Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic Review

A number of technical issues in the out-of-the-box product mar what otherwise is the best version of one of the year's best games.

Canadian developer BioWare is well known for producing high quality role-playing games, thanks to its successful Baldur's Gate series, and offers up what is, in many ways, its finest such game to date in Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic. LucasArts wisely delegated the task of producing a deep and involving Star Wars-themed RPG to BioWare, which has done a remarkable job of making Knights live up to the Star Wars name. In fact, Knights arguably lives up to the Star Wars name better than any other Star Wars property in years, including the last two theatrical releases. The game's greatest accomplishment is its focused-yet-open-ended plot progression, which gives you the freedom to play as either a morally good or evil character--or shades in between. The struggle between good and evil is, of course, central to Star Wars and manifests itself extremely well throughout this outstanding game, which debuted on the Xbox earlier this year. For good measure, Knights features hours and hours of top-notch voice-over (all the dialogue is spoken), so you'll certainly be impressed by how different characters respond differently to you, and you'll also be impressed by the sheer size of the game. Sadly, a number of bugs and technical issues in the out-of-the-box product mar what otherwise is the best version of one of the year's best games.

Knights takes place thousands of years before the Star Wars films, but you'll recognize a lot of the technology.

Those who've played BioWare's computer RPGs--either the Baldur's Gate series or last year's Neverwinter Nights--will recognize the influence of these games on Knights of the Old Republic. In fact, the main difference between the gameplay of Knights and BioWare's previous games is superficial. This one is played from a third-person perspective and thus resembles a 3D action adventure game rather than one of BioWare's older isometric RPGs. Other than that, gameplay is similar. You create a main character and then explore many different areas, interact with many different characters, settle many different disputes, solve many different puzzles, and engage in plenty of combat. Combat appears to be in real time but actually uses a turn-based system "under the hood" just like Neverwinter Nights, which means that your character's statistics and attributes (and your strategy) make all the difference, and your personal reflexes and hand-eye coordination have no bearing on the outcome. Most importantly, Knights is very different from your average RPG in that you'll always be an active participant in the storyline, rather than a passive observer. You don't just read, watch, and listen to a lot of text, cutscenes, and dialogue; instead, your character is constantly invited and required to make difficult decisions, and that's ultimately the most entertaining, impressive, and rewarding aspect of the game. The interface has been completely overhauled for the PC release of the game, and it works exceptionally well by taking full advantage of the familiar mouse-and-keyboard controls you're used to from other games. Additionally, it gives you easy access to all your options, as well as your inventory, map, and quest log, at all times.

Knights of the Old Republic actually takes place thousands of years before Star Wars Episode I, though you'll still see many of the same sorts of alien creatures and technology in the game that you probably associate with Star Wars. The story begins in the midst of a power struggle between the Republic and the Sith, an evil Imperial power that's encroaching on Republic space. Your character seems to be just another Republic trooper, and, at the beginning of the game, you manage to avoid certain death as your spaceship is attacked and destroyed. Your escape pod lands on a world that's been put under quarantine by the Sith, so your first order of business is to find a means of escape. You also need to find out what happened to Bastila, a gifted young Jedi who is key to the Republic's war efforts and who also managed to flee your doomed ship. Later, you'll be charged with uncovering the secrets of an ancient relic, called the star forge, apparently the key to the Sith's seemingly limitless supply of weaponry.

You'll meet a wide variety of interesting characters in the game, a number of whom will join you in your journey.

You'll end up visiting a number of key Star Wars locations, including the wookie homeworld of Kashyyyk and the desert planet Tatooine, in what's, by all means, an adventure of epic proportions. The game's main storyline isn't remarkable and eventually boils down to squaring off against your standard bad guy, and the main plot twists along the way don't really seem plausible. You'll encounter so many great little subplots and characters as you go along that this really won't matter. You'll investigate murders, become a bounty hunter, resolve cultural disputes, find a cure for a deadly disease, take sides or play both sides against each other in various ambiguous conflicts, and find out how life really treats citizens of the Republic and followers of the Sith. There's just a lot to see and do in this game, and it'll last you a good 40 hours or so from start to finish. You'll never see all that the game has to offer if you finish it only once. Actually, the PC version of the game adds a good amount of new content that wasn't in the original Xbox release, and it mostly comes in the form of some powerful new items.

It may seem strange, but Knights of the Old Republic actually uses a slightly simplified version of 3rd Edition Dungeons & Dragons rules for both combat and character generation. So, despite the obviously different setting, fans of BioWare's D&D-themed games will be in relatively familiar territory here. Your main character starts off as a male or female soldier, scout, or scoundrel. These three basic classes roughly correspond to D&D's fighter, ranger, and rogue. The soldier is straightforward but very strong, and he or she begins with proficiencies in various types of weapons and armor and gains the most vitality points per experience level. The scout is slightly less tough than the soldier but gains more skill points per level, thus allowing him or her to do such things as repair droids, pick locks, and disarm land mines. The scoundrel is physically the weakest class but can disappear from sight by using special cloaking devices; after "cloaking" he or she can inflict great damage to a foe if that foe is caught unaware of the impending attack. The scoundrel is also best suited to talking his or her way out of situations where the other character classes might have to resort to violence. Your choice of gender also has a bearing on the outcomes of some situations.

It's not spoiling anything to point out that you eventually gain access to Jedi powers. In turn, there are three different Jedi classes available, which emphasize either the Jedi's prowess with a lightsaber, his or her Force powers, or a balance of the two. Force powers are basically like magic spells, allowing you to do such things as stun opponents, knock them down, and choke them. In addition, you can heal yourself and use the Force to persuade characters to see things your way (the option will come up at times during dialogue). Some powers are inherently light-inclined, while others are dark-inclined, and though Jedi characters may gain access to any Force power as they gain experience levels, powers that match a Jedi's moral alignment can be used at a lower cost in Force points (which steadily recharge, thus allowing you to use your powers continuously).

Will you choose the light or the dark side?

The game does a fine job of letting you customize your character and his or her companions. Nine main different characters may join you over the course of the adventure, and you'll be able to travel with up to two of them at a time. They mostly do a good job keeping pace, but in some of the more mazelike environments, they're liable to lag behind, which can be slightly annoying. Most every character has an interesting story to tell that unfolds as you converse with him, her, or it over the course of the game, though some are developed better than others. The most entertaining of the bunch is probably HK-47, who's like a homicidal and slightly insubordinate C-3PO. As you and the others gain levels, you develop your abilities by choosing from a wide variety of skills (repair, stealth, persuasion, and so on) and combat feats (critical strike, two-weapon fighting, toughness, and so on).

Ultimately, the 3rd Edition rule system works quite well for the game and makes for an experience that seems consistent with the Star Wars mythos. Namely, the game presents Jedi as extremely powerful beings against whom conventional weapons are practically useless when opposed to the Jedi's lightsabers and Force powers. However, a few things don't quite make sense, such as how your strength statistic (rather than your dexterity) is tied to your proficiency with a lightsaber and how ranged weapons generally seem too weak, thus offering no substantial advantages over melee weapons since it's easy to close the distance between you and a gun-toting opponent. Also, much like in 3rd Edition D&D, fighter-type characters in Knights of the Old Republic can become overpowered to the point where they're virtually unstoppable. If you focus on building up such a character, you'll find that most of the combat in the game will be rather easy at the default difficulty setting, though you can crank it up to make your enemies stronger.

Combat looks dynamic, and, at a glance, you could mistake Knights of the Old Republic for an action game. You'll see characters firing away with their blasters, while those armed with melee weapons, like lightsabers, will perform a variety of close-combat moves. Characters dueling with such weapons will block and feint while looking for openings in their opponents' defenses. It's all clearly inspired by the dramatic lightsaber battle at the end of Episode I and also resembles the outstanding lightsaber battles in the recent Jedi Academy and last year's Jedi Knight II.

Blasters, grenades, and melee weapons are available, but nothing beats a good ole double-bladed lightsaber.

Despite appearances, though, the combat is really just a series of statistical checks, just like D&D. Your character's "to hit" rating, determined by his or her class, level, and weapon, is added to a random 1-20 dice roll and is then compared against the opponent's defense rating. If the to-hit roll is greater, you connect and deal damage. Your characters will automatically attack any foes nearby until either you or they are all dead, so, in some cases, you end up simply watching the fight as it unfolds. You'll only need to intervene to use healing kits, stimulants that boost your combat abilities, Force powers, and the like. You may also intervene, if necessary, to prioritize targets. You can pause the action at any time and can easily queue up specific orders for all your characters, but you can usually get away with just looking after your main character and will rarely need to micromanage things (your party members will lag behind once in a while, as you're running around, but it's not a big deal). Generally, the combat is exciting to watch and is paced nice and fast. You needn't worry if one of your characters falls in battle, as he or she will simply get up once the fighting is over--though you're tossed back to the title screen if your entire party goes down.

The combat and the dialogue are the two main elements of Knights of the Old Republic. Other than these activities, you'll find yourself running from place to place, but you'll have little interaction with the environment other than being able to open footlockers and other objects that contain goodies. You can sometimes hack into certain computer systems, but this is all done in text and isn't very interesting. Loading times between areas can feel a little disruptive, especially when you have to backtrack. Fortunately, there's an option to instantly return to your hideout or ship if you're not in a dangerous area. Some of the environments are pretty big but most aren't, and a mapping system clearly shows where you can and can't go and what the points of interest are in each area. There's also a very clear record of all the quests you have pending (and all the quests you've completed). As such, you'll probably never get lost in the game, though, at the same time, you might feel a bit confined by where you can and can't go. Fortunately, the game opens up later on, thus allowing you to freely travel between planets to accomplish numerous tasks in whichever order you please.

Knights of the Old Republic also contains several minigames. You can gamble by playing a fairly entertaining card game that's similar to poker, you can compete in simple drag races on swoop bikes, and you can man the turrets of a spaceship to shoot down enemy fighters from a first-person perspective. These are all simple diversions, however.

Hours of expertly done voice-over help make character interaction incredibly engaging throughout Knights of the Old Republic.

As mentioned, character interaction really is the best thing about Knights of the Old Republic. There's a lot of dialogue in the game--all in full speech--and if you listen to all of it rather than read it (you can turn subtitles off), the game will probably last hours longer than it could otherwise. The dialogue is well done, and many of the game's characters are well defined. Most all of the numerous subquests in the game are suitably justified and present you with more than one viable solution. You'll constantly be able to choose between good and not-so-good solutions. Early on, for instance, you can rescue a man who's being hassled by bounty hunters. Do you then offer to pay the dues he owes so that the poor man may live without fear, or do you threaten to mug him for his last remaining credits?

Knights lets you play as a really nasty character if you so choose, and that's certainly part of the fun. It's also an interesting aspect of gameplay when you consider that a big part of the theme is how Jedi constantly run the risk of falling to the dark side. Indeed, you'll probably often be tempted to see what happens if you pick the evil dialogue options rather than the good ones, if only because most RPGs simply don't let you make these types of decisions. Certain key points in the game will play out very differently depending on the decisions you make, thus creating lots of replay value.

The graphics in Knights of the Old Republic are clearly a cut above BioWare's past RPGs. The PC version of the game looks mostly identical to the Xbox original but, provided you have a top-of-the line system and don't experience the sorts of technical issues we observed, it is capable of smoother frame rates at significantly higher resolutions, providing a significantly better visual experience overall. Some important aspects of the visuals are handled particularly well. Specifically, the lightsaber combat looks dead-on, though you won't see any forearms getting chopped off or anything. Effective use of bump mapping and environment mapping can be seen on some of the aliens and their shiny armor or slick, oily skins. Many of the environments also look quite good, though some of the others are plain and lacking in detail. Character models are relatively simple, and their lip-synching and facial expressions don't always look quite right. You'll also notice that some character models will repeat often throughout the game. You'll encounter a number of different characters who all share the same face. The frame rate of Knights of the Old Republic also doesn't hold up (even on systems well in excess of the game's recommended requirements), and it can frequently bog down in combat or whenever a lot of characters are around. Furthermore, the occasional cutscenes using the game's 3D engine tend to look downright crude, which is disappointing. Knights is a great-looking game overall, but it's easy to find fault in its visuals when the other aspects of the game are so well done.

It's also easy to become extremely disappointed with the game's technical issues. Your mileage may vary, but we experienced problems with the game on four different test systems, each with a different processor and graphics card. One system simply could not load the game at all after it had successfully been installed. Another system experienced graphical issues and sluggish frame rates, though it greatly exceeded the game's recommended system requirements. The third system encountered sporadic frame rate issues as well as some unavoidable crash bugs, which prevented us from progressing further into the game. A fourth system ran the game beautifully--though with occasional, spontaneous crashes to desktop later on in the game. A look at the official technical support forums for Knights of the Old Republic revealed that none of these issues seemed to be unique to our test systems, but no clear solutions to the problems were available either. It seems likely, then, that the PC version of Knights of the Old Republic wasn't thoroughly tested on many of today's standard PC configurations before it was shipped. It also seems likely that these problems will be addressed in a patch at some point (a beta patch that addressed certain specific problems was already available a few short days after the game's release), but it's still a shame that some players' experience with this otherwise outstanding game will be worsened or even cut short because of these embarrassing problems.

Knights is both an outstanding RPG in its own right and an excellent tribute to the Star Wars source material.

Technical issues aside, some of the audio is what you'd expect from a Star Wars game, though Knights deserves credit for featuring a mostly original (yet very subdued) soundtrack, which is a nice change of pace from the ubiquitous John Williams' score. The high quality and sheer quantity of the voice acting are exceptional. Alien characters even speak in convincing alien languages, though you'll pick up on the fact that the alien voice-over actually repeats often. Overall, though, the professional voice cast does an excellent job with the material by delivering believable performances, and this really enriches the gameplay experience. Not only does Knights of the Old Republic have some of the most voice-over of any game to date, but it also has some of the best.

Assuming the bugs don't deter you, it's apparent from playing Knights of the Old Republic that a remarkable amount of effort, work, and talent went into this game. It's one of the only Star Wars games that truly makes you feel, at times, as though you're a key player in and a part of this unique and beloved sci-fi setting. You'll get to do all the sorts of stuff that you've seen and enjoyed in the Star Wars movies, and you'll get to emulate any of your favorite characters' personalities and actions over the course of the game. You'll also experience a much more morally complex version of Star Wars than what you get from the movies. Along the way, you'll find a few aspects of the game that you'll wish were better, but that's mostly because the vast majority of Knights of the Old Republic is so exceptionally good. You don't need to be a fan of Star Wars or of RPGs to appreciate all the impressive qualities of this game--but if you are, all the better.

Other Platform Reviews for Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic

About the Author

Discussion

24 comments
snaketus
snaketus

So this got better review on the Xbox, but clearle PC version is superior. Why's that?

nate1222
nate1222

I own the PC version of KotOR, via Steam download, and it runs great. Fully patched and all.

Nightelf123
Nightelf123

sorry but i figured it out that xenon patch is not good.

 

Nightelf123
Nightelf123

this game itself wasn't perfect but with fixes like xenon patch 1.04 & patch 1.03 and another mod that fixing the bug adding content &... & biges difficulty this game will be the best RPG game that i have played

yankeesfan2
yankeesfan2

How could you guys think this is TOR? If you actually read the review, it says "Last year's Neverwinter Nights", Neverwinter Nights didn't come out last year, I think we all know that.

erragal
erragal

Well played hahaha. I fooled my self too, when i saw star wars 8.8, i was like "wtf are they srs"? Then i realize its about KOTOR and not TOR. And ye Kotor deserve that score and even better , it was such nice game back then.

crdeath27
crdeath27

@Banefire76 KOTOR2 wasn't made by Bioware, it was outsourced to Obsidian. Probably why the story was a hot mess

Banefire76
Banefire76

@ akimbobo Ah... u do realise this thread is for KOTOR and not TOR?

OrNiGhTZ
OrNiGhTZ

why is the username highlighted blue and not orange

akimbobo
akimbobo

I played this game for a few months in beta and there is still nothing to get me to pay 15 a month for this game. You can level way to fast, people did it in beta by just skipping the voice acting and by just playing by not skipping it. There is no challenge to the game, missions are way to easy to solo. Space is lame IMHO, you are being pulled down a tread mill and only able to go left, right, up and down. will give this game 3 to 6 months before even considering spending money on this game, there are still to many bugs from beta that players are complaining about and again I don't think there is enough end game content to keep people after the first few months. Too many MMO's have gone free to play that have tried to charge a monthly fee and I don't think this game has the replay value to do it. I could be wrong but reading the complaints on the forums and Facebook and playing it myself in beta this game has a ways to go.

fredwv
fredwv

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

fredwv
fredwv

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

kilaen
kilaen

Far too glowing a review for a mediocre game. After 1 week with it I think I'm done.

Groovychick1980
Groovychick1980

Have been playnig this game non stop for like 3 days and have not had one problem with it. Love this game

thenemesis2
thenemesis2

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

tenz01
tenz01

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

Banefire76
Banefire76

Interestingly Drew Karpyshyn was the lead writer on all the best Bioware games. Drew didnt work on KOTOR 2, he was going to be lead writer i think for TOR but was taken off it early on. if you do the maths i think bioware makes a mistake when not using him on game.

anwar1998
anwar1998

@Hamza141 : old reviews were only these text,no key points :P

Hamza141
Hamza141

longest review i have ever seen on gamespot

nate1222
nate1222

 @souther_hill

 Agreed. Bioware proved that the Star Wars universe can make for an awesome RPG. I'm not even a Star Wars fan, and KotOR ranks among my fav RPGs for PC. Hell, Jedi Outcast is among my fav FPSes.

Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic More Info

Follow
  • First Released
    • iPhone/iPod
    • Macintosh
    • + 2 more
    • PC
    • Xbox
    You don't need to be a fan of Star Wars or of RPGs to appreciate all the impressive qualities of this game--but if you are, all the better.
    9.2
    Average User RatingOut of 27316 User Ratings
    Please Sign In to rate Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic
    Developed by:
    BioWare
    Published by:
    Aspyr, LucasArts, Activision
    Genres:
    Role-Playing, Third-Person
    Content is generally suitable for ages 13 and up. May contain violence, suggestive themes, crude humor, minimal blood, simulated gambling and/or infrequent use of strong language.
    Teen
    All Platforms
    Violence