mosaic / Member

Forum Posts Following Followers
10 10 30

mosaic Blog

8.5 for Super Metroid? How dare he!

by on
Oh, hi there. It's been, what, almost six years? Yeah, hi... I work in the accounting field now, and while it's not the most thrilling type of work, I do appreciate the security it affords. Anyway, I brought myself out of isolation to comment on something I've read on various forums. Long story short: I reviewed Super Metroid for the Wii Virtual Console some years ago and supposedly gave it a score of 8.5, and people think I'm a raging boner for doing so. Well, guess what haters -- I didn't. For kicks, I checked the original Word document I submitted. The review I submitted for copy editing had a score of 9.0 in the "suggested overall score" box. Make of it what you will. I can say that, while not explicitly stated, GameSpot's editors at the time supported an informal policy that WiiVC releases had to be judged not for their significance, but for their overall place within the ENTIRE gestalt of the Virtual Console library. Or, to put it another way: we were supposed to ding them a little for being $5 to $10 money-grabs. Honestly, I think Super Metroid is a great game, and I think the review gets the point across. Moreover, this further points to why I say readers need to READ or LISTEN to the content of reviews and just ignore the score entirely. What does an 8.5 or a 9.0 mean anyway? Other than being better than a 5.0, a number doesn't tell you whether or not the game will be right for you. Good tidings, y'all.

Farewell, GameSpot

by on
It's true, I'm no longer contributing to GameSpot. I believe CNet management let Jeff go for all the wrong reasons. I believe CNet intends to soften the site's tone and push for higher scores to make advertisers happy. I won't lie to people and tell them a game is good when it isn't. I won't downplay negatives that readers have a right to know about. And so, Frank Provo's contributions to GameSpot end after nearly 8 years. March 2000 through December 2007. It was a nice run. I feel sorry for the GameSpot staff that have to continue to work there, because they have no choice if they want to be able to pay bills and feed their families. For such upstanding people, the CNet overlords have created the ultimate soul-crushing work environment.