Infinite Undiscovery Review

Infinite Undiscovery feeds your need for narrative, but it's ultimately a shallow, flawed experience.

Role-playing games strike a tricky balance between gameplay and narrative that is easy to take for granted when everything goes together correctly. Infinite Undiscovery is sadly an example of how flawed design and myriad imperfections can mar an otherwise enjoyable adventure. Square Enix manages to provide the frame of a role-playing game epic that falls short on execution.

When the world is in danger, be sure to ask nearby furry creatures for assistance.

The world of Infinite Undiscovery is influenced heavily by the moon, which is home to a god who is revered as a source of magical blessing. Humans who are born under auspicious moon phases are tattooed with sigils known as Lunaglyphs, which grant power and the ability to cast spells. Everything's in disarray because a group called the Order of the Chains has shackled the moon to the earth, disrupting the normal flow of power and bringing the two heavenly bodies on a collision course. The people's only hope is Sigmund the Liberator, a man with the ability to cut the chains and restore the world to normal. Capell, the protagonist, is a cowardly musician who mysteriously is a twin to Sigmund in appearance, which gets him unwillingly wrapped up in the troubles of nations.

All of the characters are well defined, and it's easy to come to know and grow fond of them through the game's preponderance of narrative cutscenes (some silly dialogue notwithstanding). Whether it's Capell getting thoroughly browbeaten by the idealistic princess Aya, the adorable scamps Rico and Rucha chatting in excitement, or the serene priest Eugene offering some sage insight while adjusting his glasses, you're always learning something new about the characters and their motivations. You'll have close to 20 playable characters by the end, and though some are better fleshed out than others, many are likable. The narrative itself is engaging but at the same time feels a little light on depth, some of which is due to the gameworld.

Wedged between all of the storytelling mania is the gameplay, which sees you roaming the world in search of chains to smash and people to aid. One of the problems with both the world zones and many of the dungeons in the game is that you're often given very loose guidance about where to travel (such as "south"), and the areas themselves are huge and can be lengthy. Combine winding paths that have multiple nooks and crannies with a mapping system that relies on you discovering areas in very narrow swaths, and the whole thing feels less like exploring a world and more like a way to make you wander around and cut through enemies. With such huge outdoor zones, there are a surprisingly small number of towns to visit, which makes the lands that you wander through feel empty and lonely. You'll also have to retrace your steps quite a bit, which will get tiresome around the fifth time that you've had to cross the same desert.

Battle is completely real-time and action-oriented. You'll always be controlling Capell, and you have a few simple AI settings for your party members that you can cycle through using the D pad. Once you're in range, you'll target the nearest enemy--but it's not an autolock for attack purposes, so you'll have to continually move around to try to score hits on mobile foes. This is somewhat of a pain if you're trying to connect with an ability that involves a lengthy animation. Capell can execute quick attacks and strong slashes, and you can bind two special skills that will be activated when you hold down the A or B button. Attacking an enemy in succession will start a combo meter that you can build through your own hits and those of your friends. Using the connect feature, you can issue orders on the fly to a specific ally to use his or her special attacks, which is good for combo-building or solving some of the game's dungeon puzzles. The X button will play your flute, which lets you perform various tunes that will reveal hidden passages or enemies, or shield your party from harmful magic.

Use your connection abilities to assassinate harmless barrels.

The action is fast-paced and can be quite satisfying when you're unleashing large combo strings, but there are some problems. One is the camera, which is zoomed in so close that you can't see a lot of your field of action without panning around regularly, particularly if you're hemmed into a corner. Your view is also often obscured by an orgy of sword slices and light effects from special attacks, which can trigger some graphical slowdown. You can use the Y button to call for your party members to use healing spells or items, but occasionally they'll take their own sweet time getting it done, leading to their deaths. If you take matters into your own hands and have to open the menu during battle, you have to run to a hopefully safe location because the menu doesn't pause the game while you're sorting through and trying to find your favorite restorative. Another fun twist is that if you die, you have to just lie there and hope that one of your party members is able to cast a resurrection spell or use an item at some point while your timer ticks down, otherwise it's game over. Once Capell goes down, you cannot issue orders, access the menu, or do anything else until you come back to life, no matter how many of your party members are still up and running around.

In addition to normal fights, there are a few timed events in which you'll have to complete an objective while simultaneously fighting against the clock. Frustratingly, these events can be nested in other battles that are already a good distance from a save point, and if you fail then you'll have to restart from your last save. The same is true of boss battles, an archaic bit of punishment that really saps your momentum while you painstakingly retrace your steps.

Despite all of the loopy paths and redundant dungeons, as well as the sudden-fail conditions and game-over screens that force you to slog onward and repeat content, and cutscenes that like to cascade over one another every few steps, this game is short by RPG standards. At about 20 hours, it's just not that meaty, even with multiple difficulty settings and a sprinkling of side quests and item creation to tinker with.

Visually, there's some nice architecture in the world's castles and fortresses, gleaming marble floors and statuary, and metalworking detail on gates. Outdoor, natural-type environments are a little muddy and bland. Spell details look very nice for your own abilities and those of your foes, with lots of powerful slashes, explosions, swirling shadows, and such. Character models are detailed in armor and appearance, and every so often characters will narrow their eyes and tilt their heads and there's a sense of very natural movement and expression. Much of the time, however, the characters' lips seem to move independently of the rest of their faces in a very odd way; lip-synching is also almost nonexistent. In fact, there are sometimes whole sentences of conversation that go by without the speaker moving his or her lips at all.

Could I have the 8-hit combo meal, please?

The voice acting holds up very well on the whole; each of the main characters has a voice that fits him or her very well, and aside from some emotionally overwrought moments, they manage to hit the proper tone for their scenes. Some of the secondary roles fall a little flat and wooden, and some of the dialogue is positively dopey. The orchestral score is mostly lovely, with rousing battle themes and background music that does its job of setting tone and otherwise not bothering you.

Infinite Undiscovery has all the trappings of a mighty adventure, but it lacks the true soul. Some of that energy is siphoned off by a largely empty and repetitious world, some of it is drained by faulty scenario design, and much of it isn't allowed real depth because of the relatively short length. It's easy to grow fond of the characters and become involved in their plight, but the narrative is only one part of the whole.

The action is fast-paced and can be quite satisfying when you're unleashing large combo strings, but there are some problems. One is the camera, which is zoomed in so far that you can't see a lot of your field of action without panning around regularly, particularly if you're hemmed into a corner. Your view is also often obscured by an orgy of sword slices and light effects from special attacks, which can additionally trigger some graphical slowdown. You can use the Y button to call for your party members to use healing spells or items, but occasionally they'll take their own sweet time getting it done, leading to their deaths. If you take matters into your own hands and have to open the menu during battle, you have to run to a hopefully safe location because the menu doesn't pause the game while you're sorting through and trying to find your favorite restorative. Another fun twist is that if you die, you have to just lie there and hope that one of your party members is able to cast a resurrection spell or use an item at some point while your timer ticks down, otherwise it's game over. Once Capell goes down, you cannot issue orders, access the menu, or do anything else until you come back to life, no matter how many of your party members are still up and running around.

In addition to normal fights, there are a few timed events in which you'll have to complete an objective while simultaneously fighting against the clock. Frustratingly, these events can be nested in other battles that are already a good distance from a save point, and if you fail then you'll have to restart from your last save. The same is true of boss battles, an archaic bit of punishment that really saps your momentum while you painstakingly retrace your steps.

Despite all of the loopy paths and redundant dungeons, as well as the sudden-fail conditions and game-over screens that force you to slog onward and repeat content, and cutscenes that like to cascade over one another every few steps, this game is short by RPG standards. At about 20 hours, it's just not that meaty, even with multiple difficulty settings and a sprinkling of side quests and item creation to tinker with.

Visually, there's some nice architecture in the world's castles and fortresses, gleaming marble floors and statuary, and metalworking detail on gates. Outdoor, natural-type environments are a little muddy and bland. Spell details look very nice for your own abilities and those of your foes, with lots of powerful slashes, explosions, swirling shadows, and such. Character models are detailed in armor and appearance, and every so often characters will narrow their eyes and tilt their heads and there's a sense of very natural movement and expression. Much of the time, however, the characters' lips seem to move independently of the rest of their faces in a very odd way; lip-synching is also almost nonexistent. In fact, there are sometimes whole sentences of conversation that go by without the speaker moving his or her lips at all.

The voice acting holds up very well on the whole; each of the main characters has a voice that fits him or her very well, and aside from some emotionally overwrought moments, they manage to hit the proper tone for their scenes. Some of the secondary roles fall a little flat and wooden, and some of the dialogue is positively dopey. The orchestral score is mostly lovely, with rousing battle themes and background music that does its job of setting tone and otherwise not bothering you.

Infinite Undiscovery has all the trappings of a mighty adventure, but it lacks the true soul. Some of that energy is siphoned off by a largely empty and repetitious world, some of it is drained by faulty scenario design, and much of it isn't allowed real depth because of the relatively short length. It's easy to grow fond of the characters and become involved in their plight, but the narrative is only one part of the whole.

The Good
Detailed character models and world architecture
Characters and their stories are engaging
Fast-paced battles with spiffy-looking special moves
The Bad
Gameworld is lonely and bland
Too much repetition
Short and lacking in depth for an RPG
6.5
Fair
About GameSpot's Reviews

About the Author

Discussion

17 comments
Leboyo56
Leboyo56

Tri-Ace has the most cult-hit RPG's from just about any developer I've seen. They made the fan-favorites Star Ocean and Valkyrie Profile series, Radiata Stories, Infinite Undiscovery, and Resonance of Fate. Atlus and NIS come close, but they're publishers. 

GunBladeHero
GunBladeHero

Cool! Didn't knew they added a feature to post comments on reviews!

chimera1984
chimera1984

@ casker...maybe if you actually clicked the full review details you would see what your missing. top left "more details" then "full game details"

Casker
Casker

I don't really care that there is no score posted, lately it seems you can't trust anything anyone says. Which makes sence reviews are nicing but personal opinion. The only thing I miss, is the pros and cons list, you could tell a lot about the game just by reading those and make up your own mind on it.

guthwulf_de
guthwulf_de

Why does it say review on my updates page, but when I click on review I don't see the actual review? That doesn't make any sense. Why doesn't it say stripped-down-feed-exerpt instead? Why do I always have to dig for a score. That was much better before the update. A time when clicking on "review" really brought you there. I'm still going to buy the game though. Oh and nice to see a review from Bethany, I always enjoy reading them.

jazzyn20
jazzyn20

Seems STUPID not having the review score on the review page...Maybe they'll read this and realise their being dumb!

AdrianWrz
AdrianWrz

Playing the game right now i give this game 8/10 The story is interesting, and visuals are pretty good also. Only bad part i see is sometimes u get a scene without voice and than a next scene with voice... other than that i am enjoying the game for past 9 hours ;)

AdrianWrz
AdrianWrz

Playing the game right now i give this game 8/10 The story is interesting, and visuals are pretty good also. Only bad part i see is sometimes u get a scene without voice and than a next scene with voice... other than that i am enjoying the game for past 9 hours ;)

casualtyk
casualtyk

After a bit of digging, I found that they rated it 6.5

Telekenesis123
Telekenesis123

Well I have Tales of Vesperia right now and I gotta say im not ery impressed with it at all, it takes no risks and is strictly by the books...and it gets a 8.5. Then too human gets a 5.5. You know who I trust, myself, becuase I hae damn fine opinions thanks. I haven't played this yet, but we will see.

jbot666
jbot666

Hmph, nice review actually. It felt...honest, not cluttered with ridiculous badges or over-hyped evaluation. A far cry from reviews on this site a few months ago. While I'm a bit disappointed it got a 6.5 here I'm still psyched for the game.

dentedskillet
dentedskillet

While the review isn't too great, I am still grabbing this game tomorrow after work. I am really looking forward to a Square game on the 360. Also, I feel I have to buy it if for no other reason, to make Microsoft and Square realize they need to keep putting RPGs on the system.

LostBlade
LostBlade

And this game scores a .............. 10? 100? 1,000,000? Will we ever know?

ShockG707
ShockG707

Again with this? Where is the review score Gspot?...I will not be ignored. *twitch*

SpYkz101
SpYkz101

@AdrianWrz I would also have given this an 8, great gameplay, engaging story and colorful cutscenes

Infinite Undiscovery More Info

  • First Released
    • Xbox 360
    Infinite Undiscovery is a role-playing game exclusive to the Xbox 360.
    7.4
    Average User RatingOut of 1665 User Ratings
    Please Sign In to rate Infinite Undiscovery
    Developed by:
    Tri-Ace
    Published by:
    Square Enix
    Genres:
    Role-Playing
    Content is generally suitable for ages 13 and up. May contain violence, suggestive themes, crude humor, minimal blood, simulated gambling and/or infrequent use of strong language.
    Teen
    All Platforms
    Mild Blood, Mild Language, Suggestive Themes, Use of Alcohol, Violence