Great core game, with a few nagging issues.
Gameplay: The game is very fun, whether you are playing an actual game of baseball or managing a team, or watching your Road to the Show player flourish, there is just a lot of game to played, and its positives far outweigh the negatives. A few nagging glitches (like no CPU trading and wrong animation choices) stop the game from playing perfectly, but I still think it plays superbly.
Graphics: When graphics like these are a blemish, you know you have a good game on your hands. The player models are gorgeous, the animations are fluid (for the most part), and teh crowds suck. Typical The Show, but that is definately not a bad thing.
Sound: Another positive, the sound is good. I liked the soundtrack, even if it gets old after about your 20th listen-through. The commentary of Matt,Dave, and Rex work well together, and actually have some very specific sayings.
Overall Value: Overall, this game is jam-packed with features, almost all of them fully-developed. What are you reading my review for? Go buy this game, now.