To start I'm only level 16 on my main so I haven't gotten as far as others but personally I would give this game a 7 maybe 7.5. The graphics, character customization, and gameplay are all good in my opinion. What I find the most displeasing is the lack of more then one "quest" in an area. From what I've seen so far there is only one quest(besides story) and maybe the odd event quest in any area. So you like reach another small town or fort and there is only one thing you can do there. So basically when you are doing your storyline quests and you aren't at a high enough level yet but you've done the few quests that are in your range you are stuck doing certain event quests that respawn every like 20-30 minutes over and over because exp from killing enemies is in my opinion rather low(and yes i know about the food items you can buy to increase exp given by enemies). Still like I said at the beginning I'm only level 16. Also I have yet to play the pvp aspect of the game but from what people are saying in the general chat the game seems to be more situated towards pvp then pve atleast as far as the end game gameplay is concerned.

Edit: Also to one of the posts above me I will admit that fact that you end up doing quests with 5-20 other people and still getting say a gold rating is pretty stupid. There was this one mission to kill a mini boss in a cave and I pretty much had just walked into the cave and the boss was killed and it gave me a gold rating soooo.... yeah. Alot of the time you acually don't even end up having to do anything because of other people. If they were people I had partied up with then yeah sure whatever but when its just random people...