Play
Please use a flash video capable browser to watch videos.
00:00:00
Sorry, but you can't access this content!
Please enter your date of birth to view this video

By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's
Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Review

Red Dead Redemption Review

  • Game release: May 18, 2010
  • Reviewed:
  • X360

This stunning Wild West epic raises the bar for open world action games, and stakes its claim as one of the most engaging games this year.

As you ride the train west from the northern city of Blackwater, you have no idea what's waiting for you in the frontier town of Armadillo at the end of Red Dead Redemption's intro sequence. Conversations between other passengers clue you in to the state of the nation, and a quick look out of the window tells you that the territories are as untamed as they are beautiful. But it's not until you step off the train in the well-worn boots of protagonist John Marston and have to sidestep a drunk staggering out of the saloon that you realize how alive the world feels, and how much fun you're going to have exploring it. Similarities with recent Grand Theft Auto games are immediately apparent in the controls and the HUD, though both have been improved in subtle but important ways. Those basics, in conjunction with excellent gameplay, a great story, and a sizable multiplayer suite make Red Dead Redemption something very special.

When you arrive in Armadillo for the first time, you're a small fish in an extremely large pond. None of the townsfolk have ever heard of John Marston, and they're too busy believably going about their business to pay you much attention unless you bump into them. The gameworld stretches for miles in every direction beyond the confines of the modest town, and if it weren't for a number of mandatory missions that deftly familiarize you with the controls and gameplay mechanics early on, the prospect of venturing out into the wilderness could be daunting. Marston is a deeply flawed but very likable protagonist, and therefore it doesn't take long for him to start making friends in the New Austin territory. One of them, a ranch owner whom you meet early in the game, gives you both a place to stay (which doubles as a place to save your progress) and a horse to call your own, and it's at this point that you're more or less free to do as you please. Marston's lengthy and occasionally surprising story is linear for the most part, but it's told through missions that don't always need to be completed in a specific order, and you're free to ignore them for a time if you'd rather just explore the giant Wild West sandbox you're playing in.

Whether you're galloping between locations where there are missions available or just trotting around aimlessly, Red Dead Redemption's world is a far easier one to get sidetracked in than most. That's because in addition to the dozens of excellent and varied story missions, there are countless optional undertakings to enjoy--most of which offer some tangible reward in the form of money, weapons, or reputation. While you're in town, you might choose to gamble at card and dice tables or tear a wanted poster from the wall and do some bounty hunting, for example. And when you're in the middle of nowhere, opportunities for gunfights and the like have a habit of presenting themselves or even forcing themselves upon you. Random strangers in need of help can show up at any time, and while it's a little jarring to find two or three strangers in the same predicament back-to-back, most of their requests are varied and fun for the short time that they take to complete. You might be called upon to retrieve a stolen wagon, to collect herbs, or even to rescue someone being hanged from a tree. There's no penalty for ignoring strangers, but when you help them you collect a small reward and become a little more famous in the process.

This guy is about to get riddled with bullets, courtesy of the slow-motion dead eye mechanic.

Fame is interesting in Red Dead Redemption, because it's measured alongside but independently of your honor. Regardless of whether you're doing good deeds or bad, becoming increasingly famous is inevitable as you progress through the game. How people react when they recognize you is determined by your honor, though, which can be positive or negative. If you spend your time acting dishonorably, townsfolk might be terrified of you, but if you're considered a hero, they'll go out of their way to greet you and might even applaud as you ride into town. Either way, there are pros and cons to becoming something of a public figure. People won't bother to report you when you steal a horse if you're famous, and any bounty hunters or posses that come after you when there's a price on your head will take twice as long to try again after failing the first time, for example. On the flip side, as you make a name for yourself you become a target for gunslingers who are looking to make names for themselves, and so you're challenged to duels that play out entirely using the game's slow-motion "dead eye" mechanic.

In duels, even though speed is a factor, dead eye affords you an opportunity to place your shots precisely. The head is the most obvious target, but occasionally you might be required to (or wish to) win a duel without actually killing your opponent. With practice, you can shoot a gun out of an enemy's hand as he makes his move, which is especially satisfying and makes you more famous than killing someone outright. Dead eye can be used in much the same way during regular play, but a slowly replenishing meter limits how often you can trigger it, and given how effective the lock-on targeting system is, you're unlikely to need it much. With the exception of sniper rifles, you can lock on to enemies from a great distance with any weapon. Then, once you're locked on, you can tweak your aim to target a specific part of your enemy. Nudge your aim up just a touch, and there's a good chance you'll get a one-hit-kill headshot. (You do that so often that it's likely to become a reflex every time you raise your weapon). However, you don't always want to kill your enemies, because, for example, once you learn to use a lasso, you have the option to bring bounties in alive. It's more challenging, but it also doubles your reward, and it's extremely satisfying to shoot a criminal in the leg so that he falls to ground and can only try to crawl away, hog-tie and slump him over the back of your horse, and then deliver him to the local sheriff.

When accompanying other characters, you can easily match your speed to theirs.

You can also use your lasso to rope wild horses, which is a fun way to upgrade or just replace the mount that you spend so much time with. After catching a wild horse, you wait for just the right moment to mount it and then, via a simple minigame in which you maintain your balance as the horse tries to buck you, you break it. Initially, you might want to change your horse just to get a color that you like (there are lots to choose from), but it's also fun to keep a lookout for rare breeds, because they not only look a little more impressive but are also noticeably quicker. Regardless of what kind of horse you ride (including those that are pulling carts and wagons), the responsive controls work in the same way and make it easy to adjust your speed from a walk to a trot, canter, or gallop. You also have the option to match your speed with that of any character you're riding alongside, which is incredibly useful.

As you spend more time with the same horse, it rewards your loyalty by increasing the length of its energy bar, which determines how long it can sprint at full speed. You shouldn't become too attached to your mounts, though, because Red Dead Redemption's world is both a dangerous place and one in which horses occasionally behave unpredictably. There's nothing wrong with a horse walking around a little when you climb off it, but if you leave it close to a deep river, you run the risk of losing it if--as we witnessed on one occasion--it stupidly steps in, because, like you, horses can't swim. Horses also have a habit of not staying put when you tie them to a hitching post, so you then need to whistle for them to come to you from wherever they've ended up or run the risk of inadvertently stealing someone else's identical mount. Other, more avoidable ways to lose a horse include its getting shot by enemies or attacked by wild animals, though the controls for shooting from the saddle are good enough that you really have only yourself to blame if that happens.

Red Dead Redemption's varied wildlife adds a great deal to the world and also makes it a dangerous place to let your guard down. Crows, hawks, eagles, and vultures fly overhead; armadillos, raccoons, deer, and skunks try to stay out of your way; and cougars, coyotes, wolves, and even snakes can be dangerous if they see you before you see them. All of these species and lots more inevitably cross your path, and whether they're solitary creatures or hunting as a pack, their behavior is always believable. Furthermore, all of these animals can be hunted and then--via an animation that sees blood spattering on the screen--harvested for their skins, meat, and other valuable body parts. Beavers, boars, bobcats, bears, buffalo, bighorn--all have something to offer, and all pose a slightly different challenge.

Other than the fun of the hunt, the main reason to kill most of these animals is so that you can sell the aforementioned body parts to a store owner the next time you're in town. Sometimes, though, there are additional incentives in the form of ambient challenges that, as the name suggests, reward you for objectives that you might complete in the course of regular gameplay. For example, sharpshooter challenges include shooting people's hats off and shooting birds out of the sky from a moving train. Hunter challenges, on the other hand, include one-shotting grizzly bears and taking down a pack of wolves using only a knife. For a change of pace, treasure hunter challenges present you with a treasure map that often amounts to little more than sketches of a landmark, and challenge you to locate the treasure hidden nearby. You become a little more famous every time you complete one of these challenges, and beating a significant number of them is a requirement for unlocking at least one of the different outfits that Marston can change into.

Marston is an impressively detailed character whose scarred face and default outfit play big parts in making him wholly believable as a 30-something gunslinger. Other than donning a bandana that covers much of your face (and hides your identity so that you don't affect your fame or honor while performing certain actions), there's nothing you can do about the scars, but by putting on a different outfit you can change how certain people react to you. There are more than a dozen different outfits to discover and unlock. Some of them, like the duster jacket and the poncho, are easy to unlock and offer no real benefit other than making you look even more dangerous. Others, though, such as military and gang uniforms, can be obtained only after completing multiple challenges, and wearing them makes certain factions more accepting of you. There are even a couple of outfits that can make gambling more fun: one gives you the option to cheat anytime you deal in a game of poker, and another--acquired by signing up for the Rockstar Social Club--grants you access to a high-stakes game.

Believe it or not, even while cheating at cards and gunning down hundreds of enemies, it's possible--with only one exception during a plot-critical mission--to make it through Red Dead Redemption's entire story without ever getting on the wrong side of the law. It's fun to play as a heroic bounty hunter, but it's also fun to be chased by one, or several. Much like the system in GTA, being spotted committing a crime alerts local law enforcement, and until you outrun them, they pursue you relentlessly. Your crimes aren't completely forgotten the moment you escape in Red Dead Redemption, though, because every crime that you commit raises the bounty on your head, and the only way to clear that is to visit a telegraph operator and either pay the amount of your bounty yourself as a fine or present him with a letter of pardon--which isn't easy to come by. It's a great system, because in conjunction with fame and honor it really makes you feel like your actions have lasting consequences.

Shooting from mounts and wagons works every bit as well as shooting on foot.

Depending on how much time you spend completing optional challenges, Red Dead Redemption's single-player mode can take you anywhere from 20 to 40 hours to play through. If you're in a rush to get through the game for some reason, you can use stagecoaches and quick travel options to move between key locations on the gigantic map instantly, but there's so much fun to be had out in the wilderness that bypassing those areas isn't recommended. You should also know that while bugs and glitches are few and far between, there's at least one stagecoach driver who apparently isn't great at math and might inexplicably charge you $100 (not an insignificant sum of money, given that it's enough to buy property) on top of the quoted price for a journey. Other problems worthy of note during our 30-plus hours in single-player included a conversation between Marston and another character in which only Marston's lines could be heard, an attempt to crouch behind a decrepit overturned wagon that resulted in Marston being thrown high up into the air, and a cutscene in which two versions of the same character--one injured and animated, one neither--appeared alongside each other. You might also notice characters having some pathfinding problems when confronted by hitching posts, stacks of crates, and the like, but beyond these extremely rare issues, the world of Red Dead Redemption is very difficult to find fault with. It looks incredible, it sounds superb (though the excellent soundtrack occasionally swells up without reason), and it's just a fun place to spend time regardless of what you're doing or whom you're doing it with.

In addition to its lengthy single-player offering, Red Dead Redemption boasts a good number of multiplayer modes that support both competitive and cooperative play. No matter which mode you want to play, all multiplayer sessions start out in Free Roam. Here, you and up to 15 other players are free to do whatever you please with the entire gameworld at your disposal. You can shoot each other, you can cause trouble with townsfolk, you can form posses to complete gang hideout missions, or you can become the session's most wanted outlaw and then kill or steer clear of any other players who come looking to collect the bounty on your head. Your character in Free Roam mode is persistent, and as you earn experience points you gain access to additional character models, better weapons, and superior mounts. It's unfortunate that you don't get to design a character from scratch, and it can be frustrating to enter Free Roam as a level-one player riding a burro and armed only with a pistol, but it doesn't take long to level up, and even high-level players can be killed with just a few bullets if you can get close to them.

In multiplayer, the entire map is your playground.

When you enter competitive online modes, you don't get to use your persistent character, and everyone is on a level playing field. The five modes on offer are free-for-all and team-based versions of Shootout and three versions of Capture the Bag. Clearly, these modes are variations on the traditional deathmatch and capture-the-flag themes, but they do more than just apply a Wild West lick of paint to them. For starters, all multiplayer games kick off with an awesome standoff in which all players stand around in a circle (or in two opposing lines if it's a team game) and wait for all hell to break loose when the word "Draw" appears on the screen. And in Capture the Bag modes, the bags of gold that you carry weigh you down so that you move more slowly, making you an easy target in the free-for-all Gold Rush and making escorts or cover fire vital in the team-based Hold Your Own.

Between the Free Roam and competitive modes, there's enough great multiplayer content to keep you playing Red Dead Redemption long after you've watched the credits roll at the end of the superb single-player mode and gone back in to finish up any optional challenges and missions that you missed. This is an outstanding game that tells a great story with memorable and occasionally laugh-out-loud-funny characters. Think about great moments that you remember from spaghetti Western movies, put them all into one 20- to 40-hour epic feature, and picture yourself in the starring role. Now you have some idea of what's waiting for you in Red Dead Redemption.

The Good
Superb cast of memorable characters
Varied and always-fun story missions
Loads of optional activities and challenges
Story does a great job of building up to multiple climaxes
Good number of enjoyable multiplayer options
The Bad
Infrequent but noticeable bugs
Limited customization options for persistent multiplayer character
9.5
Superb
About GameSpot's Reviews
Other Platform Reviews for Red Dead Redemption

About the Author

Discussion

40 comments
Jasper_73
Jasper_73

I wish Rockstar would do another Red Dead Redemption game..... Am still waiting on sp dlc for gtav; ah well guess i have to be patient.

Securator
Securator

This is kinda sad to admit...but i missed this game during launch because i had to quit gaming for some stupid reasons....now that I'm playing games again....i was considering purchasing this....so what i wanna ask is this...Is this game enjoyable and relevant even now in 2014....after GTA V...???

Epak_
Epak_

Just got the game for mah Xbox, can't believe I waited so long to play it!

sofijadante
sofijadante

These is one maserpiece ! and it doesn't deserve 9.5 it deservs 100 !

Harbinger_CR
Harbinger_CR

Red Dead Redemption > GTA4 and GTA5 combined

advocacy
advocacy

Three years later, GTA V gets a score of 9.0, and Red Dead Redemption is still higher at 9.5.  =)

famos_ga
famos_ga

this game is PANDEMONIUM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! as seth would say

Peurra-37
Peurra-37

john marston is fucking awsome, it is very sad that he died but he died like a legend

malachi_27
malachi_27

I seriously need to buckle down and play this thing.  I purchased it the week of release and have yet to finish.

B_STATS
B_STATS

I don't understand how this got a 9.5 but GTA4 got 10... RDR is superior in every way to most games available today.

thequickshooter
thequickshooter

this game was perfect in almost every way

one thing always pissed me off in the campaign is that one mission you have to do for the mexican officials is to burn an entire villige just so can the general rape the girls of the villige 

if that shit was optinal i would give this game a 10 

but that mission was so bullshit, why couldn't john just help the rebels first? 

so much for non-linear 

The_GooBear
The_GooBear

Best game ever. I've never even watched a western, it just feels so real.

zekepliskin
zekepliskin

Describing it as "GTA on a horse" really doesn't do it justice.  Unlike GTA4, which felt painfully linear and unrealistic at times as compared to San Andreas, the world of Red Dead Redemption feels alive and vibrant, and really is best enjoyed on the biggest HDTV you can find, especially if it has a surround sound system so you can really become immersed.

 

It's one where almost all the sidequests and optional missions are worth doing, especially the "legendary animals" trilogy where you hunt down Khan the Jaguar etc.  In fact one of the great joys of the game is becoming a skilled hunter/gathered type - even though the storyline is pretty decent and has several memorable missions that equal or better the jetpack/harrier missions in GTA:SA, it's the literal wide open sandbox that really impresses.  Seriously, just go a-wandering in the wilderness while showing a friend who hasn't played it like I did, and they'll probably be stunned by things that pop up, like stopping a safe being robbed, helping a damsel in distress, successfully stopping someone stealing your horse, trying not to die at the hands of bears and cougars.

 

All in all it's a fantastic achievement, and like Bully stands as one of the best Rockstar Games efforts yet.  Sadly, just like Bully, I very much doubt there will be a sequel which does make it more unique and special but seems like with the eighth generation of consoles around the corner something of a missed opportunity.

 

Oh, and not to add more fuel to the long-burning console wars of the seventh generation, the Xbox360 version is graphically superior to the PS3 one: you can play it in full 1080p rather than being limited to 720p, the frame rate is set higher so gameplay is smoother, and I swear the textures are just a tad more detailed.  Whichever one you play though, you WILL have a great time if you really dive in and try everything that's on offer.

anaswardat
anaswardat

one of the best and unique games i have ever played !!! am really sad that i finished it .   :(

sahandak1367
sahandak1367

F*** you for giving this awesome game just 9.5!!!!!! If one game deserves a 10, it's this one you F***in morons!!!!!!

mhmd1
mhmd1

Got it in the mail last night as a late birthday present. 2 hours into 1p and maybe a half hour into multiplayer and it already seemed pretty frigggin awesome.

VINNYHERMAN
VINNYHERMAN

G0D@MN~~

Just p/u the last unopened copy for $29 @ G/Spot (game of da year edition to boot!) CANNOT WAIT to play this title ,FN AWESOME game/idea  R/*

5000man
5000man

i want a pc version

POWXR
POWXR

Probably the best game ever made.

vivalatour
vivalatour

unique all the way baby ! if this was not in "caps" it's because R* to often mentions something and builds up hype when the game is light years away ! ...

 Sorry R* I apologize and please have patience with me < I always wanted to say that because I hear it from R* a lot ! ... GET THE GAMES DONE !

Zephol
Zephol

one of the best game ever

The_Gaming_Baby
The_Gaming_Baby

@Jasper_73  Don't you worry. When it comes to another Red Dead game it isn't a question of if, but when

dipdish
dipdish

@advocacy It deserves a sharp 10 points. It could have been 10/10 on Gamespot, if Rockstar'd cleared all the bugs, I guess.

mr_azim
mr_azim

@malachi_27 It's a great game, really.  Tons of fun..... the only unfortunate thing is once you beat it, there's no fun-value like GTA (no helicopters in the wild west lol).

Keivz_basic
Keivz_basic

@turtlethetaffer 

Agreed. I just finished it and I found a large chunk of it to be boring. And though the world is painstakingly rendered, the music is downright dull. The story wasn't very compelling either. I wish there were badasses/bosses in the world that you had to pit your skill against or something to that effect. Oh, well--8/10.

Arda_Daghan212
Arda_Daghan212

@zekepliskin There probably will be another sequel to Red Dead series, because Redemption is actually a sequel to Revolver. Not in story though. Bully, maybe. R* tends to take their time with these sort of games. They do have money and they deliver quality games so, they don't really go for annual releases, not even close I know. But DLC and things like that that come out for these games are always worth downloading or buying in my opinion.

turtlethetaffer
turtlethetaffer

@sebbi11 @turtlethetaffer 

I still enjoyed the game. It had a lot of good qualities to it, particularly the shooting, which had an excellent feeling of power and reaction. But there were many flaws to it, so I don't really get why the game got so many good ratings.

Arda_Daghan212
Arda_Daghan212

@Keivz_basic @turtlethetaffer It's not your kind of game. With the story and the gameplay and the beautiful environment I thought it deserved the rate it got, also with the multiplayer, extremely fun, but I like playing with my character as if I was playing Sims (or Skyrim in that case) and the game didn't offer that but oh well.

turtlethetaffer
turtlethetaffer

@Arda_Daghan212 @Keivz_basic @turtlethetaffer 

What was so great about the story? Aside from the ending, it just seemed like a whole lot of errands to run for bizzare people. The gameplay was really only fun when shooting, which hinders the open world. Sure, there are things to do in it, but the only ones that are really enjoyable are the ones that involve shooting. Game is still good, but hardly a masterpiece.

Red Dead Redemption More Info

  • Released
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox 360
    Red Dead Redemption is a third-person open-world adventure featuring reformed outlaw John Marston who is on a quest to save his family.
    9.2
    Average User RatingOut of 21628 User Ratings
    Please Sign In to rate Red Dead Redemption
    Developed by:
    Rockstar San Diego
    Published by:
    Take-Two Interactive, Rockstar Games, Rockstar San Diego
    Genres:
    3D, Open-World, Adventure, Action
    Content is generally suitable for ages 17 and up. May contain intense violence, blood and gore, sexual content and/or strong language.
    Mature
    All Platforms
    Blood, Intense Violence, Nudity, Strong Language, Strong Sexual Content, Use of Drugs