Some things are good, the controls are poor, the movements too.
But :
- the controls are just awful, and some can't even be modified so I have to use a WASD set up for the sea map on my French keyboard, which is very painful. There are no key (or at least I didn't find them) to step on sides so even when you walk you kind of move like a boat, which makes fighting even harder. Oh, and by the way, you move very very slowly even when you "run".
- the sounds are pretty poor, all speeches are only written, not said.
- maps are bad or non-existing : you can't zoom out enough on the sea navigation map so at the beginning you move randomly around until you find the islands where you want to go ; there is no map for the cities so you lose some time walking around searching the key points in every city (tavern, shop, shipyard, etc).
- the melee fights are pretty difficult and in fact, at the beginning at least, you'll have some difficulties on simple 1 vs 2 fights.
I think this game could be decent if these little problems were solved, because the idea and the story seem pretty good (even though didn't play very long).