This game is 1 of the best mmorpg i played, and i played all of them from wow to ffix and all the others. The graphics i will give 7, the graphic is kind of dated but still looks some what nice. Sound i will give 8 nice sound fits the game, game play i give a 9, it would get a 10 from me if there was no lag. Value i will give a 10 it's a lot to do learn and if you are a gamer that just wants to jump in and start playing and get every thing in 30min then this game is not for you but if your like me and love to learn new things about a game even after you played it for weeks then this is the game for you. I love the game and will play it for a long long time.