Marvel Trading Card Game Review

Marvel TCG isn't too bad as far as digital trading-card games go, but it's unlikely to convert anyone not already invested in TCGs.

by

Upper Deck Entertainment, one of the more prominent purveyors of collectible trading card games today, has teamed up with Konami to bring Upper Deck's Marvel-licensed TCG to the Nintendo DS with the succinctly, if dryly, named Marvel Trading Card Game. It seems like a solid representation of Upper Deck's robust, flexible, and rather popular Vs. System Trading Card Game, and it packs a feature-rich online element that's already teeming with activity. As is the case with most digitized TCGs, it's not a particularly exciting game to watch. If you're not already knee-deep in the real-world Vs. System Trading Card Game, or other similarly advanced TCGs, it can be a confusing experience, as well.

Was Marvel Trading Card Game really the best name Konami could muster up?

In concept, Marvel Trading Card Game is a straightforward exercise in strategy. Two players, each armed with a deck of cards, take turns "attacking" one another by playing various cards with unique characteristics until one player has had all of his or her hit points depleted. Cards are divided into several different categories: characters, equipment, locations, and plot twists. Characters are probably the most significant cards, as these are what you'll use to actually attack your opponent, while equipment and locations can be used to enhance their abilities. Plot twists are also of great import, due largely to the wide range of effects they can have, from simply buffing up one of your character cards for a turn to forcing your opponent to discard cards. Plot twists can also be chained together, which can potentially cause several reversals of fortune within a single character clash.

Before you can put any characters into play, though, you'll need to meet their resource requirements. You can choose to play any card in your hand as a resource at the start of your turn, similar to the way mana cards are played in Magic: The Gathering. Likewise, you can only add a single card to your resources during any given turn, which generally causes the action to build up slowly over the course of a match, since it will take time to garner the necessary resources to put your more powerful characters into play. There's certainly a significant element of luck to your success, since you'll be drawing cards randomly from your deck, but there are several thick layers of strategy to it as well. Which characters you play is important, as each has a unique attack and defense rating that will determine how it'll fare against other characters, but where you actually place them on the playing field can matter just as much. There are two rows you can play your characters in--front and back--and how they'll behave when placed in either can depend on whether they have flight abilities and ranged attacks. Where they're placed in proximity to other characters that share their team affiliation matters, too.

All of these elements can make for some really interesting play, if you can figure out what's actually going on. There's a series of interactive tutorials to help beginners, which are helpful, though you'll ultimately still have to jump in feet first to fully understand the ins and outs of the game. Even then, the interface is densely crammed into the screen, with loads of tiny, obscure icons used to signify lots of important stuff. Plot-twist chains, which will regularly determine the outcome of a specific confrontation, can be especially difficult to keep track of due to the way they're presented. Though the game does try to spruce things up with some nice background and card art, as well as some light particle effects, it can still look like some kind of alien tax return.

How about 'Marvel Card Battle' or 'Marvel Hero Clash'? We just came up with those, right now.

If you can get a hang of it, though, Marvel Trading Card Game features several ways to play. There are two unique and lengthy single-player campaigns to play through, putting you in the role of either hero or villain. You can play against a live opponent locally, as well as online. The PSP version of Marvel Trading Card Game that came out a few months ago featured all forms of user-created and sponsored tournaments, as well as the promise of interoperability with the still forthcoming PC version. However, on the DS, you're limited to jumping into a game with an anonymous stranger or playing folks with whom you've already exchanged Friend Codes. To its credit, though, the touch-screen support in the DS version can make navigating the game's dense interface a little more intuitive. Also, the game is played by holding the DS sideways, as if it were a book. It uses the top to give you a big, easy-to-read version of the card you currently have selected, which is a plus.

With its good implementation of the well-known Vs. System, Marvel Trading Card Game will make those who've already got a taste for TCGs quite happy, and it makes pretty good use of the Marvel license on top of that. It's a step up in sophistication from the Yu-Gi-Oh! games that Konami has been churning out for years. Still, it's a shame that the game's depth gets in the way of its accessibility to a wider audience.

The Good
Good execution of vs. system trading card game
solid online play
The Bad
Not friendly to trading card game newcomers
interface a challenge to decrypt
6.5
Fair
About GameSpot's Reviews
Other Platform Reviews for Marvel Trading Card Game

About the Author

Discussion

0 comments

Marvel Trading Card Game

  • DS
  • PC
  • PSP
Based on Upper Deck Entertainment's best-selling Vs. System Trading Card Game, Marvel Trading Card Game features Marvel's complete stable of characters such as Spider-Man, the X-Men, the Avengers, Ghost Rider, the Fantastic Four, The Hulk and more.
ESRB
Teen
All Platforms
Alcohol and Tobacco Reference, Blood, Mild Fantasy Violence, Mild Language, Suggestive Themes
Check out even more info at the Marvel Trading Card Game Wiki on Giantbomb.com