Sign on Options
Theme: [Light Selected] To Dark»

UR Welcome

By JusticeCovert

Welcome to Under Review, GameSpot's new reviews blog. If you're wondering what kind of posts you can expect to find here in the coming weeks and months we have something in common. Truth is, we're not entirely sure how this blog will evolve over time, but in short, we'll be talking about GameSpot's...

Welcome to Under Review, GameSpot's new reviews blog. If you're wondering what kind of posts you can expect to find here in the coming weeks and months we have something in common. Truth is, we're not entirely sure how this blog will evolve over time, but in short, we'll be talking about GameSpot's reviews and how we go about writing them.

If you think we're late posting a review, there's a good chance that this blog will be the place where we tell you why. It won't be because we're unaware of the game's existence or because we're too lazy to write about it, but maybe it'll be because we never received a finished copy before it arrived in stores, or because we want to test the game's multiplayer features against the same players that you'll be encountering online rather than under controlled conditions against developers and testers.

We might also decide to offer a running commentary of sorts as we play through some of the games that we're reviewing, though we'll still be reserving our final judgment on those games for the reviews proper. We'll be updating Under Review regularly, so don't be a stranger.

Justin Calvert, Senior Editor

53 comments
_BlueDuck_
_BlueDuck_

Here's a question for anyone who's willing to hear.. why hasn't anyone, and I mean anyone on the whole world wide internet (with the exception of Nintendo power) reviewed River King for DS? Not only can I not find any reviews, I can barely find any previews or hands on either. Did Marvelous or Natsume or whomever ban people from reviewing it? Did the reviewers of the world all get together and collectively decide that the game isn't worth reviewing? Or is everyone just playing GTA IV and don't have time for a lowly fishing game?

Light_Bahamut
Light_Bahamut

Anyone else find it mildly ominous that this blog's first post's title was a weird, unfunny punkronym? (yeah, I totally made that word up)

mrkame16
mrkame16

i hope you gamespot reviews GTA4 as soon as its release...i dont care what rating it gets in buying it.

mike04
mike04

This should be good!

LozzaGS
LozzaGS

blahzor - we have PES2008 for the Wii on the reviews pile in the UK office.

Kevin-V
Kevin-V moderator moderatorstaff

_BlueDuck_, we haven't stopped, but faced with choices to review newly released titles and older games released via the VIrtual Console, we simply have to give our attention to original releases. Obviously, we aren't going to leave the Virtual Console behind, so you should expect to see more reviews of those games as our staffing fills out.

_BlueDuck_
_BlueDuck_

Here's a question - has Gamespot officially stopped reviewing VC games? Unless I'm mistaken I haven't seen a VC review posted in ages.

red_x2004
red_x2004

Well that looks like a great idea , looking forward to see whats next.

Mehfuz
Mehfuz

awesome idea - always wanted to know about up coming GS review

grafkhun
grafkhun

sweet a review progress update-er basically :D

Bart247
Bart247

This is an excellent idea Justin. Good work. :)

Gribb85
Gribb85

Great idea Mr Senior Editor.....Oooh hark at her :D

bruno_fmenedes
bruno_fmenedes

Interesting. I'm curious to see "how this blog will evolve over time".

speedjunkie4
speedjunkie4

Meh. I like to let myself think of a game, not the media. But good idea.

Caddy
Caddy moderator moderator

Awesome. I have bookmarked this now and will be sure to check back in regularly.

whitey_rolls
whitey_rolls

Looks like a good idea, since i'm curious myself why some pc games for 1 don't get video reviews and secondly why they can take much longer to get a review up, i thought GS was just phasing them out like everyone else, we will soon see!

Justinrmy
Justinrmy

Why hasn't Gamespot reviewed Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi (wii version)? Its been out for a while.

alanorman
alanorman

This is a brave decision and I fully support it. UR might become a unique feature your competition lacks. Good move GS!

blahzor
blahzor

Seeing as you responded to another user, Kevin-V, i was wondering if you knew who would be getting to PES2008 for the Wii? I'm curious to see what you guys think of it. This blog sounds like a great idea.

Kevin-V
Kevin-V moderator moderatorstaff

gmaster, if I remember correctly, Aaron is working on Hot Shots Golf right now. At the end of the day, there are only so many of us, and with staff as short as it is, there will be some reviews that get posted after the game is released to retail shelves.

gmastersexay
gmastersexay

Three weeks and still no Hot Shots Golf review. So if this blog is suppose to tell me why the review is late, lets hear it.

ocdog45
ocdog45

from the blo it looks like i will be coming here a lot

mrchiledonut
mrchiledonut

Wow, that's pretty interesting. I mean, I've heard some complaints from some others about the fact some games haven't been reviewed right on the spot. But, it's great to see this will cover that huh? Well, cool. Thanks.

majoras_wrath
majoras_wrath

Indeed, the only way I remember this is an RSS feed. Any chance of one?

BradHummr
BradHummr

This sounds like a great idea. I'll totally be checking in here periodically.

Gre4t
Gre4t

You should review Live For Speed.

dn3datomiced
dn3datomiced

Ah, excellent. Had I not seen your blog, though, I might not have known of its existence. An oversight, perhaps?

Willy105
Willy105 ranger

Cool. Can't wait. Sounds interesting to know what is happening on your minds when you put out a review.

Bamdude89
Bamdude89

I would like to see you guys do a review for NeoGeo Battle Coliseum and World Heroes Anthology for the PS2.

SeeD
SeeD

Your review of Viva Pinata is still my favorite ever!

LordAndrew
LordAndrew

Yummy transparency. :) This is a good idea.

Blaxploitation
Blaxploitation

Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 Wii. It's been 20 days already.

Elk
Elk ranger

I agree with Jake, feed us the rss. It's apparently really simple -- (syndication)

MysticDynamite
MysticDynamite

The idea is excellent. I'd love to be able to comment on the editor's reviews. :)

jakeboudville
jakeboudville

an rss feed on this blog would be awesome in the future...

JAB991
JAB991

This is great! I have a place where I can officially complain about the late reviews and get a real answer! Where's the Dragon Ball Z: Budokai Tenkaichi 3 review? I'm starting to nag already :)

JLuke360
JLuke360

We need a GTAIV marathon. Make it so.

gbrading
gbrading moderator moderator

An excellent idea. :) It will be very interesting to see inside the process of reviewing, and whatnot, relating to how the review is taken.

tuff_gong92
tuff_gong92

I like it. It will definitely allow us as users to understand the reviews process better and hopefully reduce the number of idiots who decry the review scores on the forums...hopefully. Along with PressSpotting, this seems very good.

Thorpe89
Thorpe89

Sounds quite good indeed. Hopefully won't get everyone asking at the forums then. :P

NekoTheSpook
NekoTheSpook

Not a bad idea at all. I look forward to seeing what this has to offer down the road. :)

carstairs
carstairs

Great idea! I'll make sure to check this often.

Demodocus
Demodocus

The feature doesn't suck! I mean it's good!

bigethan
bigethan

This is exciting transparency!

Conversation powered by Livefyre

Hot Stories

Newsmakers

Featured Stories

Submit News

Got tips? Send them in!