repetative...
1- in home run derby you have to watch the CPU bat and you cant skip or sim them
2- it has very repetative feilding styles and the ball always goes in the perfect spot so the 3rd or 1st baseman can reach into the crowd for it ( which is cool maybe once every 3 or 5 games not 3 or 5 times a game)
3- in dynasty or gm career people like carlos delgado break the homerun record and rbi record for all time
4- also in dynasty or GM career the players drafter become so good that there is aways like20 99 overall rated players in the free agency but they all have similar stats
the good things about the game are
1- the swing stick makes you love to hit homers or rbi' s because you feel it so much better
2- diving is fun because you must time it and if you miss it in the outfeild then your giving up a trple maybe!
3- being the baserunner is cool
4- designing a character is also cool 5- dynasty and GM career(despite their flaws) are deep and its fun to break records with guys and get into the hall of fame