While we are on this Topic, I wana Bring Up Beyond: Two Souls. This game does not bring up meaning consequences for the decisions you make like Heavy Rain but its narrative has been delivered more intuitively, Its Interacive Storytelling at its Finest, much more relative to gaming than whatever it was Hideo Kojima Was trying to pull with MGS IV. Which one has the better story ? Well theres no objective answer to that because they are polar opposites. So lets add some context: in this medium (gaming): Beyond wins. In Passive Mediums (like Movies). MGS wins.
Two things you have to remember Lulu, Cage hates game over screens and you only play as one character, so the decisions you make in game can't be as "fatal" as in heavy rain and still keep the story going.