I'm tired of saving the world and somehow being an "alpha" character in games. I want to be meat just wandering along and really earning the title, not just being lucky and being in the right place in the right time to make me special. Many games have that that problem IMO, making the player somehow better than the other characters.
It's sad to see games die with hardware. I will really miss Red Dead Redemption. Ok, I could just keep the system and the dicss, but that will take a lot of room and I don't want to start stacking consoles just for a few games. It will take a lot of time till streaming will be available worldwide, so there is nothing else to do, to be sad.
I would give it a 9/10 too, but for different reasons - the first time i got in a car, i was disappointed - physics & the damage model were far worse than in GTA4. All i wanted in GTA4, was to take the car off road, in GTA5, you can do it, but it's much less enjoyable, because of the arcade style of handling etc. (Possibly because of the old hardware, if you wish, you can get a frame drop easily) Overall, it's a great game, but not as great as i was hoping for.
MustSeeMelons' comments