Sign on Options
Theme:
To Dark

WWE's latest THQ suit detailed

Wrestling company claims publisher has been illegally sublicensing out rights it doesn't have for the last five years, wants option to terminate long-term contract.

Last week, publisher THQ announced that it was being sued again by World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE). This is the second time the WWE has sued the publisher, with the first case still working its way through the courts.

THQ said the latest dispute was over alleged improper sales of WWE games in Japan and other Asian countries, quickly adding its contention that the suit is without merit and the publisher will fight it. However, other details were sparse. GameSpot obtained a copy of the suit today to find out exactly what the wrestling federation's beef with its game-publishing tag-team partner entails.

WWE is claiming that THQ sublicensed out the rights to games based on the wrestling organization for at least the last five years when it didn't have the rights to do so. For one thing, WWE says that THQ never had any kind of a license agreement with the wrestling company in the first place; its deals were made with THQ-Jakks Pacific, a separate joint venture half owned by the publisher and half owned by WWE's toy license-holder Jakks Pacific.

Furthermore, WWE says that the licensing agreement it does have with THQ-Jakks Pacific specifically forbids sublicensing to any company that is not wholly owned by the joint venture without prior written consent from WWE. WWE said that it never received a request for nor granted any such written consent.

As for whom THQ was licensing the rights to, WWE claims it was SmackDown! franchise developer Yuke's (of which THQ is only a part owner), which handles the distribution of WWE games in Japan and other Asian countries. The wrestling organization also claims that THQ was collecting royalties from Yuke's that should have gone straight to the WWE instead.

As for why the WWE hasn't brought the issue to court before now, the company claims that THQ concealed the sublicensing agreements from it. It says that when THQ submitted package approval request forms in 2004 for a game to be sold in Japan, the publisher listed Yuke's as "THQ's regional distributor," and not a sublicensee.

THQ-Jakks Pacific has held the WWE game license since June of 1998, according to the suit, and the agreement currently extends throughout 2009. THQ-Jakks also holds the option to extend that by another five years "provided that certain conditions are met." Those conditions are not specified in the lawsuit.

The WWE is asking for a declaration that it is entitled to terminate its licensing agreement with THQ-Jakks Pacific, for THQ to give up whatever money it made from the sublicensing agreement, and for monetary damages with interest.

When WWE first brought the charges to THQ's attention earlier this year, the publisher denied them. "The WWE had been aware and had consented to the manner of distribution in Japan and the payment of royalties with respect to such sales and, in addition, had separately released the joint venture from any claims with respect to such matter as a result of a settlement of a royalty audit of the THQ/JAKKS joint venture," THQ said, later adding, "We believe we have several bases for defending any claim of breach of the video game license agreement resulting from the manner of distribution of WWE-licensed products in Japan and other Asian territories."

104 Comments

  • Shadow_Spinner

    Posted Oct 31, 2006 6:22 pm GMT

    As long as Yukes still makes the game I don't give a crap about who puts it in a box.

  • SiKh22

    Posted Oct 30, 2006 3:45 pm GMT

    : (

  • tartar23

    Posted Oct 30, 2006 1:04 am GMT

    WWE is too greedy - THQ made the franchise a HIT specially with WWE Smackdown : HTCP - WWE won't even hit the higher grounds in Video Game market if it wasn't for THQ , this is like a Stab in the back - shame on WWE , I say THQ dump the WWE brand & make a rumble street wrestler of your own - let's see WWE come up with a better money making idea next time .

  • tmack24

    Posted Oct 29, 2006 1:52 pm GMT

    the way i see it thq-jakks has made the wrestling games fun and exciting. while on the other hand aki has also did they part now if only just as an idea thq-jakks-aki teamed and made the game what would yall think then? lol just a hypothetical question. Now look at the EA games look wat they are doing to madden and live both arent pulling they weight i think if anything 2k sports should have a shot at the license cause EA games just suck. But i'd prefer thq to keep it got every wrestling game they made from ps to ps2 even the bad ones for the xbox raw series lol but thq need to keep the license

  • CENA125

    Posted Oct 28, 2006 10:52 pm GMT

    You know i don't think wwe even care about there games you know the just want the money so i dont think THQ is going to Smackdown Vs Raw 2008 which will suck because they have been making almost every wrestling game there is today.So WWE stop thinking about the money for a minute and think about fans that buy these games.

  • _Sam_

    Posted Oct 28, 2006 7:10 pm GMT

    what next

  • spiderman2007

    Posted Oct 28, 2006 3:31 pm GMT

    the games 2 this point have never been bad, just okay games. akl would be a better fit & more inivative.

  • Col-Neil

    Posted Oct 28, 2006 10:07 am GMT

    Were's my nine iron Vinces head needs to be hit with it several times

  • MartinMan

    Posted Oct 25, 2006 3:14 pm GMT

    God EA Sucks!
    I hope we don't get stuck with those idiots if THQ loses their exclusive deal.

  • ssn560

    Posted Oct 25, 2006 11:21 am GMT

    "Look up WCW Mayhem (the wrestiling game that they contemplated getting rid of the ring entirely???) "

    WCW Mayhem is a great game.

  • angelus_2kuk

    Posted Oct 25, 2006 8:55 am GMT

    Bring back AKI!

  • GrimBee

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 3:50 pm GMT

    The sneaky thing is that WWE knows that thq made a tonne of money from this, so i GUARANTEE you that WWE will offer to purchase THQ to foot the bill, or at least have some total control over something THQ does.

    I mean, WWE usually has a great business head on its shoulders, and to pass up THQ would be very stupid.

    It's all part of a bigger plan, vince isnt sony

  • thefjk

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 2:53 pm GMT

    Coool!

  • MadGamer132

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 1:49 pm GMT

    hmmmmm, it is okay to handle this, please. i don't know what's next.

  • Ebigmike2003

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 10:46 am GMT

    yea AKI made the best wwf games ever. Thats why DEF JAM fight for NY was so good, because AKI helped make it.

  • jacash3492

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 10:38 am GMT

    im pretty sick of the WWE putting out these lamea$$ cases because they need the money to hire better scriptors. WWE is a good company, but relies to much on cash, and not on entertainement. What they are not gettign is that if they sue THQ an Jakks, then they will lose more profit because at least 30 or 40 percent of some of the profits get donated to them. Money can be the route of all evil.

  • supersnake68

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 9:51 am GMT

    "No, if it WASN'T for the money he'd be a dumBass."

    very well put

  • ricsuave

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 9:46 am GMT

    "WHY VINCE WHY! its all for the money huh vince...you are a dumass"


    No, if it WASN'T for the money he'd be a dumBass.

  • UnsolvedParadox

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 9:31 am GMT

    Hope this doesn't delay the upcoming release...

  • Tony-Baxter

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 9:31 am GMT

    Give it back to AKI!

  • Gamer360_1

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 9:22 am GMT

    WHY VINCE WHY! its all for the money huh vince...you are a dumass

  • nick1500

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 8:34 am GMT

    don't care cause i am not a fan. but this is weird coz these guys did make few dam good games together.

  • Konfusion

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 7:27 am GMT

    I'm pretty much a "life is a business" kind of guy, but this is lame. Vince & co are counting the dollars here, while they are ignoring that THQ is doing them a favor, since the games were actually good, which helps the WWE for its fans. But anyway, I've already made the switch from WWE to TNA, so it's not like I'm going to miss the next game (or show).

  • The_Weekend

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 7:14 am GMT

    Aww come on, drop the stupid charges VINCE!

  • Seeker25

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 6:57 am GMT

    The Hell with EA!THQ and Yuke's are the perfect team for making the current WWE Games!How can THQ and Yukes cut off after so many successful games?This is absurd..

  • moppy43

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 6:12 am GMT

    Aww... It would be too bad to see THQ stop making WWE games... It's seen so much improvement over the years, it would suck to see it all go out the window. But I don't see them breaking up anytime soon.

  • yanike18

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 5:52 am GMT

    I think EA offered more money for the license and WWE wants out of this contract.

  • Irve

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 5:43 am GMT

    If anyone remembers the WWF sued Aklaim to get out of the contract with them. History is repeating itself ! ............. still it's the way most big firms do business.

  • metaljeff

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 5:42 am GMT

    EA is behind this.They are going to ruin the industry.Boycott their games and watch them crumble!!!

  • Mr_Saturn26

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 3:17 am GMT

    nvm, looked up AKI and, it seemed to help make the dragon ball bodokai games, and the def jam games, hmm intresting.

  • Mr_Saturn26

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 3:15 am GMT

    is AKI still around anyway?

  • SidSimelia

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 2:50 am GMT

    I think this could be settled out of court, and this could be a non-issue. I do hope that the licensed WWE games come out of Yukes or AKI development teams. I also think that those have been the best wrestling games. Also it's Cashville Ten a Key..

  • wenbin09

    Posted Oct 24, 2006 1:39 am GMT

    WWE just want more $.. i believe someone is offring more to make their game.. so that's y they wanted to terminate licensing agreement.

  • yinyang3

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 11:19 pm GMT

    bghattas, you are a smart man on a wrestling board. Until someone also agrees with what I beleive. Then, they're smart men too. Anyway, screw WWE. It's all a bunch of crap anyway. TNA forever.

  • dragthat

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 10:49 pm GMT

    tna sucks, wwe, wwe for life

  • bghattas

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 9:26 pm GMT

    If this lawsuit is just some ploy for the WWE to get out of its contract with TH*Q/Jakks and jump to EA/Aki then that is sad. While many might be thrilled with the idea of Aki's engine running the next WWE game in next-gen, this lawsuit seems pretty minor to me. I'm no fan of EA's heavy-handed style of frosting so there is some concern.

    BTW, I don't watch the WWE but I enjoy their Smackdown series. I do watch TNA but the timeslot is terrible as I'm usually in bed. However, November 16th they move to prime time so that will change. I love wrestling and hate "sports entertainment" and I would rather watch Shelton Benjamin and Chris Benoit go 60 minutes over seeing 10 minute DX promos.

  • ocdog45

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 9:24 pm GMT

    something is up for the claim to come out of nowhere.

  • wwf20112

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 9:16 pm GMT

    honestly thq doesnt do that bad of a job but they still not anywhere near aki

  • RaiKageRyu

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 9:09 pm GMT

    WWE, stop being a idiot, THQ games helped you.

  • dmn_link

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 8:14 pm GMT

    nintendorocks wrote:
    "If THQ has been doing this for five years, why wasn't this suit filed five years ago? Seems fishy to me." They said why.

    "As for why the WWE hasn't brought the issue to court before now, the company claims that THQ concealed the sublicensing agreements from it."

  • nintendorocks

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:57 pm GMT

    If THQ has been doing this for five years, why wasn't this suit filed five years ago? Seems fishy to me.

  • DoubleDragon1

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:56 pm GMT

    Yes the WWE is worth billions and they really don't need to do this whole lawsuit thing. This is all about someone taking their brand and profiting off of it without consent. I can see why they have beef with THQ. Obviously Vince doesn't need the money, this is just a matter of principle. If these charges are true, THQ's reputation is definitely in the toilet.

  • SavoyPrime

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:53 pm GMT

    If this will get AKI back in the door so we can get the quality of wrestling titles back to the N64 days (WCW vs. NWO: World Tour, WCW/NWO Revenge, WWE Wrestlemania 2000, and WWE No Mercy), then I'm all for this.

  • ashy_knuckles

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:32 pm GMT

    kells77
    "THQ is done, that is what you get for not realsing the game for the company that helped the WWE get into videogames, Sony" Yeah, becuz those games they made for the N64, Super Nintendo, and NES didn't sell worth a lick. McMahon, Madden, Mario and Master Chief owe it all to SONY. (sarcasm)

  • steelcityD36

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:23 pm GMT

    AKI !!!!!!!!!! PLEASE COME BACK AND SAVE WRESTLING GAMES!!!!!!!!

  • nellyp007

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:19 pm GMT

    to shunsleezy

    TNA is already being held by Midway games so I doubt that the licence will go to THQ if they lose the WWE one.

  • madman666

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 7:04 pm GMT

    i don't want EA, they flub every great gaming opportunity just look at Marvel vs. Nemesis and even Madden since they had the exclusive. Their stuff seems like it starts off good, then just falls short. Take it to Ubi

  • ultimate_zero

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 6:55 pm GMT

    I wonder how 2k games will do if they were signed.

  • kells77

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 6:51 pm GMT

    THQ is done, that is what you get for not realsing the game for the company that helped the WWE get into videogames, Sony.

  • shunsleezy

    Posted Oct 23, 2006 6:14 pm GMT

    Hopefully when the WWE drops THQ, they will sign a contract with TNA and dominate the wrestling game empire.

Subscribe to GameSpot's YouTube Channel

Hot Stories

Newsmakers

Featured Stories

Tags

lawsuit   thq   wrestling   wwe

Submit News

Got tips? Send them in!

Related Game

WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2007

WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2007 Boxshot
Follow:
  1. Not Following
    Xbox 360: Follow
  2. Not Following
    PlayStation 3: Follow
  3. Not Following
    PlayStation 2: Follow
  4. Not Following
    PSP: Follow
Add to List
  1. Xbox 360
  2. PlayStation 3
  3. PlayStation 2
  4. PSP

Follow for the latest news, videos, & tips from experts & insiders

GameSpot Fuse
    • Publisher(s): THQ
    • Developer(s): Yuke's
    • Genre: Action
    • Release: Nov 14, 2006 (US)
    Platforms:

    Site Blogs