Also, is being an "old" game really a criticism? It sounds like either grasping for straws to fanboy as hard as possible or being one of those modern snobs everyone thinks is cool these days.
Hell I still have my N64 and PS2 hooked up to play the classics, can't beat some of those gems.
Games with Gold, while generally older titles, is worthwhile because you will always own the games. PS+ is worthwhile because of the sheer quantity and general quality of content, but it's a bigger negative that you don't get to keep the games because even if you stay subscribed, once that console is no longer supported, it's byebye to all those games.
tl;dr both are worthwhile for what they offer, stop being stupid.
RepoxMan1225's comments