Humans are biased.

Reviews are written by humans.

Thus reviews are biased.

Q.E.D.

Gee, let's see...

When I play CnC3:

...Rush rush rush, spam more tanks...when can I get the Manmmoth Tank...

When I play Company of Heroes:

...First and second squad on patrol...suddenly under fire - MG42 in the farm house, second floor! First squad take cover by the wall and provide suppressing fire. Second squad flank from the right and put grenades in those windows...OH **** MG nest just opened up on second squad...German infantry is counter attacking...Mortars provide covering fire, second squad retreat to the rally point, paratroopers reinforce first squad with satchel charge...Tiger sighted 11 o'clock, paratroopers fire recoilless rifle tries to distract the Tiger, while Johnson and his gang tires to sneak around and put sticky bombs in the engine...volksgrenadiers run under heavy BAR fire, while grenadiers manage to dig in around the Tiger and lay down fire with LMG42...Johnson got stuck...requesting aerial bombardment on enemy position...(BOOM and body parts flying everywhere)...Tiger commander cries foul in the radio - he just had a new paint job done this morning...lol...

Company of Heroes no question, it's just more entertaining than CnC3...