Do review of games really matter? No because gamers have different taste like movies and music you might hate one thing but others love it for example I wouldn't play an RPG if you paid me, then there others that would throw a rock at my window for saying I don't like RPG. If you base your selection of games on what somebody else say then why are you playing games for? playing games should be fun for you and if you not sure about the game here's something simple rent the game instead of shelling out 30 to 50 bucks pay the 3 to five bucks at your local video store if you like it buy it and if you don't take it back and be glad that you didn't buy it. And if game reviews matter what the hell happen to ICO?