Left 4 Dead 2 faster on Linux than Windows, says Valve
By
Mark Walton, Senior Staff Writer - Reviews
Valve runs Left 4 Dead 2 at 315 frames per second on Linux; claims to have "improved graphic driver performance" under the OS.
Valve's Source Engine, which powers games such as Left 4 Dead 2 and Portal 2, runs up to 20 percent faster under Linux and OpenGL than under Windows and DirectX/Direct 3D, says the famed Half-Life developer. According to a post on the official blog, Left 4 Dead 2 ran at 315 frames per second on the developer's Ubuntu Linux machine, versus 270 frames per second on a Windows PC with comparable power.
The results are surprising, given Valve has put substantial effort into developing for Windows platforms over the past 10 years. It attributes the speed-up to the "underlying efficiency of the [Linux] kernel and OpenGL", as well as "a few additional microseconds overhead in Direct3D, which does not affect OpenGL on Windows".
Most interesting for Linux users is Valve's claim to have "improved graphic driver performance" under the operating system by working directly with hardware manufacturers such as NVIDIA, AMD, and Intel--companies that have traditionally not gone out of their way to support the platform.
At a recent presentation, Linus Torvalds, the creator of the Linux kernel, called NVIDIA the "single worst company" that Linux developers have worked with. He concluded his speech by saying "Nvidia, f**k you", and presenting his middle finger to the camera.
Valve's foray into Linux development follows comments from company head Gabe Newell, who recently told All Things D that Windows 8 "is a catastrophe for everyone in the PC space", referring to the locked-down nature of the operating system. "Valve wouldn’t exist today without the PC, or Epic, or Zynga, or Google. They all wouldn’t have existed without the openness of the platform".
Valve recently announced it was working on a version of Steam and Left 4 Dead 2 for Linux, though there's still no release date for either.
By
Mark Walton, Senior Staff Writer - Reviews
Writer, riff maker, purveyor of fine foods. Mark currently spends his days trying to overcome his small (large) obsession with high-top trainers and mobile games. He's known to respond well to Long Island Iced Tea, falafels, and karaoke, but not necessarily in that order.
331 comments
This just in: Shitty Old Game runs faster on Shitty Useless Operating System than Windows, says Valve. Shitty Useless OS runs Shitty Old Game at 301245231 fps, as opposed to Windows, which runs Shitty Old Game at a hilariously measly disgustingly shit 301245230 fps.
1 Like @tweezzzy You mean there's a near future where we can play 2k and Activision games on Linux? That would be lovely -no sarcasm-
1 Like I don't notice any improvements in frame rate beyond 60fps. Enjoy your screen tearing.
a 2 years old game. already running at highest FPS on windows7 . seriously whats the point of this new?
@ChaosUndivided Eyes can detect a change in anything under about 24 frames per second. A lot of bro's and general tards tend to believe that their eyes can see any changes under 30 fps, and some "hardcore gamers" aka strong retards believe they can notice under 60 fps. The real reason for a higher than needed fps is to account for framerate drops, which keeps them above the 24 fps line.
I see Windows 8 being the new Vista, I don't see mass adoption by PC users. They'll force it on tablet owners, but then again you could just buy an ipad
Gabby is upset because of the Win 8 marketplace - period. Even if the marketplace is a bad as, say, Origin it still has the potential to put a big hurt on Valve/Steam because it will be on every single Win 8 computer, something Steam is obviously not. Also, Microsoft has a bit of a history of gimping competing software through "patching"; they did this all the time with Novell client which made Novell a real pain to support. Microsoft wins. These reasons are why Valve is panicking. Many gamers are already using Win 8. Let's be clear: it's not a disaster for gaming, it's a disaster for Valve. Gabe is creating FUD and Mr. Walton is spreading it. Shame on both of you.
I don't love M$ and I have 142 retail games on Steam. No agenda here other than to offer a reason to chill if you're worried about Win 8 "ruining PC gaming."
*** Part the 2nd - Linux ***
@andrew_ribbons : hilarious.
@AshTrai thanks for pointing out that the difference is OpenGL, not Linux.
@Geon106 I wish you were right but this is just not going to happen. I've been playing with Linux distro's since the early '90s. People were saying the same thing back then. Windows 95 was the "end of Microsoft gaming" because of backward compatibility with DOS games. Windows XP was a mess at launch, cost $200-$300, and few machines had enough RAM to run it. It's going to take more than transition issues and FUD to make Windows go away.
Newell probably optimized L4D2 like crazy for Linux, and OpenGL, which naturally will be faster on Linux. The fact is, that Newell needs win7, and if Win8 succeeds, its a huge plus , in order for him to make the big bucks. I'm 100% sure if he optimized L4D2 on Win7, it will get the same framerates.
3 Like @ihateds2 "You know, the only thing keeping me from getting Linux(even as a second OS on my PC) is the fact that every single Linux user I've met was a massive tool."
Yes, so absolutely true. I know 3 and they're all absolute nerd-a-tronic losers :/ The same guy who touts Ubuntu as the future of the PC, also at the same time, owns a Toyota Prius. Say no more...
That and i just don't care for the Linux OS environment. It feels horrible and cheap, and nasty. Like own-brand Coke rip offs, yes just like that XPI tried Feisty Fawn Ubuntu and it was not a smooth experience. I had to install it 4 times before i got a stable install, the drivers were messy on my PC's hardware and some of my peripheral hardware was not supported AT ALL. Really not tempted to move away from Windows 7 for that nonsense and the quite frankly NASTY install system.
I'm sticking with Windows 7, it's smooth, fast, clean and really lovely to use. Windows 8 will be okay for tablets, but i wouldn't be surprised if something else comes along which suits PCs/Laptops better from MS's Windows team later on. For now Windows 7 is all the DirectX 11 loveliness for gaming i need!
Also that Linus guy is just pure ass.
@andrew_ribbons I won't comment on the personality traits of Linux users, but I've just installed Ubuntu on a PC 2 days ago, and it went really smoothly. It took all of 20 minutes, and was completely hassle free, and without an internet connection too.
Apart from that, I'm really not that surprised that stuff runs (could run) faster on a Linux system. More bang for your buck - or more bang for less buck rather - sounds pretty good to me.
@PhilMastro Linux is to programmable calculator as Windows is to iphone. Windows >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Linux for almost every situation, except retarded shit that the general computer using population doesnt even know/care about.
There is no reason to use anything but windows, as it is the dominant OS, its obviously great, and everything is made for it.
@Jestersmiles Watch this space, Linux is growing at an alarming rate. With Windows 8 being a closed platform I can see developers moving to Linux and personally, if they increase game support on Linux i'll use Linux more than Windows as it is a far superior OS. Plus as @jamesh-42 said, Linux is in more places than you think. Android being one which if you don't use, have used in the past at one point or another. Don't underestimate the underdog.
@Geon106 No one will move to linux because no one uses linux. There is no incentive to make shit for an OS that no one likes/uses, its fucking stupid and it needs to die out already. Windows should be the only OS, everything should run it.
@Geon106 that great an all but the fact of the matter is that very few games support Linux if any at all. So having steam on Linus will be just for the Valve game, no thnx.
@Jestersmiles I think Valve wants to get most if not all of the Steam library running under Linux. If you look at the market share Linux has grown a considerable amount over the last 5 years. I don't think it will ever take over from OSX/Windows, but I do think it will become more mainstream. @q-bert39 oh dear. That reply doesn't even warrant me spending time explaining why Windows doesn't fulfill everyone's requirements.
1 Like @Jestersmiles There is a good chance you're already using Linux somewhere (possibly in your phone, your wifi router, your television set, etc). So supporting Linux on the desktop doesn't seem that crazy an idea.
And it isn't as if it is necessarily going to cost you anything to take advantage of their work: Ubuntu is free, and you can dual boot it with your existing OS. You can also ignore their work if you choose and you're no worse off than you were to start with.
L4D2:
windows 7 + Direct3D = 270.6 FPS
windows 7 + OpenGL = 303.4 FPS
Ubuntu 12.04 + OpenGL = 315 FPS
The biggest improvement they made was just changing from Direct3D to OpenGL rather than windows to linux.
1 Like Nice to know that we Linux users have such a mature representative in Torvalds. /sarcasm
1 Like You know, the only thing keeping me from getting Linux(even as a second OS on my PC) is the fact that every single Linux user I've met was a massive tool.
1 Like Just so people understand yes, at these frames it is irrelevant for actual gaming. But when you look at these performances it basically means that they can put maybe one more zombie or another building or w/e on the screen than they can on the Windows version while running at 60FPS. Also important to note that this is more of a comparison of OpenGL to Direct3D than anything. Linux being 'lighter' is just going to be icing on the cake for end users. Which is why I'm such a Linux fanboy, because honestly right now if you're not playing the latest games and are computer literate, there is almost no excuse not to use Linux at this point. The driver support is there for most things out there by companies like Logitech, laptop cameras, graphics cards, etc. They may not be the best but they all work to perfectly and your computer will be a ton snappier and more functionality will come with your experience.
@Jebril I agree. Linux still has its flaws but has improved so much over the past 5 years. It is a great OS. I'd use it as my main OS if more games were supported on it. It is more stable, faster, easier and much more of a logically thought out OS. Linux kind of reminds me of a cross between AmigaOS and Mac OSX, true the latter is also based on Unix but I mean more for the feel rather than technical reasons.
Cool Valve, but I'm not a bird so I have enough trouble distinguishing between 60 and 80 so when you start talking in the hundreds my interest flatlines. I get Valve don't want to have to deal with the compatibility issues with windows 8 and the possibility of a competing store built into every OS but Linux is for crazy people.
3 Like Linux uses less resource so it only makes sense that it would run games better... It is something I always wanted to see... Genuine games running on Linux without using wine... Lets see how it shapes up for the future of Linux gaming!
1 Like Linux is a lot more stable than Window 7, I still got tons of bugs and glitches such as missing icons, taskbar volume disappeared in the middle of my working stage. And it store tons and tons of garbage which lag my 3d rig.
Why the hell Steam is still no where available in Apple, tell me I'm wrong, please!!!! No Bootcamp, no proxy server, no parented program, pure MAC based Steam!
@WillyChong Steam is on Mac. But Mac is a closed platform also. Furthermore Steve Jobs said a few years back when someone commented on lack of game support "The Mac will always be for the professional and not for the gamer" or something along those lines
1 Like The games graphics aren't even good enough to notice the difference. Unless you are running it on an 8 year old PC.
1 Like "At a recent presentation, Linus Torvalds, the creator of the Linux kernel, called NVIDIA the "single worst company" that Linux developers have worked with. He concluded his speech by saying "Nvidia, f**k you", and presenting his middle finger to the camera."
I enjoyed reading that...and of course linux is a crap load better then windows!
The old openGL VS DirectX S**T from 12 years ago all over again. OpenGL is faster than DX in most scenarios, is not a Windows/linux . But image quality need to be evaluated since the rendering could be different.
Heres a thought...try working on L4D3 or Half-Life 3. All this time has passed and no new Source engine? No new games? Come on Valve.
1 Like
since when Valve creating "NEW" Games??
The only "authentic" games they had is just Half-life, other than that is just popular MOD created by Community (which was then acquired by Valve.)
Probably they will release New Engine along with new Half Life.
-_-
Who cares everyone will never agree on one System/OS/Driver or anything else for that matter... So gonna have to keep developing for the open systems as well the money grabbing ones.
2 Like Really, I dont see any issue with using linux instead of windows for gaming. I mean if it really did mean better performance, and really, the only thing linux is sorely lacking is games. I mean, why not have two operating systems that you can use. I have a multi boot system, running linux, window 7 and 8, and I hardly use 8 at all.
And without a touchscreen, windows 8 is garbage. I like the idea, and could even get used to it, if it was actually designed with a mouse instead of touchscreen, or maybe options for both. Going all touchscreeny is a bad idea, I mean, who is selling tablets? Really, apple. no one else has even tapped into that market enough to make a difference. Windows 8 wont be bad on a tablet, but I dont know if it will offer what I need.
Got off topic there a bit. Linux is lighweight, supports all major file formats, is cheaper, and again, if my games run faster, then hell why not? Install Ubuntu and give it a try, then picture your steam library, and you will see, its not that bad.
This is just Newell (whose company hasn't released a new engine or game in YEARS) trying to badmouth Windows 8 because the Windows Store (similar to Apple's App Store) included in WIndows 8 will be direct competition for Steam. The truth is that Steam is more bloated than Windows these days and gets worse with every update.
Go make Half-Life 3, Gabe. Until then, please shut the [pick your own expletive] up!
If all the games on steam are made to work on Linux then I'd be more than happy to swap. Windows isn't worth the fuss!
@Pexalottle9 I guess I'm 3, plus the 10 more I know that run Linux, including my Gf and sister...yea it's such a 'hardcore' distro.
5 Like @snaketus Lol, I love that 2 people then complain about the joke... just makes it so much better.
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Content you might like…
-
Valve porting Steam to Linux
Ubuntu version of Left 4 Dead 2 already functioning, more Valve titles planned for Linux compatibility.
- Jul 17, 2012
Users who looked at this article also looked at these content items.
Hot Stories
Newsmakers
-
Xbox One has preowned fee - Report
Microsoft confirms all discs must be installed to HDD to play; secondhand owners required to pay an unspecified fee. Full Story
- Posted May 21, 2013 11:44 am PT
-
Xbox One will launch this year
Microsoft formally announces Xbox 360 successor during media event; will support live TV and Skype; features 500GB hard drive, 8GB RAM, Blu-ray drive; 64-bit architecture. Full Story
- Posted May 21, 2013 10:09 am PT
Featured Stories
-
The Simpsons writer signs on for Angry Birds movie
Emmy-winning writer Jon Vitti, who penned "Mr. Plow" episode of The Simpsons, working on 2016 film based on Rovio's game. Full Story
- Posted May 20, 2013 12:23 pm PT
-
Grand Theft Auto V premium bundles revealed
$150 Collector's Edition includes money bag, snapback hat, blueprint map, artwork, and various in-game items and bonuses; all preorders receive access to pilot atomic blimp vehicle. Full Story
- Posted May 23, 2013 5:44 am PT
-
Atari to sell RollerCoaster Tycoon, Test Drive franchises at auction
Bankrupt publisher hoping to bring in at least $22 million from upcoming asset auctions. Full Story
- Posted May 23, 2013 9:43 am PT
-
38 Studios court case begins
Arguments in legal battle between defunct Amalur developer and Rhode Island presented in court today; state claims it has "avalanche" of evidence against 38 Studios. Full Story
- Posted May 22, 2013 1:51 pm PT
-
Katie Couric acknowledges one-sided violent video games report
Network journalist acknowledges one-sided violent video game report; invitations to Bungie and the Entertainment Software Association were declined. Full Story
- Posted May 20, 2013 10:45 pm PT
Submit News
Related Game
Left 4 Dead 2
- Publisher(s): Electronic Arts
- Developer(s): Valve Software
- Genre: Action
- Release:
- ESRB: M
Recent News
-
GameStop shares slide on Xbox One preowned rumors
[UPDATE] Share value down more 13 percent today amid new reports claiming GameStop's business could be hurt by Microsoft's rumored used game policy for...
