Easy 9 in my eyes. The combat here makes Skyrim look like you're fighting with paper swords. Wooden characters, wooden animations, wooden combat, wooden mechanics and that game gets a higher score? Idiocy.
Amalur is probably the greatest RPG of 2012. My character was so pimp, he could nearly oneshot anything, including that idiot pirate from the DLC. Owned that scrub hard. Washing his bits off the sand with ice still.