@JosephDMcDaniel: No game deserves to be on this list as much as Horizon. Would have been the best game of the year if not for Breath of the Wild.

Beyond that, I agree that Nier should have been included, but let's be fair, the PS4 has had an amazing year, and no matter what GS would have picked, people would have called them out for what they missed. The games they've included are all amazing, so I can't really complain about their top 5.

Gen 1: Charmander

Gen 2: Totodile

Gen 3: Torchic

Gen 4: Chimchar

Gen 5: Snivy

Gen 6: Froakie

OVERALL: Charmander obviously

@wilsondiabetes: Probably, because Turnwip doesn't exist.

@vadagar1 The game is based on the movie, not the other way around :|

8/10

@G4m3r0uTL4wZ @Eddie-Vedder I'm betting you haven't even touched the game.

Good picks, guys!

I bet it'd going to be between GW2, ME3 and Dishonored.

GOTY confirmed

What the frack O_o

Three stars. Does that mean AC3 has won three World Cups? :P