Visual and audio presentation, accessibility, frequent updates, and deep gameplay and features make this the best madden
Next-Gen Madden on PS3 was ridiculously bad with Madden 07 and 08. I felt the frame rate and animations were so bad overall, that it made you feel you were playing football on a prettied up 16 bit system. This year, the animations are fluid, the tackles are incredible with MANY different animations, and the gameplay... Well, the players are just unbelieably responsive and you always feel in control.
I think Gamespot was expecting a bit too much from this title. The Madden IQ is not perfect, but after a few games, it really does adjust well to you. Also, for someone like me who doesn't understand the strategy of Football all that well, the backtrack feature is great for learning how to better approach things.
On previous installments, I would never know how to set up hot routes and audibles. This year, I'm playing like a pro, and thanks to the great commentating and backtrack features, I'm breaking down the defenses like a champ!! I even beat my veteran Madden player friend the other night!! :)
I have the Collector's Edition, and I'll say that it's a waste of your money. Stick with the $59.99 game, there's nothing you'll really use in the Collector's Edition.
The Madden Test doesn't do a good job of setting up your Madden IQ. It's much easier than a real game. Thus, leaving you with a few losses in the preseason. But, it will eventually adjust. The bluff plays (for 2 player competition) is back and works great.
Whether you're a football wiz, or a noob. Whether you have tons of Maddens under your belt, or this is your first. Whether you like football, or not... This is a GREAT game that will bring you hours of fun!!!