Not up to my expectations.
The good things about the game are:
1) the scenery looks good.
2) the musics and sounds fits well.
3) to add voices to the characters is a good idea.
Unfortunately, that's it.
The bad things:
1) lots of bugs; you may find yourselves with some 10 bugs in your first half-hour play.
2) the game-play is poor, not very developed and after some time, it becomes boring.
3) The game fails to provide a true "Pirate Game".
4) The game is to easy and does not provides a challenge.
5) No thinking or strategies are needed for combat as they are too simple; just keep on clicking on the enemies. {My fingers are still hurting.}
From my point of view, this game had not been tested. If ever it's announced for a second released, these should be the first things to improved.
Conclusion: This is a poor game. Avoid unless you are curious or a game modifier planning to create a mod/patch for this game.