Gears of War 2:

I don't feel like any FPS will ever get a perfect score ever again. (I know its a bold statement but the same could be said about racing games)

MGS4:

Although this game has the possibility of being a 10 i strongly doubt it for two reasons. One, just like racing games and FPS, stealth 3PS are quickly becoming all to common. Two, the whirlwind from the PS3 and opposing console owners would be nothing short of forum chaos. (more-so then it is now) :P

As for the current "10" game GTAIV witch is why I believe this thread was started..... I'll hold my tongue till i get it tomorrow ^^b

personally, I find that the weight of the 360 controller to be a drawback. But honestly, If you are coming from the Wii controller I don't think you will have a hard time with them both. If you have established skill with tilt and movement the PS3 controller might hold some familiar traits not to mention game types in the foreseeable future. One possible drawback to the PS3-C is that the recargable battery is built in so if it ever goes dead you might have to buy a new one (I think).