Although this game has a bad reputation it is worth a try.
Now, after the Conan craze..I found Conan to be a waste of time so, I decided to give POTBS a new look.
Once I put forth the effort I found that although flawed in some places POTBS is a great game. With a great community. I joined a Society (guild) and they have been nothing but helpful with my progression.
The main focal point of this game is PVP. The French, English, Spain and Pirates all compete in controlling ports in the Caribbean. I am not going to get into great depth on how the game picks the winner of the PVP map, but I will tell you that everyone no matter what level can contribute to the effort. Which makes it fun and meaningful for everyone.
The quests in the game do lack substance and for the most part can be skipped entirely if you desire.
The economy is in very high inflation right now which is bad BUT as long as you are in a good Society the port auction housed can be overlooked because nearly everything in the game is character created. If you need a ship find a Shipwright to build it for you. If you want to build your own ships then build the desired means to do so.
Its a very satisfying thing to build your own ships and provide for yourself as well.
I think POTBS has came a long way since it was initially released and deserves a second chance from some you.
Currently I am playing on the Antigua server on the French side by the name of Swanson Longshanks. If you are thinking about playing again or a new player send me a tell and I will get you help.