Play
Please use a flash video capable browser to watch videos.
00:00:00
Sorry, but you can't access this content!
Please enter your date of birth to view this video

By clicking 'enter', you agree to GameSpot's
Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Review

Eternal Sonata Review

  • First Released
  • Reviewed:
  • X360

Eternal Sonata's superb art direction will dazzle you, but a dreamy story and exciting battles make it sing.

The life and death of Polish composer Frederic Chopin doesn't sound like a very fascinating theme for a role-playing game. Who'd have thought, then, that such a game would set the standard for Japanese RPGs on the Xbox 360? Eternal Sonata is a pleasant surprise, full of joy, old-fashioned romance, and set in a gorgeous, fully realized fantasy world. It's also a wonder that the soft, chewy center of the story is complemented by an action-packed battle system that continually keeps you on your toes. It has some issues, but the game will make you feel consistently warm and fuzzy, thanks to its big heart and total commitment to its subject matter.

Even with nightmarish baddies like this guy, this is one dream you won't want to wake from.

If that makes Eternal Sonata sound sickeningly sweet, rest assured that it also possesses a good deal of maturity. We watch Chopin sleeping on his deathbed, as the clock slowly counts down to his last moment on earth. But the real story is in his mind, where he joins an alternate reality already in progress and multiple stories that eventually converge. His first friend is Polka, a loveable girl with awesome pigtails that can wield magic, but like other magic users in this world, she is destined to die young. Along the way, they are joined by other adventurers, such as street urchins Alegretto and Beat. They are also accompanied by goat herder Viola and the members of the rebel group Andantino, amongst others. Together, they unite against the rule of the evil Count Waltz, who is turning the populace of Forte into mindless slaves, thanks to an untaxed, addictive mineral powder.

It's not the grandest, most epic tale ever told in an RPG, but it's a highly personal one. Chopin must discover what he is searching for in this moving, thoughtful journey that we take with him. His travel companions are charming, multifaceted characters who develop strong bonds, including Alegretto's touching affection for ever-sweet Polka. You will care for these characters, and if their initial quest doesn't seem all that breathtaking, the passion with which they undertake it will win you over. The story also touches on topics that tie lessons of the past to current events. Blind devotion to the government, the separation of fact from fiction, social persecution, and other themes are all obviously meant to parallel our own modern political climate. The only problem with the narrative is the pace, which is broken up by narrated segments about Chopin's life and the politics of his own time. These interruptions feature photo stills of such cities as Paris and Warsaw, accompanied by Chopin's famous piano works. But the history lessons, as well intentioned as they are, just don't fit because they force us back into a reality the game does such a good job of letting us escape.

Developer Tri-Crescendo has created a beautiful world here. It's easy to get swept up in the French Impressionist color palate and gorgeous lighting, but incredible artistry gushes from every aspect of the visual design. The clothing of your party members is richly drawn, with intricate stitching and other fine details. The interiors of cottages are filled with meticulously designed décor, from textured linens to finely crafted plates hanging on the walls. Environments are spectacular, even such traditionally cliché locations as swamps or forests, which use shadows and mild light bloom to create scenes you would expect to see in a Monet painting. But all of this 2D art does come at the expense of 3D exploration. You can't freely explore every nook and cranny, nor can you rotate the camera. So there are times you wish you could head off into the rolling hills to check out every valley and crevasse but are fixed to your narrow pathway. You may also occasionally cringe at the color saturation, which is sometimes a little too Candy Land for its own good. But make no mistake: Eternal Sonata is a visual triumph and a beautiful artistic achievement.

Even the characters can't stop ogling the gorgeous visuals.

As you might imagine, music plays an important role in the game's production values as well, though Chopin's music is usually limited to the edutainment portions previously mentioned. But that's fine because Motoi Sakuraba's score is as exquisite as the visuals, using Chopin's romanticism as a starting point for a subtle but sweeping musical journey. The voice acting doesn't reach for the stars, but it is solid enough. Chopin and Salsa in particular come to life vividly, thanks to strong acting, though other voices get too syrupy after a while. Sadly, there are some scenes of extended dialogue that, for whatever reason, feature no music and minimal ambient noise. In a musical score, rests are as important as notes, but these extended silences are jarring.

Once you get beyond the glittering production, how does it actually play? Thankfully, the gameplay is satisfying and moves at a slick tempo. There are no random encounters, so you can see every monster. Oftentimes, you can simply go around them, though you will be forced into some battles (and some terrific, challenging boss fights too). Combat isn't a typical series of turns with infinite time in between, though: Eternal Sonata's system is an inventive mix of turn-based and real-time warfare that gets trickier as the game progresses.

First up is your action bar. Each character has a limited amount of time to complete his or her turn before it ends. But within that turn, you can move freely about the battlefield. Each action, whether it is an attack, a spell, or a simple movement depletes the bar even more. As your party level increases, the planning time you have decreases, special attacks deplete more of your meter, and other changes are made until battles are frenetic, tactical scherzos.

The battle system seems simple at first, but it gets more complex and thrilling as your party levels up.

Then you have a whole other can of worms: light and dark. If you're standing in the light, you have a different set of skills available to you than if you are standing in shadows. For example, archer Viola can execute a party heal when she is standing in the light but a devastating attack when in the shadows. Furthermore, these abilities may change depending on how close you are to your enemy. And if that wasn't enough, your enemies can take advantage of the light and dark as well, going so far as to shape-shift when moving from the shadows into the light. Eventually, this system gets really complex because enemies may cast spells on you that envelop you in darkness, or you might use items that surround you in a glow of light. And some weapons are more effective in the shadows than in the sun.

Then there is real-time blocking, which is where a well-timed button press can block an enemy attacking from the front or even execute a counter attack. In the later portions of the game, successful blocking can make the difference between success and failure. But it's not easy to block, so don't expect to mash your B button when you're on the defensive. You have a tiny smidgen of time, so you are constantly on your toes, even when it isn't your turn. All of these dynamics result in a constant tactical repositioning of each character depending on where you stand, where your enemy stands, whether you're attacking it from the front or rear, and other factors. It's literally the best of both worlds, combining the strategy of turn-based battles with the frantic immediacy of real-time combat.

Most of the time, the system is terrific, and the challenge ramps up considerably as the game progresses. But there are some small issues with it. Creatures cast their own shadows, so if you are in one of them, you obviously only have access to your shadow skills. This is usually a great strategic element, but because monster animations cause the shadow to also move, you could be caught on the fringe of a swaying foe, watching your available actions jitter back and forth. You could end up using a different skill than you intended or wasting some of your precious action bar on moving to another location, thereby getting less time to attack the enemy. It's also worth noting that the enemy artificial intelligence is inconsistent. On the one hand, monsters are quick to figure out which party member is casting the healing spells and will focus their attacks there. On the other hand, they don't quite know how to handle objects on the battlefield, sometimes charging right into a boulder and doing the hokey pokey before turning themselves around.

The towns and characters have musical names. Oh--and did we mention how pretty this game is?

Other frustrations are minor, but they still come up from time to time. Your journey is highly linear, so don't expect to spend any time doing side quests or gallivanting about the countryside to check out the sights. Another odd element is Beat's photography skills, which allow you to take pictures during battle and sell them for a tidy profit. The problem with it isn't the concept--because it's a great way to allow the party to earn some money--but that you can make a serious load of gold this way. So if you take the initially powerful Viola and Allegretto into battle with him, they can mop up enemies while Beat rakes in the photos. It won't take long to accumulate more funds than you know what to do with, and it eases the challenge considerably for the first half of the game because you can load up on floral powder or healing cookies. And interestingly, for a game featuring a famous composer, music isn't integrated into the gameplay itself, aside from a minigame that lets you play bits of music with various friendly townsfolk. It's nice that you can listen to music clips that you unlock, as well as the fact that characters and towns are all named after musical terms. But it's always subtext and doesn't often come to the forefront.

You might find Eternal Sonata to be relatively short for your tastes if you are a fan of Japanese RPGs. It clocks in at around 30 hours in a leisurely play-through, but it's worth noting that there is little filler in the gameplay or story. The game gets to the point with a smart, action-packed battle system and a dazzling world that will take your breath away. Yet while it may be the beauty that draws you in, it will be the warmth at Eternal Sonata's heart and soul that will prevent you from ever wanting to leave.

The Good
Magnificent visual design makes even the most mundane places look beautiful
Stunning musical score
Inventive battle system is both tactical and packed with exciting action
A great cast of warm, charming characters will draw you into the story
The Bad
Story is completely linear
Photography element makes money too easy to earn
8.5
Great
About GameSpot's Reviews
Other Platform Reviews for Eternal Sonata

About the Author

GameSpot senior editor Kevin VanOrd has a cat named Ollie who refuses to play Rock Band because he always gets stuck pla

Discussion

4 comments
Necrotron
Necrotron

Xbox Live sale brought me here. :)

daedstarr
daedstarr

Expecting a JRPG to be anything, but linear is kind of ignorant. Linear gameplay is fully expected for all games like this and there hasn't been one yet that has not been. Putting it down as a bad feature of the game just shows you shouldn't have  been reviewing this game. JRPGs and western RPGs are completely different game types and cannot be judged as the same type. Most western RPGs are non-linear or very close to it and have loads of customization, whereas all JRPGs are linear and almost always have no character creation. If you're going into a JRPG expecting it to be non-linear, you're going to have a bad time.

jenovaschilld
jenovaschilld

@Necrotron me to.


On a side note, man, can Kevin Vanord write a review. 

arjunrajshekhar
arjunrajshekhar

@daedstarr  With the exception of "story tailoring" games like Mass Effect or the Walking Dead series, isn't it normal for games to have a linear story? 

Maybe he meant that the exploratory component of the game is linear....

Eternal Sonata More Info

Follow
  • First Released
    • PlayStation 3
    • Xbox 360
    Eternal Sonata features crisp anime graphics, a lyrical story about the struggle between good and evil, and the music of Chopin.
    8.3
    Average User RatingOut of 4443 User Ratings
    Please Sign In to rate Eternal Sonata
    Developed by:
    Tri-Crescendo
    Published by:
    Namco Bandai Games, Atari, Bandai Namco Games, Namco Bandai Games America
    Genres:
    Role-Playing
    Content is generally suitable for ages 13 and up. May contain violence, suggestive themes, crude humor, minimal blood, simulated gambling and/or infrequent use of strong language.
    Teen
    All Platforms
    Fantasy Violence, Mild Language, Use of Alcohol