Memento Mori 2: Guardians of Immortality Review

Better off dead.

Some adventure games are epic journeys across varying locales. Memento Mori 2: Guardians of Immortality tries to be. It tries to tell a Da Vinci Code-esque story of murder and intrigue with clues hidden in artwork and a quasi-religious journey spanning several countries. Sadly, Memento Mori 2: Guardians of Immortality is a below-average adventure plagued by bad localization from its original European release.

You primarily play as two recently married characters, Lara and Max, with the majority of time spent controlling the former. Lara is a detective who specializes in art-related crime, while her husband, Max, who's an artist, is mostly tagging along because they're on vacation together. What begins as a simple art theft investigation (because that's the best way for newlyweds to spend time together away from home) evolves into an increasingly convoluted tale of conspiracy, murder, and spirituality.

Why hello there, you studly stud you. I just love how you unbutton your top button. Oh yeah.

It's a standard point-and-click adventure in just about every way. Click on places you want to go, things you want to look at, or items you want to use. Some items can be carried in your inventory, often with no satisfying explanation of why ("Oh look, fresh asphalt! Don't mind if just stick some of that in my pocket for later"). Items can also be examined close up, and occasionally they can be combined, which helps you solve a variety of puzzles with often unconventional solutions. All in all, it's really just par for the course for the genre, which isn't inherently a bad thing, though it's certainly unoriginal.

Memento Mori 2: Guardians of Immortality is a below-average adventure plagued by bad localization from its original European release.

The real issue is that Memento Mori 2 is cobbled together from subpar pieces, a fact made worse by poor localization in terms of both translation and voice acting. Character models might look OK when standing still, but every animation looks stilted and unnatural. The dialogue and overall story range from uninteresting to bad, and many awkward phrases betray the fact that their writers are not native English speakers.

Nobody in Memento Mori 2 knows how to hold a phone against their ear.

And that's to say nothing of various bugs and errors, including one particularly troublesome issue where certain characters sometimes say the wrong line at the wrong time. The subtitle will be correct, but the audio is completely out of place, and may accidentally give away dialogue that is supposed to be uttered later. A slightly less jarring but still awkward issue is that many lines sound as if they aren't said by their actual actors, but rather by stand-ins trying (and failing) to imitate them. One line is delivered by the actor you're used to, and then the voice is different for the very next sentence before switching back again. Even basic audio mixing is a problem; characters on the other end of phone calls are practically inaudible.

In concept, though, Memento Mori 2 aims high, and there are brief moments when there seems to be an unpolished gem somewhere under the dirt of bad animation and voice work. During the globe-trotting plot, you are occasionally faced with choices that feel as if they might have interesting and important repercussions--but they don't. Sure, your ending might change slightly if you decide to hand over a resignation letter, and a scene where you can (if you choose to) hide certain pieces of evidence almost succeeds in adding tension to the situation, but for the most part, these choices feel more like missed opportunities than meaningful actions.

That might be OK if more than a handful of puzzles in the game were interesting. Sadly, many of Memento Mori 2's puzzles are good only on paper. For example, a relatively early puzzle has you dusting for and then comparing fingerprints, an action that is reasonable in the context of the story's investigation (though the character analyzing this evidence has no reason to know this skill) and can require a certain level of thought to execute. In practice, however, holding fingerprint samples side by side is less exciting than your everyday "spot the difference" style of puzzle. Furthermore, the common adventure game frustration of being stuck purely because you didn't spot the tiny item or clue on a single screen is here in full effect, though it's alleviated somewhat by the ability to highlight clickable objects with a button press.

Sorry, we ate the pizza on the way to the door. Can we still have the money?

But even that pales in comparison to the many actions you perform that are just plain boring. At one point in the game, you need to print some photos. But oh no, that darn printer is giving an error message. It's a paper jam, so you should open it up to fix that problem. Just find the switch to open the cover. But wait! You need to remove the toner first. You can't just pull the toner cartridge out, so find the switch that releases it. There, OK, now you can remove the paper jam and print what you need to print--after you put the toner back, obviously. It's all the tedium of an office job without the exhilaration of a paycheck.

Toward the end, Memento Mori 2's plot almost gets interesting. After hours of the game's own protagonist complaining that none of the plot details make sense, the game promises to explain everything and tie it all together after you stop a killer and maybe save the world or something. But that explanation isn't at all satisfying, leaving you with nothing to show from a rather boring expedition around the globe. If this is what immortality is about, then you have to wonder why anyone would bother to guard it in the first place.

The Good
A handful of puzzles are interesting
The Bad
Lackluster writing is worsened by a bad translation
Most puzzles are boring
Audio bugs and quirks make bad acting even worse
Animations never look natural
4
Poor
About GameSpot's Reviews

About the Author

Britton Peele has been on The Longest Journey, sailed to Monkey Island, and linked to Myst a half-dozen times. He's usually up for a good adventure, but he wishes he'd stayed home for this one.

Discussion

10 comments
drjoenh
drjoenh

Memento Mori, as some may know, translates from latin into "remember that you will die", which is this own game's self-fulfilling prophecy, truly a masterful critique on the futility of trying to be better than one's fate, which they ought to have known was doomed from the planning stages of this atrocity.

chibistevo32
chibistevo32

Memento Mori 


if the nineth lion ate the sun

Warlord_Irochi
Warlord_Irochi

Seems in europe either me make masterpiece or pure crap. No middle-mark :/

cxxal
cxxal

I played the first game, it was not good....

Hurvl
Hurvl

Meh-mento mori, more like it, heh.

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

I suppose that some adventure game designers haven't been doing research on what is the informal "bar" for the genre.

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

@liquidbutter

I have written user reviews for adventure titles which I have played already. I do research on their development history and such as well as compare them against that of other games. 

Yet, I am having the impression that you are making a "don't criticisize if you can't do better" remark, aren't you?

Gelugon_baat
Gelugon_baat

@liquidbutter  

I see what you intend by that query. ;)

Alright, I will admit here that the only answer which I have for that is that the informal 'bar' is not anything which the reviewer had criticized, but that's of course a rather subjective statement. Also, certainly, there's no official "bar", and I will admit too that I covered my ass with the addition of the quotation symbols and the phrase "informal".

Still, I haven't seen anyone who would say that Centauri Production's games are up there with the likes of vaunted titles by its European peers, such as Broken Sword by Revolution Software (United Kingdom) and the Deponia series by Daedalic Entertainment (Deutschland).

Memento Mori 2 - Guardian of Immortality More Info

Follow
  • Unknown Release Date
    • PC
    Memento Mori 2 - Guardian of Immortality is the sequal to dtp entertainment's original title.
    0
    Average User RatingOut of 0 User Ratings
    Memento Mori 2 - Guardian of Immortality has not been released yet!
    Developed by:
    Centauri Production
    Published by:
    DTP Entertainment
    Genres:
    Adventure
    Not yet assigned a final ESRB rating. Appears only in advertising, marketing and promotional materials related to a game that is expected to carry an ESRB rating, and should be replaced by a game's rating once it has been assigned.
    Rating Pending
    All Platforms