciates sarcasm. :/

Also, you can make all those arguments about semantics and technicalities when responding to those other people, but I would make an opinion here: I think that you are being rather cynical.

I do wonder if anyone would agree with you.

Kevin-V
Kevin-V moderator staff

@DepressiveMan Dude, we got this relatively short game a week before release. We didn't get Divinity in advance, so I got to start playing an 80-hour game at the same time everyone else did. During that time, Wolf Among Us came out, and I had multiple appointments and interviews, alas, so while I devoted every possible moment to Divinity, I did take time to take my cat to the vet, sleep, and do a few other things in my available time in addition to playing Divinity. 


If you would like to complain that we did not receive a review copy in advance, you can direct that complaint to Larian. 


Edit: Also, you could just ask, or follow me on Twitter, where I always provide updates as to where I am in current reviews, rather than being a jerk.

Orontes13
Orontes13

@Pierce_Sparrow @hitomo While I dont agree with Hitomo... I must admit that the graphics is this game is just badly designed. They have obviously put effort into the graphics - its all hand painted. But its painted absolutely terribly.  Its a waste of effort and resources - it shows a lack of wisdom on the part of its makers. If you consider the history of art in India - they could have gone for millions of unique (never seen before in a video game) and gorgeous art-styles, instead they went for the generic primary school level water color. Its neither Indian, nor artistic, nor even functionally superior - its just terrible.

kozzy1234
kozzy1234

@LordCrash88 @DepressiveMan Dude Divinity is one of the biggest rpgs of the last 10 years. I have 169 hours logged in and still not done!


I for one am VERY glad Kevin took his time!

kozzy1234
kozzy1234

@DepressiveMan @Kevin-V You didn't hit a nerve you just posted just an ignorant comment that one can't help but either 1) laugh or 2) call you out on being a complete tool and not thinking before you post

The only one here who is being a jerk if you, someone who has no idea how big and how much content Divinity has in it. Kevin should be given compliments for not rushing through the game and doing regular UPDATES on his twitter as to how the reviews are coming.

Kevin-V
Kevin-V moderator staff

@DepressiveMan @Kevin-V No, you didn't hit a nerve. You made a snotty comment. If you have questions, they are easy to answer, and I am always happy to offer information with a smile. But it doesn't seem like you want answers, or better understanding--you just wanted to be snotty. I busted by ass to get the Divinity review done as quickly as I could, so I am not particularly inclined to respond to your snottiness with warm welcomes and polite nods. 

RogerioFM
RogerioFM

@Gelugon_baat @RogerioFM Could have, didn't and it was posted here. I'm not saying he shouldn't be credited, just reminding that we should credit all involved.

DepressiveMan
DepressiveMan

@Kevin-V @DepressiveMan I have to say, I'm confused, you went on a rant against me and called me a jerk for making a really inoffensive comment and then you say I didn't hit a nerve while going on another little rant? I'll just assume you're having a bad day or something, maybe you could use a little vacation.

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

@RogerioFM 

That would be up to the individual.

I personally am not so generous as to give credit to GameSpot, or any other site for that matter, for publishing the submission of a freelancer.

_Witchunter_
_Witchunter_

@DepressiveMan @Kevin-V Nope, it's you who's being a jerk.

There are other ways to provide feedback to GameSpot which are more mature than trying to be sarcastic about it (and failing in the process). Not that your negative comment had any solid ground given that they did not have a game sample up until release.

Also, is there some kind of a subscription model to GameSpot that I'm not aware of? Cause I can't see why you're being so arrogant when you're getting these reviews for free.

BrunoBRS
BrunoBRS

@Gelugon_baat @RogerioFM they did pay the freelancer though. which means they looked at it and thought "yes, this review is worth spending money on".

DepressiveMan
DepressiveMan

@_Witchunter_ @DepressiveMan @Kevin-V I wasn't providing feedback so I couldn't fail to do it,  the comment did have solid ground since the review did not go out before the game was released which is the only thing I said about it, it's an indisputable fact, and the argument that people can't complain when something is free has always been terrible, stop using it. I'm giving you a pile of shi t to eat and you can't complain about it because I'm giving it to you for free! But then again, I didn't actually complain, so the argument doesn't even apply to the current situation, but it's a bad argument.

BrunoBRS
BrunoBRS

@Gelugon_baat @BrunoBRS because the freelancer isn't a volunteer. his review is only published if the site thinks it's worth publishing, and if the site thinks it's worth publishing, then it pays the freelancer.

which means gamespot does deserve at least some credit for thinking a review of this game is worth putting on their site. and going by what you're saying, not many other sites bothered paying someone to review this game.

plus, it's not like the freelancer writes the reviews then start knocking on e-doors looking for people interested in buying. you can probably ask kevin vanord about how their freelancing works, but i imagine the freelancers get games assigned to them by the editors, which means it was gamespot's decision to get a freelancer to write a review for this game.

TL;DR: don't be so quick to be anti-corporation.

RogerioFM
RogerioFM

@Gelugon_baat @BrunoBRS Funny how people just want to be right and when someone provides a good argument the best they can do is provide a backhanded compliment.


Well done Bruno, explained things very clearly.

BrunoBRS
BrunoBRS

@Gelugon_baat @BrunoBRS just trying to get across that your "gamespot deserves no credit, the freelancer did all the work" attitude isn't right.

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

@BrunoBRS 

I will only concede if I am convinced that someone at GameSpot assigned the review of this game to a freelancer.

BrunoBRS
BrunoBRS

@Gelugon_baat @BrunoBRS that i cannot provide, but you shouldn't assume they didn't either.


plus, as my long winded post mentions, even then, gamespot is one of the very few sites that thought it deserved the attention of being published (going by jeager_titan's comment).

Unrest More Info

Follow
  • First Released
    • Macintosh
    • PC
    • Unix/Linux
    Legends tell of heroes, villains, and quests that save the world from darkness. The streets tell a different story. Unrest is a story driven RPG set in ancient India in the midst of an uprising. Play as ordinary men and women struggling for safety, freedom, food for their children, and a chance at peace.
    0
    Average User RatingOut of 0 User Ratings
    Please Sign In to rate Unrest
    Developed by:
    Pyrodactyl, Pyrodactyl Games
    Published by:
    KISS Ltd.
    Genres:
    Role-Playing