E-mail:
Password:
GameSpot Video Games, PC, Wii, PlayStation 2, GameCube, PSP, DS, GBA, PS2, PS3, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3

Take-Two shares wobbly post-GTAIV launch

Uncertainty over buyout leads analyst to downgrade stock; company chairman claims vindication at critical, commercial response to Rockstar's latest.
By Brendan Sinclair, GameSpot
Posted May 1, 2008 3:02 pm PT

From the day Electronic Arts first went public with its bid to buy Take-Two Interactive, the takeover target and owner of Grand Theft Auto IV publisher Rockstar Games has been consistent with its response. Take-Two chairman Strauss Zelnick reiterated the opinion that EA's original $26 per share offer undervalued the company's worth when rejecting said offer during a shareholders' meeting last month. However, he also said the Take-Two board would be open to entering discussions after GTAIV went on sale April 29.

GTAIV came out this week to critical acclaim and record-setting sales, prompting Zelnick to tell the New York Times in a statement that the reaction to the game "vindicates our strategy of waiting until the launch with regard to EA's offer." On the day of the game's release, Take-Two stock nudged upward $.16 to close at $26.63.

That gain was quickly wiped out as Wednesday trading saw the stock fall to $26.24, and this morning it suffered another hit as Kaufman Brothers analyst Todd Mitchell downgraded the stock from "Buy" to "Hold." According to a Reuters report, Mitchell lowered his assessment on the belief that EA was ready to play hardball and even walk away from the Take-Two deal entirely if its current offer of $25.74 per share (lowered to compensate for a Take-Two poison pill provision) was not accepted.

Mitchell reportedly told investors that he expected a maximum sale price of $28-$30 for Take-Two shares, and didn't feel the potential reward outweighed the risk of EA pulling its offer from the table. If EA walked away from Take-Two now, Mitchell suggested the Rockstar parent company's share price could sink by as much as $7.

Take-Two shares closed today's trading down $.15 to $26.09.

Sign up now to post a comment on this story!

140 Comments

First to Last Latest
1 2 3
« prevnext »
tojo12

Sell jackasses! Maybe EA could've released GTAIV without all the damn bugs! You should be ashamed of yourselves for putting this game out in this state. It has potential, but if I can only play for 4 minutes before freezing, that's a load of crap.

Posted May 6, 2008 8:25 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-3)
zaptoman

Don't do it Take-Two! Don't sell out! We need a company that ISN'T EA out there!!

Posted May 6, 2008 2:11 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+2)
Citan76

@ Jmartin, I doubt it after this whole fiasco. Likely they would get rid of all the executives and take all the sports employees they could hire and fire the rest. They will probably keep Rockstar and maybe the Bioshock guys somewhat independent. The rest I doubt will retain any autonomy.

Posted May 6, 2008 9:53 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
jmartin1016

EA is the devil. I hope for the sake of future gamers that T2 is able to operate independently from EA.

Posted May 6, 2008 6:14 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
effthat

Please take the time to study mergers and acquisitions before you make posts like, "DON'T SELL OUT T2!".

The board is making bad choices and the stockholders are suffering for it. Not only that, but the owners of T2 (That's right! A big money grubbing corporation already owns them!) could take some serious hits, because of T2 decision. For those of you who don't know, selling stock is one of the most common ways that existing business raise funds to take on big projects. So this hurts T2 and the consumers and the stockholders and only really helps the board of directors who are already fat and happy, but figured they had brainwashed the public into buying three copies of GTA4 so they decided to hold out for more money. Aren't you glad that T2 stuck it to the man?!

Posted May 6, 2008 4:21 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
zombey1333

Man, I hope they don't give in to EA. They're good on their own, they don't need to be part of a company full of mediocre junk.

Posted May 5, 2008 6:19 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
GeigerdolylWodd

Online Multiplayerwise? This is what Saints Row' should have been like. Team Deathmatch in particular having the whole city at your disposal, the other NPCs driving their cars or walking, the police present (if the option's turned on), and no mysterious warping...

Posted May 5, 2008 4:55 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+1)
-Raiden-

yes, its nice to see EA down:-)

Posted May 4, 2008 3:02 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-3)
Dryker

Never having caught the GTA bug, I bought this game strictly over the hype and generally positive consensus. I am glad I did. This is one of the most amazing gaming experiences I have ever had. It is a collection of so many finely tuned and honed tidbits that culminates into a completely immersive and ultimately gratifying experience. An experience I truly feel would suffer at the hands of EA, even if they had all the best intentions. They're TOO big and have too many outside forces affecting their decisions. The first change would definitely be to tone-down the sexuality, language, and drug use and that would be a crime. I choose not to behave the way that is allowed in GTA, but I respect its actuality nonetheless and the novelty of its experience.

Posted May 4, 2008 2:30 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
Impostorzim

I don't expect stock prices to go down. I thought they mentioned a few weeks ago that it would rocket up to $30! I really don't understand these things very well, I just really wanna play GTAIV already.

Posted May 4, 2008 9:34 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
Painkiller-jack

I cant wait to see GTA IV on PC

Posted May 4, 2008 8:53 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+1)
pourya_ahmadian

go TAKE-TWO;GO;

Posted May 3, 2008 11:52 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-2)
pourya_ahmadian

go TAKE-TWO;GO;

Posted May 3, 2008 11:45 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-2)
brain20035

I personally will wait for the PC version of the GTA IV since I don't have any consoles!!

Posted May 3, 2008 11:35 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+2)
robertino007

My biggest mistake was to pay Rockstar 60 beautiful dollars insted of Blockbuster 6.

Posted May 3, 2008 8:32 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+1)
sphinx-shadow

we just have to wait and see i am just done guessing.

Posted May 3, 2008 4:31 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-1)
Sins-of-Mosin

I be waiting for the PC version of GTAIV.

Posted May 3, 2008 3:07 pm PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+1)
SalarianChemist

Grand Theft Auto 4 really has failed to live up to the sales up, because consumers are intelligent--they don't want to risk buying defective software, especially if it is going to be recalled in certain areas.

I know I'm going to listen to the news, and I'm going to wait to buy Grand Theft Auto 4 until all the bugs and glitches and other problems have been solved.

If I feel a need to play it, I will just rent it on the weekend, which might even save me $60 since I won't need to buy the game afterwards.

Posted May 3, 2008 11:59 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-1)
otanikun

The whole point is to not sell out to the Bully *insert lulz here* whom call themselves EA Games.
Quite honestly I think Take-Two is making great moves to prevent it's self from burning up in flames, to actually take EA's offer into consideration for a minute would cause them to end up dead in the water like so many other game companies that sold their souls to a higher cause just to stay alfoat.

Take-Two is higher than this and a gimpy 2B dollars isn't enough for this great company, I'd say aim higher, but then I'd have to send angry letters to EA for several years until they tell me to shove off or something.
On a different note, since I heard the news of the proposed take over, I have committed myself to never buy another EA game for as long as I live, what does a franchise such as them want with TT or Rockstar Games anyway?
I know EA pretty much destroys all it see's with it's Midas touch, but they haven't said anything about their other games; like Midnight Club, BioShock etc...

Lets ride the waves of success on a game we had nothing to do with; was EA's mentality, well bullocks to you EA, pure unadulterated bullocks.

Posted May 3, 2008 7:29 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-2)
kaziechameleon

this is bull, why build a great company like that only to sell out. this is bad for consumers.

Posted May 3, 2008 6:52 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+1)
iwilson1296

acurev, would you rather take-two keep making the games the way they have been ( which has been getting better with every new installment), or have EA buy them out only to run the gta series into the ground the way they do?

Posted May 3, 2008 5:33 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-1)
Acurev Posted May 2, 2008 2:33 pm PT (does not meet display criteria. login to show)
seeddrmmr Posted May 2, 2008 1:07 pm PT (does not meet display criteria. login to show)
skyline7284

The Take Two Execs are whining liek little babies, just end this stupid thing already so sick fo hearing about it

Posted May 2, 2008 11:14 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-1)
BigSmitts07

this just goes in circles....its like theyre married....will it ever end?

Posted May 2, 2008 11:10 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+7)
ColdfireTrilogy

Man this is ridiculous, just do something im sick of hearing about this its about as annoying as seeing Mrs. Spears on every mag cover for 3 years .....

Posted May 2, 2008 10:28 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+10)
BigDoherz

Publishing wise EA does a good job with some games. However whenever they get any input on game development the game usually sucks.

Posted May 2, 2008 10:17 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+4)
LindBergh2007 Posted May 2, 2008 10:09 am PT (does not meet display criteria. login to show)
hooligan_apex

GOOD. I hope your shares tank even more, Take Two. I'ts your own phucking fault for releasing what could have been game of the year, but turned out to be a crashing pile of nonsense.

We are not your beta-testers!!

Posted May 2, 2008 9:41 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+4)
agni_1

I hope to god that they don't sell the company

Posted May 2, 2008 9:11 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+7)
matrixman2k

What a pity. Oh well, never mind.

Posted May 2, 2008 9:03 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+4)
kos1085

I dont think take two will be able to outlast the EA empire for too much longer even with GTA sales.

Posted May 2, 2008 8:34 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+0)
ps3thabest

damn ea if they buy T2 max payne would be done for

Posted May 2, 2008 8:06 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-3)
mysterylobster

"If ea buys T2 won't be long before we see gta wii."

Then I hope they buy them ASAP.

Posted May 2, 2008 7:59 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-1)
d3vilg0d

from a business perspective it is hell of a deal for both parties,long term for EA and good price for take2 but from a gamers perspective don't sell because we will get screwed.

Then agen EA does publish Valve,Crytek,Bioware and pandemic.

Posted May 2, 2008 7:04 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+5)
Nineball2112

Well, at least one analyst believes that it won't get any better (in the near term) for TT since he is suggesting a "Hold" strategy rather than a "Buy" strategy.

I also agree with Markharris... "The EA deal is the best offer out there for T2, and if you are a shareholder I would highly recommend you encourage T2 to sell."

And depending on how widespread this freezing glitch is, and how it affects sales until it is fixed, the share price might drop even further.

From a business standpoint, the TT shareholders ought to be concerned about the board of directors decision to not take EA's offer.

This is an interesting case study in acquisitions!

Posted May 2, 2008 6:49 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+2)
skrutop

I'm with you markharris31. The stock was inflated to EA's buy-out price when the offer was made. GTAIV's already been factored into their $26 price. This stock isn't going anywhere.

Posted May 2, 2008 6:34 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+2)
jknight5422

I've always thought that a game company going public is one of the stupidest things it can do. I don't think Take-Two should sell to the EA Borg. We don't need a monopoly running video game publishing, design, & manufacturing.

Posted May 2, 2008 6:16 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-5)
markharris31

The ignorance on these boards makes me sad. I've been saying this all along (and I have seen some of you others making note of it) that T2 shares were artificially inflated by the EA offer. That is the reason they aren't going up since the GTA release. Honestly, when you value the company as a whole, not just Rockstar, the actual share price, even after GTA, would still be down somewhere close to $20 per share. The EA deal is the best offer out there for T2, and if you are a shareholder I would highly recommend you encourage T2 to sell.

Posted May 2, 2008 5:44 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+3)
commander1122

I JUST WAN gta 4 ON PC.....I DUN CARE!!!

Posted May 2, 2008 5:07 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-2)
peeweeshift

there stock was artificially boosted due to ea helping it

Posted May 2, 2008 4:41 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+4)
Peltz999

To d3vilg0d: Dont assume that if a game doesnt use the latest "uber mega devastator" engine it cant be fun. The best of games are a perfect mix of everything from graphics to story.

Posted May 2, 2008 3:14 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-1)
lord-of-gamers

diablobasher because the people buying T2 shares want EA to buy the shares from them but at a higher price than what they payed for - its about making money - and if EA backs away - then people will sell the shares because the offer is gone - and when shares are sold - their value decreases

Posted May 2, 2008 3:07 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+3)
d3vilg0d

If ea buys T2 won't be long before we see gta wii.The name it self shud see it sell over million but the quality of the game will be an entirely different issue all together.

Posted May 2, 2008 2:44 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-3)
diablobasher

What a load of rubbish, i dont see why EA's offer should be affecting share prices at all, even if EA walks away Take 2 is still a very profitable company with a lot of good franchises, and some great new ones on the way this year.

Posted May 2, 2008 2:41 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (-5)
tyzwain

@santiagochile: Sure...and then put Mario on the PS3...because you know he'll look much better in 720

Posted May 2, 2008 2:41 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+2)
SomeFreakyGuy

I have no real problem with big buisness stuff. At the end of the day it is in the hands of the owners of the company.

I do however have a problem with EA who have a habit of beasting fantastic companies and forcing them to release mediocre sequels.

I still have not forgiven them for destroying Oddworld.

Posted May 2, 2008 1:52 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+3)
Richmaester6907

GTA Wii haha oh right you were being serious LMAO!!!!!!

Posted May 2, 2008 1:49 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+2)
cdx00

@santiagochile,

Right.

Posted May 2, 2008 12:58 am PT
Login to rate this comment
/ (+3)
santiagochile Posted May 2, 2008 12:45 am PT (does not meet display criteria. login to show)
1 2 3
« prevnext »
advertisement

Story Tags

News Features

Featured Stories

E3 2008: SCEA unveils $399 80GB PS3, God of War III

Sony's press conference sees SCEA president Jack Tretton reveal Resistance for PSP and MAG, an all-new massive action game from Zipper Interactive; PS3 video store launching tonight; full video inside.
Posted Jul 15, 2008 11:31 am PT

Newsmakers

E3 2008: Video Q&A: Carmack on 'one-game' id-EA deal

Legendary Doom founder, id lead designer Tim Willits, and EA Partners GM David DeMartini talk to GameSpot about how Electronic Arts became Rage's publisher.
Posted Jul 14, 2008 10:47 pm PT

Related Companies