[QUOTE="Pikminmaniac"]
I just reached the credits in an absolutely brilliant game called Red Dead Redemption. The only major complaint I had with the game was the underwhelming ending. Killing Ross in a duel didn't really give me any satisfaction. It just happens so quietly and quickly. It felt tacked on. It probably didn't help that it took place on a peaceful sunny day. There didn't seem to be any attempt by the developers to drive anything home. There was no emotion. It also didn't help that the voice actor for Jack Marston was rather flat in his delivery. How did you feel about the conclusion to this game?
Vari3ty
I'd argue that's because killing Ross really isn't supposed to satisfactory. The real conclusion of the game, in my opinion, is John's death - his final sacrifice for his family after a game where his sole purpose was to be reunited with them. While the credits might not roll after it, that scene is - for me - where the main game really ends. And that ending was phenomenal.
Back to my previous statement, killing Ross I believe wasn't meant to be extremely satisfying. And really, how much would Rockstar have to do to make a satisfying revenge ending? It would have to be a lot, as while John's death was predictable, it was still shocking to see the main character die after having spent an entire game becoming attached to his character. Jack's killing of Ross just felt more of like what must be done - in the sidequest, you talk to Ross's wife, find out what Ross has been up to - he's a retired man, nearing the end of his life, and not a threat to Jack in anyway - yet Jack must kill him, for his revenge (which ironically, the action of killing Ross shows that Jack will likely follow in the footsteps of John, which is what John didn't want Jack to do).
I hope my ramblings are actually making some sense - I guess I'd counter your criticism by asking what exactly the developers should have done to make the ending more "emotional". A boss fight wouldn't feel right in Red Dead's world, and a longer cutscene featuring Jack arguing with Ross would just feel like a rehash of the John/Ross scenes. John Marston couldn't escape his past, and in many respects his death was the same as Ross's - as you put it, quick and quiet. I personally wouldn't have had it any other way.
'I disagree. I loved killing Ross' wife and brother before finally hunting him down. I thought this was one of the best endings in games this gen. Also, I hated seeing John die, the scene with the gravesites of him and his wife was one of the more emotional moments I have had with games.
Log in to comment