Forum Posts Following Followers
4396 281 17297

On the Greatness and Importance of The Last of Us: Left Behind

This post includes spoilers for The Last of Us: Left Behind.

Much has already been made of The Last of Us: Left Behind, an add-on chapter to one of last year's biggest blockbusters. Our own Tom Mc Shea has written a review and an excellent analysis of the DLC's strengths as a piece of interactive storytelling. And today in Wired, Laura Hudson posted a great piece about what playing Left Behind meant to her, entitled The Videogame That Finally Made Me Feel Like a Human Being. I just felt the need to add my voice to the chorus of voices proclaiming that The Last of Us: Left Behind is both outstanding and vitally important.

Some might be inclined to think that I feel this way simply because it's a story about women. Well, you wouldn't be entirely wrong. It's a sad reality, but a reality nonetheless, that games about women that treat those women as actual, complicated, three-dimensional human beings are exceedingly rare, so when games tell stories about women, they are still noteworthy for that reason and that reason alone. I think about how many women who play games, myself included, once latched on to characters like Princess Zelda, characters whose few moments of seeming strength and agency made them appear strong and admirable within the landscape of video game women, but who, by any reasonable standard, are terrible. (In last year's great The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds, Zelda is still a damsel, more a plot device than a character.) Because it is so rare, when games do give us stories about women who aren't sex objects but people, it is something worthy of being acknowledged and celebrated. I look forward to the day when this isn't a big deal anymore, when such portrayals of women in games are commonplace, but for now, it's still a huge deal.

But the thing about Left Behind is that it doesn't need me to fall back on that argument because, gender of the characters aside, it also depicts one of the most real relationships between two of the most human characters ever portrayed in a game. And while I positively love well-designed action, rewarding gameplay systems, and all the other mechanical things that go into making games fun, I don't think there's anything more important or exciting happening in games right now than these little glimpses of the potential for games to actually tell stories about people. Left Behind does this masterfully. Within its very brief running time are so many moments between Ellie and Riley that feel more alive and true than such moments in just about any other game I've ever played. Some of those moments are funny. Some of them are sad. Some of them are sweet. We're only with Ellie and Riley for a short time, but that time gives us a glimpse of a fully realized, complex relationship.

I can't stress enough how believable these characters are. When Ellie asks a fortune-telling skull, "Am I ever gonna get boobs or what?" I thought, yes, this is it, this is exactly the kind of humanity that you never, ever see in games. That's the sort of thing that a girl her age would actually think and feel. When Ellie reads Riley jokes from a book, their reactions to the jokes don't even feel scripted. They feel real.

When I started playing, Left Behind asked me if I wanted to allow it to post to Facebook. It would only post one thing. In general, I don't let games post to Facebook or Twitter for me. But I had a good feeling about this. And I'm glad I did. What wound up being shared to my Facebook was a strip of photo booth snapshots, taken as Ellie and Riley do one more normal thing people their age might do; they live in a devastated world, but as Left Behind repeatedly reminds us, they're still just teenagers. If the relationship between the characters weren't believable, this strip of photos would have been meaningless, a reminder of a time I pushed some buttons and made some polygonal figures take on different poses and expressions. But instead, because I was there with Ellie and Riley when they rode the carousel, and when they hunted each other with water guns, and when they threw bricks at cars, and when they tried on old Halloween masks, and when they listened to music, and when they kissed, those pictures mean something.

And as Tom has written about, it's wonderful, the way this relationship isn't just formed through noninteractive cutscenes but through gameplay. Left Behind is brilliant in the way that it takes mechanics that we've previously associated with fear and violence and makes them the stuff of play, things that Ellie and Riley (and you) share. It's beautiful. Left Behind exists within the limitations of AAA action adventure games, and like Tom, I lament the chapter's need to fall back on the conventions of these games and end with a climactic section in which you have to kill a bunch of dudes. But I also appreciate how Left Behind so often takes its own mechanics and presents them to us in contexts that completely change how we feel about them.

Does every game need to tell a meaningful human story? No, of course not. But the issue is that almost no games do. This, more than anything else, is what I feel like games need more of in the years to come. Left Behind is an extraordinary demonstration of how it can be done.

1 comments
OllieBrown
OllieBrown

I have no stomach for the violence that game makers and Hollywood shovels on us in this era.  Meaningful relationships are formed, amazing characters paraded out, their beauty (both inner and outer) demonstrated so that we care about them, so that we identify with them, maybe even idolize them.  Then, they are destroyed.  Utterly and completely, with no remorse, the act of which we are made to watch or worse are made complicit in because there were no other options.  Movies like Braveheart, Pulp Fiction, Schindler's List, Dancer in the Dark ... these are just a few that have defined themselves in my life by this horrific experience.  I didn't want that experience and I have come to severely distrust Hollywood as a result.  I simply refuse to see any movie that even looks like it might wander down this path, even just flirt with it.  When I accidentally find myself watching one because I let my guard down, I walk out.

I love good story telling in video games!  The experiences that stick with me are the ones with meaningful characters of any races, creeds and colors, as long as they are real, complex portrayals of people I find a way to relate and video games enhance this experience (beyond a non-interactive film).  And yes, real people are evil, flawed, even stupid and bad things will happen but just as much as I don't relate to superheros and extraordinarily benevolent characters, I don't relate to the super vile peoples and actions either.

Where then should I put The Last of Us?  Hollywood has left me guarded and gun shy.  I don't want to grow to love a character that moments later will be forced to bash someones brains out in incredible photo-realistic glory.  People who's opinions I generally agree with (yours included) have sung its praises for a while now.  The addition of this DLC chapter has really pushed this praise to a fever pitch.  I know what I'm getting myself into with this game.  I've seen the unbelievably senseless violence that you are not just made to watch but forced to perpetrate just to advance in the game.  I do not want to devalue human life so much that I can sit through that without squirming, without setting down the controller and walking away.  Such an experience seems fundamentally incompatible with the praise everyone levels on this story.  I'm sure I will one day experience The Last of Us first hand and draw my own conclusions.

For now, I will stick with environmental storytelling experiences.  The wordless or characterless experiences of thatgamecompany and The Chinese Room have heaped wonderfully liberating and positive experiences into their gameplay, experiences that make me revel in the human condition, not beat it into a bloody stump.  Naughty Dog has not won me over and I'm sad that I miss an experience like this because of it.